11 Best Italian Restaurants in Evanston

“Great atmosphere and food!“

“An intimate space, but the entrées and desserts were excellent and the service was pleasant and efficient. A modest, but reasonable wine list.“

“Quaint place with excellent food and cocktails at a reasonable price. The service was exceptional in this unexceptional restaurant environment. Our Server was excellent. She didn’t miss a beat! We enjoyed the evening.“

“Carry out was outstanding! Helped tide us over until we are all able to eat here and in all restaurants again! 👍🏼“

“Stopped in for dinner last night. Food was excellent. The gnocchi and penne pasta were some of the best I’ve had. The gnocchi literally melted in the mouth!“

“Thank you Paninos for fast turn around and great food for our group tonight. The food was a big hit.“

“Arrived in half the quoted time, piping hot and enough for two meals - not to mention super flavorful and delicious! I ordered fettuccine w/bolognese & broccoli and it was packaged in adorable packaging as well. I will be ordering again in the future for sure“

“I feel like we order often enough from this place that they seriously deserve a review - finally! They're our go to pizza place out of the many places in the area we've tried and their Arancini Balls are absolutely to die for. We love their thin crust pizza and their communication is always on point regarding out of stock drinks/delivery times. Seriously recommend!“

“Thanks To Sam, Martin and Miguel For The Great Tasting Pizza and Service!“

“The hours are great in case u wake up in the middle of night they are convenient. I love my chicken alfredo pizza..“

“I was looking forward to my first Chicago deep dish pizza and Lou Malnati’s was the place. The restaurant in Evanston has an old school pizza place feel, and we sat at a table by the window. Our server was friendly and welcoming. I ordered the personal deep dish with pepperoni and mushrooms on the butter crust and a salad. The server indicated it takes about 30 minutes for the pizza. The salad was simple lettuce but the salad dressing was so delicious - a sweet, light onion Italian flavor I could simply just drink it was so good! The pizza was tasty and delicious with the butter crust holding the pepperoni, mushrooms, tomato sauce and cheese all blended perfectly with the deep dish crust. My first Chicago deep dish was outstanding and I highly recommend Lou Malnati’s which has been doing pizza for many years - a true classic!“