18 Best American Restaurants in Galesburg

“always look forward to going to Coney Island when in area! never had a bad experience.“

“Ride & drive scenic 160 mile round-trip to enjoy this outstanding long-time Maid-Rite for their fresh made original loose meat Cheese-Rite sandwich, homemade wonderful chili available yr round, fountain Green River soda or like made into a float this time, homemade delicious pies, great friendly service, & prices!“

“Cherry Street offers tasty locally-crafted beers, brewed onsite, that appeal to a variety of palates. Great food, quick service, pleasant atmosphere, and attentive bartenders and servers. Highly recommend if you find yourself in or near Galesburg.“

“We arrived at Culver’s around 9pm, they were SWAMPED! The workers & management did an amazing job working together as a team to knock out order after order. Our food was amazing as always, thank you to this crew!!!“

“always welcoming and friendly and the food is always great“

“Pickle Fest was delicious! The bar has great food, great staff and a great atmosphere!! We will be back!! 🥒 🥒“

“We ate here for the first time before a show at the Orpheum, which is just around the corner. The food was excellent, and we were happy to see so many gluten free options. I had the meatloaf sandwich and I would have it again without hesitation. Fine crepe desserts, too. Highly recommended.“

“best ribs out there, always tender and delicious. they are always willing to accommodate us as I like mine with no sauce and my fiance lives extra sauce 10000% recommend“

“Great place for family style event. We loved the private dining option and the ease of booking and setup. The staff was friendly and ensured all guests were taken care of. Thank you jimmys pizza!“

“Service was excellent as were all four of our meals. Food was hot, cooked right and served timely. Service was excellent. We will be returning.“

“This was a clean and nice Applebee's. Typical decor. Our waitress was fantastic. The food was decent. I got the all you can eat and tried rickets but mine did not have much meat. My son's rib let's were much more meaty. I did do the battered shrimp and it was excellent. The coleslaw was not very good to me. My wife got the grilled salmon and said it was very good also.“

“I absolutely love coming to the packinghouse! the salad bar is a must have! it is always VERY fresh, and there are a lot of options to choose from. I have tried many things off of the menu. The calamari is great! You wont regret trying anything off of the menu! The jalapeño chicken wraps to the meat loaf all the way to the steaks are great choices depending on what you are craving that day! Did I mention that the salad bar is phenomenal? I've tried many of the drinks here, and I love the long islands and I especially love their red cabernet sauvingons! this place is great whether you are coming here alone, with a group, or for date night! I could really go on and on about why you should eat here but I'd love to see you experience it for yourself! Tonight I had the pleasure of Alexia and Kolissa serving me and they are both great compliments to this establishment! They also were more than accommodating! 5 out 5 EVERYTIME!“

“Great meal and service. Def in the rotation when we are in Galesburg.“

“To dine at the Iron Spike Brewery & Grill is to step into a sanctuary of reinvention, where the bones of Galesburg’s original firehouse now cradle the clink of pint glasses and the sizzle of ambition. The air hums with the ghost of old alarms, yet the space is alive with the alchemy of malt and meat, a testament to the town’s ability to honor its past while pouring a bold future. But does this repurposed relic deliver a meal as stirring as its story? I began with the Flat Back IPA, a brew that strides confidently into the glass, its golden haze promising citrus and pine. It delivers a crisp, zesty bite, with notes of grapefruit and a subtle hoppy backbone that lingers just long enough to intrigue. It is not a beer to rewrite the annals of brewing, but it is a faithful steed, sturdy and reliable. Paired with the pulled pork nachos, it finds its purpose. The nachos are a riot of texture and flavor—crisp tortilla chips groan under a lavish pile of smoky, succulent pork, kissed by a barbecue sauce that teeters between sweet and tangy. A blanket of melted cheese anchors the dish, while jalapeños spark like embers, adding just enough heat to keep things lively. It’s a dish that knows its audience: unapologetically bold, yet comforting, like a fireman’s tale told over a cold one. My companions, ever adventurous, opted for the chicken sticks with a side of gravy—a humble offering that could easily falter in lesser hands. The chicken, encased in a golden, crunchy breading, was tender and moist, though the seasoning leaned heavily on salt, leaving little room for subtlety. The gravy, however, was a quiet triumph: silken, savory, with a faint whisper of thyme that elevated the dish from mere bar fare to something approaching memorable. It’s the kind of sidekick that doesn’t steal the show but earns its keep. The pulled pork flatbread, chosen by another companion, aimed higher. Its thin, charred crust—reminiscent of a hearth long cooled—supported a generous layer of pork, sweet caramelized onions, and a sharp cheddar that cut through the richness like a siren through the night. A drizzle of barbecue sauce bound it all together, though a touch more acidity would have lifted it from very good to unforgettable. It is a dish that flirts with refinement but remains proudly tethered to its bar-and-grill roots. The Iron Spike Brewery & Grill is a place where history and hunger collide, where the weight of Galesburg’s past is matched by the warmth of its present. The Flat Back IPA and pulled pork nachos, in particular, embody this spirit—unfussy, flavorful, and fiercely satisfying. The meal does not aim to dazzle with avant-garde flourishes, nor does it need to. It is honest, robust, and deeply rooted in the community it serves. In a world that often demands reinvention, Iron Spike proves that sometimes, the old can be made new again with a little fire and a lot of heart“

“We stop in anytime we are in Galesburg !! Great food !!! Great service !!!! And Suz is the best waitress!!! Give her a raise 💰“

“Friendly staff and amazing food.“

“My burger was one of the best ones I’ve had in awhile I loved it !!❤️❤️“

“Make it a point to come here to the steak and shake every time I'm in town their food is awesome their staff is so friendly it's clean also their food is made to order so it's always hot and fresh try their dessert shakes they're great“