21 Best Italian Restaurants near Coal Valley

“yummy 🇺🇸🦅🏡👷‍♀️⛽💯‼️🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕🍕“

“Yep you see what I selected for what I paid, and 🥹 it’s 100% worth it! I got the big stuffed pizza. It took about 45 minutes which is absolutely worth the wait. Upon getting this home and opening the box, and getting the first two pieces out the first bite just made me happy. It’s exactly what I was looking for. I finally found a place I will get my favorite pizza.“

“Very friendly and attentive staff. Food was delicious.“

“Hands down best breakfast in the QC.. come every Sunday!!! Nothing compares“

“One of the few places the entire family can agree on. Always fresh and consistent. Tortellini and the garlic bread is my personal favorite. ❣️“

“Great old fashioned food. Great service.“

“hadn't been here in 20+ years. Last time I was a child! randomly stopped here with a friend to catch up over dinner. THE BEST! food was incredible! our server was polite, friendly, and helpful. so so so good!“

“Had a great lunch at Pagalo’s. We had a large group, service was great and the food was even better. Can’t beat the lunch special, choice of two items - individual pizza, soup or a salad for $10.99. We’ll be back and next time will save room for gelato. Well done, Pagalo’s!“

“Wednesday January 18th 2023 we were seated at our table after 45 minutes no one had come to ask what we wanted to drink or eat the waitress walked by us many times but never stopped then she went to people who were seated after us and waited on them we got up and left will never come back“

“We are from out of town and wanted something close to our hotel. The food and service were top notch! Can’t say enough about this place. If we are ever in the area again we will definitely return.“

“A good neighborhood restaurant. Prices were reasonable. Their garlic bread is very popular. It was good, but on the sweet side. I chose a pasta dish and the portion was very generous. I just prefer my red sauce less sweet. My fellow companions liked the bread and pasta a lot.“

“I have never been unhappy with anything that I have ordered. Their food is great. I always order delivery because I'm handicapped, and the food is hot and delicious when it's delivered.“

“We had a wonderful experience Kammi with her service was above and beyond we didn’t have to ask for refills checked up on us! Definitely was the perfect ending to our girls trip and search for a homecoming dress. Five stars across all boards! 🫶🏼 1 million put a ten recommend Kammi to be your server ❤“

“I just had to write a review of our experience, we had reservations for 1 on 3/22 we had fantastic service our waitress was amazing...we never had to ask for refills or anything the food was amazing and didn't disappoint at all. I highly recommend Johnny's Italian Steakhouse. Hats off to the chef as well for preparing our order to perfection.“

“Dough is unique, deliciously savory and always perfectly balanced with a hint of sweetness and has the perfect texture that, I think, is superior to any other similar ‘Quad-Cities style’ pizza places. The pizza is absolutely amazing, but the real treasures are their calzones. For me, it’s their eggplant calzone. Eggplant can be tricky, but they slice it very thinly, use an excellent breading, fry it to perfection and layer it with creamy ricotta & rich mozzarella wrapped in that amazing dough, though occasionally they’ll not use enough filling (so, I order extra eggplant & cheese, just to be safe.) When combined with their ‘calzone sauce’ (on the side, a perfect match, bold & rich, similar to an amazing marinara but their own take, and I think it’s necessary for the full experience), it is one of my favorite meals. I’ve had pizza & calzones in so many states and cities, so many styles and varieties, but I always end up craving Pizza & Subs above all others when I’m in the mood for that. Pro tip: add eggplant to some of their pizzas, such as their garden. Another nice thing, they actually still deliver themselves, not using some service, and they deliver surprisingly quickly most of the time, for a very reasonable fee, and the people are always kind and friendly. Unfortunately, they changed their hours in the past few years and close much earlier than most pizza places, which can often be frustrating. Sometimes they’ll close randomly due to staffing issues or things that come up beyond their control. And their website is literally years out of date, and always reminds me of how much they’ve raised their prices when I go to look at their menu... But, it’s a family run joint that makes amazing food, so accepting those things is necessary even if it means I don’t get food from them as often as I used to. Otherwise, I can’t recommend Pizza & Subs highly enough as something uniquely amazing that I hope remains open for generations to come. Just wish they were able to stay open later, and their prices went down. It’s worth the splurge sometimes, though, and their pizzas are quite loaded with toppings. 🤷‍♂️“

“Great pizza, great people, great environment, was my first time trying St. Giuseppe and Joe gave me and my wife a free small cheese bread! We will most definitely be back, as places with great pizza, individuals, and a great family environment, are places I look to spend my money. 10/10. 😁“

“Can’t say enough. I’ve had my fair share of Chicago style pizza and I’m hands down saying it’s the best. The crust and flavor to the toppings and cheese/sauce was on point. Also, ordered the traditional wings that were crispy and meaty. Would highly recommend and will be going back when traveling around here. Need to open one up in Des Moines…. Staff were very friendly and accommodating. I don’t ever write reviews but Tony’s was impossible not too.“

“Cheap prices, great food, kid friendly“

“We used Happy Joe’s for our employee lunch. The food was ready to go when ordered and tasted great. Thanks so much for the good food!“

“the owner, manager, head chef came to our table while my wife was at salad bar and asked if he could get me something from soup/salad bar (I walk with a cane and was waiting for wife to return) SURE, you can bring some soup, which he did- now where else would this service happen only at Welcome Inn in Milan!!!! Katy was our waitress and she was very polite and efficient Tks to the staff
Dick&Joni Sellon“

“I like the food. It works well occasionally if I need to feed the kids quickly and I’m short on time. The last two times I’ve been here it has taken FOREVER. I also do not think the pizza is worth the price hike I’ve seen in little ceasars.“