Myrtle's Pie
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
927 N Main St, Princeton
(815) 915-8397
Myrtle's Pie Reviews
What I like... - nice owner and staff - family heritage of multiple generations - zero chance they don't make a flavor you want - tiny, but super cute location What I think they could improve... - Thanksgiving ordering and pickup process is understandably busy. Would be great to be able to order online, and even pay ahead of time. And a more organized process for finding your order and pickup that may help reduce the sis time standing outside in the cold.
My family and I heard about this place from an online source, so we'd figure we'd come out and try it. Once we did, I was blown away. This tiny, almost hole-in-the-wall place serves easily the best pie I've ever had. I had a chocolate cake batter pie with salted caramel and brownie in the bottom. It was almost beyond words how delicious it was. The man running it was also very polite, going so far as to help a different customer find another restaurant. If you need to satisfy...read full review
Ratings
Menu
People in Princeton Also Viewed
Excellent pies