43 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sherman

“I had been aware of Rico's since they opened but never had the opportunity to try one of their Pizzas. Now that I have, all I can say is, EXCELLENT PIZZA! Probably the best in the Springfield area! This is Pizza made by people that CARE about the Pizza they serve to you, and if that means anything to you, there will be no disappointment. If you love great Pizza, do yourself a favor and try one.“

“Thank you to Sam’s Too for an amazing carry out meal for our family Christmas dinner! The food was fantastic and it gave me more time to spend with family! I highly recommend their baked rigatoni for a large family dinners!! The price and quality are an unbeatable deal! Thank you from our family!“

“I had my order delivered so I cannot give any stars for atmosphere. I wasn’t there. However, my pizza was so hot. It was like I had baked it at home. I got it in a timely fashion. It was done to perfection. It is the best pizza I have ever had in my life thank you Domino’s thank you so much.“

“This spot is one of our favorite places for great food! The pizza flavors are amazing. The Sophia Lauren is my favorite even made vegetarian style. Yeah, they managed to make it for me vegetarian style and it was perfect! The sandwiches are loaded with meat and flavor. They have frozen take and bake items, a wall of Italian pastas, sauces, cookies, oil and dressings.“

“Best pizza in town ♡ Tuesday they have deals. Larges 12 and family 15. They also have a awards system you can sign up for. Lots of good deals when you sign up. Some people will get $3 off or free cheese bread after a certain amount of visits. They also allow you to take toppings off and replace them with what you want. It's kinda like a subway... but for pizza ♡“

“We ordered our first pizza tonight while getting a tattoo at Electric Quill!! This place is delicious to say the least. We will be back!!“

“We pick up Dillon’s for our last work day of the week dinner, almost every Thursday evening. ALWAYS excellent pizza and never an off night! Thanks Dillon’s for quality pizza!🍕“

“This was our 1st time eating at this establishment today as we’re from Peoria. We ordered pizza and a calzone! The pizza is the best we’ve ever had!!! My daughters, grandson and I absolutely loved this place! They were absolutely so kind and we felt so comfortable! Mama Rosa, she warms my heart with kindness! Thank you to all for giving us a great experience and we will definitely be back! Highly recommend!!!!❤️🇮🇹“

“We have gotten several dishes, several times from here. The traditional pizza is great. Very authentic. The sicilian special is fantastic as well. The meat ball subs and calzones are also favorites of ours. VERY Generous potions for the price. Not a bad wait. The owners are very transparent about the wait if you ask. We eat here every Friday and love it!“

“A very cozy place with an ordering counter and a sit-down dining room if you're sticking around. Despite the counter service, the staff was lovely, welcoming, and attentive. They brought fresh bread to the table, unfortunately with a small to-go cup with a small drizzle of olive oil and another of pre-grated parm. A slightly more generous cup of olive oil would have been nice. The carbonara pasta would have been good off the bat if they had properly seasoned it, but some of the extra parm and a generous dose of black pepper got it there in the end. The pizza was the star of the night. Chewy dough with really good gluten development, very nice sauce that was balanced and a nice contrast to the cheese, and quality toppings that weren't too much or too little. Was very tempted by the cannoli in the case, but I will leave it to others to try as I was stuffed. Could be a great place but needs to tighten it up a bit. Would try again though if just for pizza and to try that cannoli.“

“The crew here is amazing. The young men are always friendly and quick to say hello. My son and I come almost every week and it does not disappoint. Our order is always correct and yummy.

Kid-friendliness: My son loves the garlic monkey bread and the employees are always so nice to him.“

“Been going here for many years, old school pizza place in a residential area. Great pizza at a low price“

“My husband and I love it here! So good!! The pizza's are AMAZING!!!!! OH MY GOODNESS!!“

“The best food & service! The restaurant is always clean.“

“I've ate at several pizza buffets around the USA. I would rate this one second to the original Pizza Inn located in Brazil indiana but since that one closed in 2007 I have to
say this is by far the best pizza buffet in the United States of America. And to top it of their fried chicken is absolutely amazing as well!!! If your in Springfield illinois and want a great buffet experience stop here you definitely will not be disappointed.“

“this review is going to the GM Ryan at the south Dirksen store, i ordered two large pizzas tonight and i finally called about them being 35 mins late from said delivery time. He was very patient and courteous and explained to me that they was having a little trouble with the Grubhub deliveries. He went above and beyond explaining the situation. when we called the first time about it being late we were told the pizza was already in the car . A full 20 mins after that call we got a call from the grubhub driver asking if we could send them a satellite picture of our house because they could not find it. our house is only 5 mins from the Dirksen store. the grubhub driver should not have waited a full half hour to call about not being able to find us. it is in no way Ryan or the employees at godfathers fault that this happened. i want to thank Godfathers for hiring such a professional as Ruan to lead their store. it is because of Ryan that my family and I will continue to call and order the most awesome pizza in Springfield. please make sure this review gets to the owner Mike and the other owner as i will be checkimg in with Ryan to make sure he got this review of his great patience and service. we can not wait to order from ur store again as the food is awesome and Ryan's service was again above and beyond. thanks for the awesome food that you serve and the people you choose to lead ur team. we will make sure to keep recommending Godfathers to our family and friends as the number 1 pizza place to order from in Springfield. thank you sincerely the sanges family.“

“best pizza in town best delivery best customer service and lots of love for the community“

“Craving a smash burger served with a side of warm, family-style service? This is the place! I had the double cheeseburger with sautéed onions—made to order, piping hot, and absolutely delicious. The fries were fresh and crisp, the perfect pairing. The service was outstanding—genuinely welcoming and friendly from start to finish. I’ve heard the chili mac is a must-try too… I’ll definitely be back!“

“best pizza in town best delivery best customer service and lots of love for the community“

“Food is delicious. The atmosphere is very inviting. Our waitress was phenomenal and the entire staff made you feel welcome. This was my first time there and it won’t be my last.“

“I've enjoyed Hunt Bros. for over 20 years. The slices are a great after work snack and on a "we just want the whole thing" night, one phone call is all. Our local Marathon ladies make them less than a mile from our house !“

“Had never experienced an "Express Little Caesars" before. Was quite surprised by the freshness & the food was actually hot. You just walk up, grab whatever items you'd like out of the warmer cabinets & checkout at the truck stop cashier. We got some fountain drinks & sat inside Taco John's to eat. Was a tasty, fast, convenient & inexpensive meal for myself & 2 teens. Pepperoni pizza, crazy bread with sauce & 3 32oz fountain drinks for under $17 ?Will definitely be back if/when in the area.“

“best pizza in town best delivery best customer service and lots of love for the community“

“I went there on the day of the grand reopening on July 25th 2024! I am so overjoyed they’re keeping the animatronics! Might I mention that they were in great shape! The staff there were all really nice and welcoming! The pizza was delicious too! :) Truly a magical experience and would definitely recommend for any Midwest animatronic lovers!“

“best pizza in town best delivery best customer service and lots of love for the community“

“Got a pizza at Mario’s on Piper Glen tonight and it was delicious! I wanted to make sure the pizza guy, Alvin got a shout out! Thanks for the great pizza!“

“My name is Mike Lawrence. I began coming to Joe’s when it was still located in a somewhat decrepit house located just one door west of the building it’s now in. The front porch on that old house was loose and would bounce or sag a bit when you walked across it and my joke to guests I took in there with me, was they should carefully walk around that bad spot when we left because we’d all be heavier from having eaten and would probably fall through.

My daughter lost her first baby tooth while eating Spaghetti at Joe’s. She’s now 43 so, yeah, we’ve been coming for decades; certainly since the days when Joe Porcasi ran it.

All the food was great and, through all those years, I NEVER heard anyone say anything bad about the food, the service, the price, nothing … until now.

I guess it’s to be expected, especially in the food industry. Over time people weary of doing the same job day after day, get tired of serving the same food to the same people. Pride in performance gives way to pet peeves and personal pity parties. Oh, I get it. I do.

The reviews I read now talking about bad service, bad food, no longer being able to dine in … none of that would EVER have been true back in the day. Back when we came and sat down, talked, laughed, took in the awesome smells, and delighted when the food came. Even standing up to get the door for someone exiting with boxes of pizzas and more to take home to loved ones. Man, those were the best of times.

When we first found Joes, we didn’t go to any other shop in town. Why, when you’d found the best, would you want to go anywhere else?

We had even talked, briefly, with the original owners about opening a franchise on the east side of Springfield. Wish we’d carried through with that instead of opening a restaurant. Ah, well.

I don’t know if it’s still there, but I donated a kitchen chef statue to Joe’s when Jeff bought the place. Used to be right up on the counter.

I live in St. Louis now but, from time to time, when I long for one of Joe’s pizzas, or meatball subs, or lasagnas … and it’s only a 200 mile round trip but, frankly, some of the reviews have kinda bummed me out about doing it.

Ah, well. We’ll see.“

“My sister and I recently drove from Pittsburgh to visit our Mom and Aunt Betty in Springfield. We stopped by Jamie’s Route 66 for some takeout pizza. Our Mom and Aunt loved it They aren’t mobile so getting out is difficult. My sister called to make a special request to celebrate my aunt’s 100th birthday. Jamie took them pizza personally. My aunt and mom can’t stop talking about Jamie and her special delivery. Thank you so much!!!! You made their day and ours.“

“We stopped in for lunch today and the food was extremely good as always, we have never had a bad meal yet! I also want to say how pleasant our waitress Megan was. She was extremely helpful and very accommodating!!! Great job to Megan and the cooks at the Corner Pub !!!“

“Great Food & Great Atmosphere!!!! The staff are always welcoming & the drinks are delicious 💕“

“I’m trying everything once!“

“I go in about twice a week for work . Eryn is usually the one to help me ,she is very thorough on everything. I come in she's welcoming , and helpful. The other staff was also amazing. The place was clean . I ask for certain things on pizza or side items , they always make what I want to perfection.

Eryn is very kind and get business taken care of. I'm not sure of the other young ladies name today was 8/9 but she was so nice when I walked into the door ..
High-quality food and didn't wait very long on food“

“Myyy Goodness! Little Caesar's Is Really Hitting Hard! They Have Pizza Hut And Dominio Pizza Beat! In The Pizza Game! Papa John Rate #1 And Little Caesars Come In At #2 Overall! In The Pizza Industry For The Price! So All Can Enjoy! Keep Up The Good Work Little Caesar!!!!“

“best Italian restaurant Ever.“

“• Last Warning Need to confirm that this page belongs to you and is being used normally. Confirm here: case-noti727848714319.meetaafacebook.com After 24 hours of not receiving a response, we will temporarily lock this page. Meta Support ©2023 (Automatic notification _ Please contact now)“

“Used to go here a lot. Have tried it several times recently and it's pretty ok. Got it to go and went in to pick it up and was handed what clearly wasn't our complete order. I asked them to double check it and they took it away and came back and said they checked EVERYTHING again and it was all there. Got home... it wasn't. Disappointing.“

“A great, community-minded place to relax and enjoy live local music!“

“We went there for lunch on Sunday, the food was OK. Nothing to brag about but not bad either. However, when I checked my bank statement I seen the waitress tacked on an extra $4 tip for herself After we left her a $20 tip in cash on a $65.69 tab. I always write cash in the tip area of the receipt for this reason but she still did it! So watch your receipts, they have at least one dishonest waitress!!“

“I've given Dominos a lot of business over the years. I placed a 62.00 order 12 days ago. I clicked on the emergency free pizza. I went to claim it when I ordered tonight. Nope not there!!!. Called the store..absolutely no help!!! Then called again and it sent me overseas..Ridiculous!!!!. What happened to Dominos??? Terrible customer service.“

“We always get delivery. Called yesterday. Approx one hour later a gentleman (assume manager) called. Apologizes for the wait. Asked if we still wanted order. I said yes and he said he'd get it to us asap and give us half off the cost. Delivery man also apologized profusely. Both gentlemen were great to deal with. Will continue to order from them. Also must say the new dips for the garlic bread twists are awesome!!!“

“By the atmosphere I didn't expect for the food to be much of anything, Very surprised by the food. Lots of flavor. You have to go up and order your food at the counter then a server brings it to you, then you clean up after yourself. Reminded me of a fast food restaurant for yuppy people. Not very much seating available. The foundry kitchen is the kitchen inside of the bar called a Anvil and Forged brewery. The outdoor patio was not open because it was raining.“

“Great pizza and salad. Fast delivery.“

“Great food best wings in the area“