“I would rate this as a really good place! I'm surprised it's not busy. The food is good they have more options than Subway and better quality food than them as well. Similar pricing for food as well and you get way more meat than Subway.Parking: There are some spots out front but more to the side and back of the building if needing to look for some.“
“Amazing and friendly employees and always has the best quality of food! They also have super quick food service! This subway is the best one in Rexburg and makes me want to come back each week! Always super clean and is super cozy lookin! Keep up the good work y’all!“
“Me and a friend came here after donating plasma, just to grab a bite to eat. We got there, and my friend immediately threw up. We felt terrible, but the staff, especially an employee named Nick, were super helpful. They brought out paper towels and helped properly clean it up, and afterward brought out a cookie, and helped make sure she was feeling OK. Thanks for being so helpful!“
“Riley was AWESOME!! They were super friendly and on top of everything. When I asked for extras they followed my order exactly!! I was incredibly impressed. They didn't skimp and I'm so grateful. Definitely order yourself a sandwich when Riley's there!“
“I love Jimmy Johns. I order from this location a lot. They are usually so so fast and the food is always good. Today I had a bad experience with delivery. It is graduation on campus and I figured it would take a bit longer, but my order showed up 2 hours late. I ordered a BLT and when my food got here there was no B on it. That being said, I do love Jimmy Johns and this location always does a great job! Just one bad experience today.“
“Okay, it may not be five stars for other places, but for a subway in Rexburg, it's the best one! I have had to survive off of this one for pregnancy cravings because sandwiches are not exactly pregnancy friendly and toasted is the only way I can have them. I've had the other subways' in town and NASTY! Seriously...one even made me sick. So if you want subway, this is the one you want. Just trust the pregnant lady“
“I freaking love su and way but....I have a problem with the vegetables with any subway store anywhere is when I ask for tomatoes, they put tomatoes on that are green when there are ripe tomatoes in the bin. Please dont put on unripe tomatoes for customers. Would you eat that green crunchy tomato?.... no I doubt it. Same goes for any other vegetable.“
“When I get in the extreme of my feelings - Happy or Sad - I choose without thinking twice to go to Millhollow. I love the customer service, and the sandwiches. My favorite - BBQ Chicken with everything besides yellow and green peppers - never disappoints me.I recommend this place to anybody that is visiting Rexburg. No regrets at all.Too bad my student budget doesn’t let me go as often as I would like, just so I can have the good vibes in a restaurant that is unmatched in comparison to any other place in this town.“