Ice Cream Shop · $
1 Annie's Custard & Cafe
1320 Mulholland St, Nauvoo
Customers’ favorites
- Teriyaki Chicken Waffle
- Lemon Custard
- Strawberries
- Hot Fudge
“We stopped at Annie’s Frozen Custard & Café in Nauvoo, Illinois, and ended up going three days in a row — it’s that good! The biscuits and sausage gravy were perfectly seasoned and comforting, and the Wagon Wheel cinnamon roll was absolutely unforgettable — soft, sweet, and made with love. One of the best parts was meeting the owner, who was kind, welcoming, and truly invested in the community. She hires and supports local staff, and it shows in the warm, friendly service. We’re from the South, and this place felt like a little taste of home. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town!”