Myrtle's Pie

$ • American

About Myrtle's Pie

Myrtle's Pie is a cozy, nostalgic restaurant known for its delicious coffee and pies. The coconut cream pie is a standout, and they offer a variety of flavors to suit every taste, including German chocolate, French Silk, Oreo, and a cake batter pie with sprinkles for kids. The shop also features strawberry mango and other popular options. Customers can enjoy a slice of pie, take and bake, or purchase ready-made pies and quiche to bake at home. The bakery is praised for its delicious treats like cookies, cinnamon rolls, and other baked goods. The owner and staff are friendly and attentive, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The pies are highly praised, with key lime rivaling anything in Florida, and favorites include lemon meringue, custard, and Rum Chata. The location is small, adding to its cozy charm, but the busy Thanksgiving ordering process might benefit from online ordering or a more organized system. The shop is often busy and sells out quickly, so arriving early or ordering ahead is recommended. A highlight of the restaurant is its exceptional pie, making it an ideal spot for satisfying a sweet tooth. The owner is known for being personable and providing excellent service, making every visit a pleasant experience.