50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Garden City

“Great food and prices. Have some specialty items you can't find elsewhere. Plus their Philly cheese steak is amazing!

September 2025:
Took home a spicy bite pizza and again was well worth it. We added chicken but honestly it doesn't need it.“

“I went with my friend for Happy Hour! The margarita I had was excellent! Well balanced flavor! I also had the meatballs as an appetizer. They were perfectly spicy, held together perfectly, size was perfect too! (Yes it does deserve to have 3 “perfect” descriptions). I can’t remember the name of the salad I had, but I told many people that it had a White Balsamic Dressing, it was light and bright, veggies were cool and crispy. I can’t wait to go back! 10/10 will have again!“

“Fun, decent food, cold inside tho 🥶🥶🥶“

“Awesome scenery! Awesome staff! Awesome food!!“

“A family favorite!!! In fact, I chose to celebrate Mother’s Day at 3 Wood Pizza and Pub and it didn’t disappoint. Exceptional service, incredible pizza, and to top it off…I was handed a Mother’s Day Rose before leaving. Thanks for your tireless dedication for excellence! Much appreciated!“

“The food is very good. We have tried pizza and salads and both were fresh and very tastey. The on-line ordering is horrible. Yesterday we placed a to go order at 3 pm and was told that it would not be ready to pick up until 7 pm, 4 hours later. That is not unusual and sometimes they stop on-line ordering several hours before closing. They either need more ovens, a better system or discontinue take out orders because on-line ordering for take out is very frustrating and annoying.“

“Favorite Pizza in the Valley“

“We visited Margherita Pizza for the first time tonight. Seeing a wood fired oven in a pizza restaurant is a good first sign. A friendly, personable staff is the second. Tasting a fresh salad, refreshing Italian soda, and delicious pizza (in a style very similar to what we had in Italy) sealed the deal for us! They just gained two more loyal customers.“

“Favorite Pizza in the Valley“

“we are visiting from Utah for a few days. we randomly chose to go to Romio's for dinner. what a great choice! we ordered Greek platter. there was enough food there for two of us. our food came out to us nice and hot and absolutely delicious! we were so full that we had to take our tiramisu to go. our waiter was very attentive, friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. we highly recommend Romio's. we' ll be back the next time we come to Boise. Mike and Chris Quick“

“a great pup and differentiated service“

“Good amazing!!! Order puf n stuff perfect starter pizza so good!!! Salads so big“

“Super friendly staff, the pizza was done on time, and on top of that the pizza is great. I don’t think you can find a better place in Boise!“

“I have been here with my kiddos but we are from out of town, so I had to return with my entire family to make another great experience & to make great memories! Highly recommend best experience & best pizza I have ever ate.“

“My Family visited Proper Pizza for the 1st time tonight. The best thin crust pizza in the valley. The man who served us was so friendly and nice. We will be back!“

“Favorite Pizza in the Valley“

“Best white slice in Idaho!!!!!“

“while I love Uncle Bob's probably should have prepared for the Halloween rush better. I ordered at 2:30 for pick up at 5:15, got there and was told it would be an additional 20 to 30 minutes. I did feel bad for the staff because people were angry. Just a suggestion for next year!“

“This is easily one of my favorite pizza places in the boise area. Its that delicious fresh pizza by the slice. I return here frequently when I work in the area. These guys are a well oiled pizza machine and they do some good specials too. Go get you some!“

“Idaho pizza makes the best crust! We just ordered their 'two topping' special with mushrooms and chopped garlic - awesome combo and you could really enjoy the flavors of this pizza. Try them - this was the Eagle location!“

“amazing pizza super awesome staff“

“Excellent pizza and family owned service I highly recommend this restaurant“

“Really tasty pizza with lots of different interesting combinations. The joyride was a flavor explosion and the g willikins was overflowing with pepperoni. Generous portions, beautiful atmosphere, and tasty dough makes this a top 5 pizza spot in Idaho.“

“Pizza Twist ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Pizza Twist is an international pizza chain that started in Sacramento, California. It was originally known as Chicago’s Pizza with a Twist. Today, they have 103 locations. Like most pizza chains, Pizza Twist uses frozen, pre-formed dough. Known for using locally sourced ingredients and premium quality GMO-free meat, Pizza Twist offers traditional and Indian-influenced pizzas. They have Vegetarian, Vegan, Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Egg-Free, and Halal options On 7/1/23, I tried Pizza Twist in Boise for the first time. I ordered a small Spicy Lamb Kabob pizza ($13.99), which is a customer favorite. Spicy Lamb Kabob pizza has their signature Tandoori sauce, fresh diced mozzarella cheese, sliced lamb, crisp red onions, spicy jalapeno, juicy pineapple, fresh diced; garlic, ginger, and green chilies, garnished with fresh cilantro. My experience at Pizza Twist exceeded my expectations! The service was excellent even though they were very busy the night I visited. Owner Raj took my order. He asked how spicy I wanted my pizza. I told him that I like spicy food and asked him to make me the Pizza the way he would, if making it for himself. My pizza was ready to go in about 20 minutes. My pizza was still hot when I got home, which is about a 10 minute drive. The pizza crust was unremarkable, but the flavor combination of the toppings was outstanding! I wouldn’t normally order pizza with pineapple, but the sweetness of the pineapple paired perfectly with the lamb and spicy jalapeño. I understand why the Spicy Lamb Kabob is a customer favorite. It’s unlike any pizza I’ve ever had, with a unique combination of flavors that is downright addictive. I would definitely order it again. Next, I would like to try the Butter Chicken pizza. Highly Recommended!!!“

“Words cannot express the elation I felt after taking my first bite of the pizza from Chicago Fire. After moving to Idaho over 8 years ago, we have been repeatedly disappointed by other “Chicago-style pizza” restaurants. Chicago Fire gets it right. I’ve been dying for a true thin-crust pizza for literal years, only fulfilling my craving during trips back to the Midwest. Thank you for coming to Meridian!“

“Their Vegan Pizza is delicious!!“

“I'd classify Idaho Pizza Co as very good pizza. Not great, but definitely better than your average Dominos, Pizza Hut, Murphy's etc. The service here is wonderful- their employees are lovely and kind. My only stars docked are for the atmosphere- it does feel a little stale and lacks warmth, but then again, it's affordable and very good pizza so it doesn't need to have exceptional vibes or decor.“

“This place could be better but they refused to make it easier on those of us that have pizza stones. The instructions for pizza stones say "preheat pizza stone in the oven". Spoke to a manager once that said just bring the pizza stone in and we will build the pizza on it. Not exactly a solution. I'm not taking a pizza stone that's over 300 degrees and driving it to their store. All they really have to do is flip the crust over and dust it with flour on one side so it slides off of their disposable Pizza Pan. Or dust the top and flip it onto a new pan before building the pizza on the top. They really do need to explain why I bought the pizza stone in the first place. I bought it because I like their pizza and I like using a pizza stone but now it's a useless piece of equipment in my cabinet.“

“I wish there were half and quarter star options - I like the pizza, is it the best, nope, is it a contender for one of the treasure valley's best - maybe. Would I order again, probably.

I ordered via doordash - the reason for no 5 star review - (1) I order tomatoes as a topping, they came - sliced fresh in a separate container - please read that again - toppings, that were not cooked on the pizza, but came in a separate container.

I've had the opportunity to try pizza in many states and a couple of countries outside the US. I don't think My bewilderment would be considered strange here.

The only other reason for the 4 star review is, when I called and as politely and diplomatically as possible asked about this and shared feedback, like, maybe the website and order process should call out the fact you wont actually get tomatoes as a topping was met with - equal bewilderment - I could tell the individual listening thought the suggestions were odd

so, bottom line, if you order from here, you are probably going to get a great pizza - just don't order tomatoes as a topping thinking they will be placed on and cooked on the pizza - they wont unless you ask specifically - thank you“

“Favorite Pizza in the Valley“

“My family decided to call in for pizza on valentines day and I was selected to go pick up our food. The service was quick and the atmosphere was nice. The staff was highly helpful and quick to get me my order. The lovely to check me was Grace, she was very nice and friendly she even gave me candy!“

“We got a 20” Cheese pizza to go and it was phenomenal. Delicious, thin, NY Style pizza. We were absolutely thrilled and looking forward to trying the rest of the menu.“

“Bomb pizza, killer service and delicious Sriracha/ranch sauce!! 10/10 🙌🏻😍“

“One of the best pizzas in Boise!“

“Great! People friendly and good pizza.“

“I've been coming here since they first opened in the early 1990s. Best New York style pizza I have had in Boise. Highly recommend the Stromboli with their homemade meatballs.“

“It was our second time visiting here last night. To celebrate birthday! Their pizza was absolutely phenomenal! Definitely authentic Italian style! Thin and crispy crust. Even the simplest topping tasted so good! The salad we ordered came with thin seasoned bread. We enjoyed every bite of that salad. Then our pizza came. One rich topping and one simple topping. Perfect balanced! Tonny was quietly preparing our food in the back under chill jazz. Just like he was cooking in his home, preparing food for his friends. Had his own chill flow back there! Greeted us with smile as we were walking out. Our server was also super nice and sweet! I really hope this place can stay here forever! Already can see it’ll hold so much of my happy memories in the future! Thank you guys!“

“I was craving an eat coast style Stromboli and man I love the way they make them here. 😎👍🏼great team there too.“

“I called in online order 45 minutes in advance get there they finally found my ticket underneath a rack on the counter had to wait a other ten minutes for them to finally make it when you call in online you do it to run in grab your pizza and leave not to wait another ten minutes for them to make it it's ridiculous to have a line order if when you get there you still have to wait it's pure B.S. one unhappy custoner“

“Favorite Pizza in the Valley“

“I am from Texas and I have traveled all over the country and I have been all over the world and have eaten at many different places
The Idaho Supreme pizza was one of the best pizza's that I have had
The delivery driver was very polite and they delivered ahead of the allotted time I was given
Ya'll need to keep up the good work and give my delivery driver a raise or a bonus
I will be getting more food from you and will want the same delivery driver“

“Great little place, great pizza“

“If you want a very affordable place to have all you can eat pizza buffet this is the go to spot. Between 11-2pm they serve a variety of pizza buffet style. It ranges to about 13 dollars per person which in my opinion is an absolute bargain of a deal. The pizza is almost always fresh and if it's not you can ask them to make a pizza and they will notify you when it's ready. You can pay a dollar extra for all you can eat salad. For just a dollar that's a pretty good deal.“

“Pizza was ready on time & delicious! The online ordering Forces you to give a 15% tip. Why? I ordered it online & I piced it up, baked it & served myself & my family. What justifies a 15% tip? Forced tipping is out of hand!“

“Would not take 100 even though it came from my bank... how do you use money? I get it, have it on your card. lol. the staff was apologetic because they are told if they accept 100 bills they get in trouble. There needs to be some trust. I can't believe PM is having and overrun of 100 bill users. actually I never use them but this time I happen to had forgotten my card. I live here, I will give you my address or whatever. made to feel like a criminal for spending hard earned money.“

“Elijah is the MAN!
I just went to pick up my pie, he started to hand it to me and pulled away and said, "let me have them fix this." I said, "what, was it broken?!"
He said, "there wasn't enough pepperoni on it."
I had previously complained via the website, but those complaints go to corporate. Come to find out, my last visit I complimented him on the quality (actually picked up in the drive through, then pulled around front and went in to thank them). MONTHS AGO, was when I complained to corporate. After talking to Elijah, I sent another comment, this time a very positive compliment...right after my visit, corporate sent his boss the negative comments from months ago. Lame.
Fast forward, hey boss man, Elijah is STILL killing it! Give that man a raise! He is kind, friendly, and taking great care of your customers - he should be rewarded!
I write this so that the owners know for sure that he is an honest man, and puts his all into providing a great product for his customers!
If you are looking for a great pie, this is your place! SL NY can't be beat!“

“Not a bad choice!! If you're in a bus, truck trailer, or any other big rig, you're screwed for parking. There is 1 spot on the side of the road you can park a bus or similarly sized vehicle, but it seems that employees park in it.“

“Great service. Great food, will definitely go again“

“I went in to purchase a gift card to give a friend. I was greeted as soon as I walked in and it was quick and easy to get the card. I love going to Papa Murphy's. Their pizza is awesome (especially the garlic chicken thin crust). I like giving their gift cards as presents, I mean who doesn't like pizza!?! I definitely recommend Papa Murphy's if you want that home cooked goodness.“

“We were going for dine in and it was sort of late at night and there was not a soul around us so it was really nice. I think we got lucky because everyone was at the football game.

And as always the food was Great! They've also brought back the salad bar.“