My parents have been ordering from this place for the longest I could remember. Lately, we have been calling but no one picks up the phone or someone picks up and we get placed on hold and we’re left waiting. Today we decided to give it one last shot. We called four times and no response. After reading the reviews, it’s become apparent that there’s also a new owner. This pizza has always been our go to but it’s unfortunate that we must let this place go.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
James D.
This is the single worst pizza place I've ever done business with. After taking the order and the money, they delivered absolutely nothing and refused to answer the phone. Stay away. They do not care about customers at all.
Jacob Cohen
If you you’re looking for a great pizza, you should go to Pizza Mania! Great pizza and friendly customer service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Jared S.
Just tried this place at night after a few glasses of wine. I can't eat pizza at night anymore even though I crave it. This pizza did not upset my stomach like most pizzas do so I was able to eat it! Most thin crust pizzas are way too greasy and upset my stomach. People complain that this pizza tastes like 'cardboard' because they are just used to greasy pizza! This pizza is on the drier side but it's very flavorful. If you love greasy pizza, do not go here!
JJ Hussinger
I found this gem of a pizza place on a trip to Chicago a few months ago and had been looking for a good slice of pizza and a Google search led me here. The staff was very friendly and we chatted about music and the world's longest running music festival which is SummerFest in Milwaukee while my slice was being heated. The enormous slice of cheese sausage and some green peppers was amazing and they gave me a rewards card. Buy 9 slices and get the 10th slice FREE!! You can bet I brought my card for this current return trip. I also love that they are open late as I wasn't able to get here until 9:30. So now that I have 4 punches you know I'm going to keep coming back until I get that 10th slice for FREE! Thanks Pizza Mania!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tanya Kiatathikom
1st timer via a “Too Good to Go” specialty slice order. Got 2 of their Brownstown slices (ricotta & mozz, sausage, pepperon. & artichoke hearts) for $6.63. We ate there since it was starting to rain. The place is compact, designed more for ”to-go” orders. 3 small rectangular tables w/ bar stools & a standing counter. It’s a no frills joint…no booze, just soft drinks, a tv & an arcade game built into the wall. The girl behind the counter, Kate, offered to reheat our slices for us. We found out she’s the owner’s cousin and just the sweetest & friendliest girl. She was handling dough to make fresh pizzas while talking to us. We were shocked at how good the crust was! Cracker-like crisp, light, and the pizza wasn’t greasy or heavy. My bf said it reminded him of east coast ‘za. She said the Too Good To Go orders are always fresh from earlier that day. We’ll def be back!! Especially to try the desserts like the churro cheesecake! She used to work at Bombon, so I’m sure they’ll be amazing!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownstone Pesto Pizza
Jonelle M.
This pizza tastes like cardboard it's terrible!! They forgot all our sauces. I would get it if it was cheaper but still it was gross
Kline Clemente
This is the pizza cook and manager u all have come to love. (I am the one who throws the pizza.) I have quit because the owner wants to play games with my money and owe me egregious amounts of money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Caprice King
They were super friendly when I called with a question and while i was at the restaurant. I moved to the area not so long ago and I’m glad I found this place- the food is great and the staff is so friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Debbie H
First time ordering here and they were very helpful when asking about choices.Pizza smelled delicious and flavor is awesome. Highly recommend this hidden gem !Parking: Difficult to find a close parking spot for pick up but pizza was worth the extra walking.
My wife & I tried this place yesterday. Delivery was delayed by over half an hour. The topping kind of slid around on top of the crust. Both of us got pretty intense indigestion. Will not be trying them again.
Patrick W
Delivery was delayed by over half an hour (took over 90 min). Delivery person just dropped it at the desk rather than bringing it up. Topping kind of slid around on top of the crust. Both my wife and I had intense indigestion after.
Isabella Z
The overall vibe of the place is really nice! The food is really good. And its just a really nice place to hang out and chat.
Julian Campos
Ordered some food here and when I arrived, I saw them working on a new pizza, a breakfast pizza. They gave me a slice to try and it was absolutely amazing!!!If they put it on the menu, I’ll absolutely be ordering
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Michaela M
Pizza is good and well seasoned - we got the Aztec and a few slices of the Brownstone; great pizzas with good flavor. Staff is kind and helpful; dough is hand made in front of you.
My parents have been ordering from this place for the longest I could remember. Lately, we have been calling but no one picks up the phone or someone picks up and we get placed on hold and we’re left waiting. Today we decided to give it one last shot. We called four times and no response. After reading the reviews, it’s become apparent that there’s also a new owner. This pizza has always been our go to but it’s unfortunate that we must let this place go.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
This is the single worst pizza place I've ever done business with. After taking the order and the money, they delivered absolutely nothing and refused to answer the phone. Stay away. They do not care about customers at all.
If you you’re looking for a great pizza, you should go to Pizza Mania! Great pizza and friendly customer service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Just tried this place at night after a few glasses of wine. I can't eat pizza at night anymore even though I crave it. This pizza did not upset my stomach like most pizzas do so I was able to eat it! Most thin crust pizzas are way too greasy and upset my stomach. People complain that this pizza tastes like 'cardboard' because they are just used to greasy pizza! This pizza is on the drier side but it's very flavorful. If you love greasy pizza, do not go here!
I found this gem of a pizza place on a trip to Chicago a few months ago and had been looking for a good slice of pizza and a Google search led me here. The staff was very friendly and we chatted about music and the world's longest running music festival which is SummerFest in Milwaukee while my slice was being heated. The enormous slice of cheese sausage and some green peppers was amazing and they gave me a rewards card. Buy 9 slices and get the 10th slice FREE!! You can bet I brought my card for this current return trip. I also love that they are open late as I wasn't able to get here until 9:30. So now that I have 4 punches you know I'm going to keep coming back until I get that 10th slice for FREE! Thanks Pizza Mania!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
1st timer via a “Too Good to Go” specialty slice order. Got 2 of their Brownstown slices (ricotta & mozz, sausage, pepperon. & artichoke hearts) for $6.63. We ate there since it was starting to rain. The place is compact, designed more for ”to-go” orders. 3 small rectangular tables w/ bar stools & a standing counter. It’s a no frills joint…no booze, just soft drinks, a tv & an arcade game built into the wall. The girl behind the counter, Kate, offered to reheat our slices for us. We found out she’s the owner’s cousin and just the sweetest & friendliest girl. She was handling dough to make fresh pizzas while talking to us. We were shocked at how good the crust was! Cracker-like crisp, light, and the pizza wasn’t greasy or heavy. My bf said it reminded him of east coast ‘za. She said the Too Good To Go orders are always fresh from earlier that day. We’ll def be back!! Especially to try the desserts like the churro cheesecake! She used to work at Bombon, so I’m sure they’ll be amazing!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownstone Pesto Pizza
This pizza tastes like cardboard it's terrible!! They forgot all our sauces. I would get it if it was cheaper but still it was gross
This is the pizza cook and manager u all have come to love. (I am the one who throws the pizza.) I have quit because the owner wants to play games with my money and owe me egregious amounts of money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
They were super friendly when I called with a question and while i was at the restaurant. I moved to the area not so long ago and I’m glad I found this place- the food is great and the staff is so friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
First time ordering here and they were very helpful when asking about choices.Pizza smelled delicious and flavor is awesome. Highly recommend this hidden gem !Parking: Difficult to find a close parking spot for pick up but pizza was worth the extra walking.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
My wife & I tried this place yesterday. Delivery was delayed by over half an hour. The topping kind of slid around on top of the crust. Both of us got pretty intense indigestion. Will not be trying them again.
Delivery was delayed by over half an hour (took over 90 min). Delivery person just dropped it at the desk rather than bringing it up. Topping kind of slid around on top of the crust. Both my wife and I had intense indigestion after.
The overall vibe of the place is really nice! The food is really good. And its just a really nice place to hang out and chat.
Ordered some food here and when I arrived, I saw them working on a new pizza, a breakfast pizza. They gave me a slice to try and it was absolutely amazing!!!If they put it on the menu, I’ll absolutely be ordering
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Pizza is good and well seasoned - we got the Aztec and a few slices of the Brownstone; great pizzas with good flavor. Staff is kind and helpful; dough is hand made in front of you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5