4 Best Pizza Restaurants near Monticello

Legacy Lanes Pizza • $$
901 N Birch St, Monticello

“My boys and I visited Legacy Lanes this past weekend for an NEYBP Bowling Tournament. This was one of the BEST experiences that we have had at an alley. While there were a couple of very normal lane issues, really, overall, the lanes ran and played great! When there was an issue, the owner was quick to get it fixed so that we could keep moving. The food was SO GOOD! We are so use to nasty, fried, bowling alley food and that is not what we found here. The staff was friendly, attentive, kind and overall we just really enjoyed ourselves. Thank you for a wonderful experience and God Bless you all!“

5 Superb17 Reviews
Godfather's Pizza Pizza • $
2100 S Main St, Monticello

Customers` Favorites

Classic Pizza

“Love this place. It's inside a little truck stop. They serve the best pizzas. Only complaint ever is when the out jalapeños on my veggie pizza without my knowledge.Vegetarian options: Veggie pizzaParking: Truck stop with a nice medium sized lot.“

4 Good11 Reviews
Diamond Pi Company Pizza • $
601 S Main St, Monticello

“Good food, friendly staff all in a nice clean restaurant. They have a small arcade area to keep kids entertained and they STILL have the train that follows along the ceiling/walls. 26 years ago when I was kid they (Happy Joe's) had that train. Love it.“

3.8 Good15 Reviews
Pizza Ranch Buffet • $
505 E Oak St, Monticello

Customers` Favorites

Fried Chicken and Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
Salad and Pizza Buffet
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Buffet Your Way
Breadsticks
Chicken Pack

“We were here around 630 pm on 11/16/23. Servers were attentive to keep pizza, chicken and other fixings full on buffet. Main area was pretty busy for a Thursday night but overflow seating wasn't open.Pizza, chicken and salad looked good for the most part. Corn and green beans might as well not been available. They were discolored and looked unappetizing, but I doubt people eat there for these items. Servers fixed specific requests for pizzas reasonably fast but no followup with customers on asking customers how the food is, etc. Biscuits were made fresh but just margarine for spread, no jelly or anything else. I'm sure that's to keep expenses down.Senior discount from regular price is $0.56?! Check it out on website. I think that could be better. I give four stars because OVERALL, I'd go back for the food but if you're sensitive about colder room temp, high quality service, stringent cleanliness, etc you may not find it here.“

3.6 Good47 Reviews
Loading...

Enjoy More Tastes In Monticello

map Map