Tilly’s Pizzeria
Pizza
Hours:
91 N Center St, Lava Hot Springs
(208) 648-4791
About Tilly’s Pizzeria
Tilly’s Pizzeria Reviews
Share your opinion about Tilly’s Pizzeria
First problem was they were out of 12” pizza dough by noon. Do they not make their own dough? Had to buy individual slices from the display that had been in there who knows how long. Waited what seemed like forever for a turkey sandwich and garlic bread. The garlic bread was actually just cheap white bread slices that were somewhat toasted and had no flavor. Sandwich was okay but for $10 could’ve at least come with a bag of chips. Lady seemed put out when I asked for a cup...read full review
It was so good!! Three meat sandwich on Sourdough Bread with Tilly’s toppings!! Pizza, Churos, Cinnamon Roll, Fruit parfait!! Everything is Fantastic!!
Fantastic food! We had a large group of over 20 people and ordered a variety of pizza, subs, and drinks. They got our food extremely fast and it was delicious. Highly recommended!
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 8AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 8AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 9PM |
People in Lava Hot Springs Also Viewed
Tilly’s Pizzeria is a popular spot known for its delicious pizza, sandwiches, and drinks, along with friendly and attentive staff. Customers frequently praise the quality of the food, especially the pizza, with one visitor calling the hot honey pepperoni pizza the best they have ever had, even considering trying to make a four-hour trip just for more. The menu includes favorites like the 3 cheese pizza, BBQ chicken pizza, and breakfast burrito, all of which receive positive remarks, along with consistently good coffee enjoyed daily by visitors.
The restaurant’s atmosphere might be limited by its take-out only policy, though some suggest adding outdoor tables to improve the experience. Customers appreciate the care and attention from the staff, who go above and beyond. For instance, one customer received a free latte after forgetting to pick it up, demonstrating the staff’s kindness. Another customer expressed a strong desire to help bring a Tilly’s to Boise, Idaho, offering support and even proposing promotional ideas, showing the strong loyalty and admiration for the brand.
However, there have been some issues, such as a supreme pizza that was undercooked with cold, raw toppings, and a Hawaiian pizza that lacked extra sauce despite specific requests. Despite these minor setbacks, most reviews highlight the restaurant’s good food, welcoming atmosphere, and the personal care of the staff.
Overall, Tilly’s Pizzeria stands out for its great pizza, friendly service, and the community feel it fosters, making it a favorite for many locals and visitors alike.