4 Best Italian Restaurants in Ketchum

“Had a wonderful experience here. The service was attentive and welcoming from start to finish, and every dish we tried was absolutely delicious. Great quaint ambience. You can really tell there’s care put into both the food and the overall experience. Highly recommend and would definitely come back!“

“If you’re vacationing in Sun Valley or even just passing through, you absolutely have to dine here. It was a highlight of our trip, though I highly recommend making a reservation in advance as it’s clearly a local favorite and fills up fast.

The service was top-tier. Brian was amazing—he made our entire group feel incredibly welcome from the moment we sat down. He was also very knowledgeable about the menu and helped us select a perfect bottle of wine that paired beautifully with our meal.

As for the food, every dish was delicious and expertly prepared:

The Duck: Perfectly cooked with a rich, savory flavor.

The Trout: Fresh, light, and seasoned to perfection.

Spaghetti and Meatballs: A total standout. Sometimes the simplest dishes are the hardest to get right, and this was 👌.

Between the atmosphere, the hospitality, and the incredible kitchen, this is a must-visit in Ketchum. We will definitely be back!“

“I usually get my Calzone from Hailey Wise Guy and it’s the best. Unfortunately can’t say that about Ketchum Wise Guy. Crust was so hard it was difficult to chew, hardly any olives inside and overall tasteless. These 2 restaurants must not be affiliated with each other. I’ll Never will go back to Ketchum.“

“Excellent service and great food!!!!“