20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Smithton

“SUCH A GREAT PIZZA!!!!! Highly recommended 😎“

“Bennie’s Pizza Pub in Belleville is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, you’re welcomed by a laid-back, friendly atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Whether you're here for a casual night out or grabbing a quick slice, this place delivers in every way.

Let’s talk about the pizza—phenomenal! The crust has the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, with just the right amount of char from the wood-fired oven. The toppings are fresh and generously portioned, and the cheese has that perfect melt and stretch. We tried a few different options, but the standout was their signature Bennie’s Special—every bite was loaded with flavor. If you love a little heat, their spicy options won’t disappoint either.

Beyond the pizza, the beer selection is fantastic. I did not try any of them, but they had a good choice. They offer a great mix of local and craft beers that pair perfectly with their menu. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive without being overbearing, and service was quick even when the place was busy.

Bennie’s strikes that perfect balance between a casual, fun vibe and seriously good food. It’s easy to see why locals love it. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, you won’t be disappointed. This place is a must-visit! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Parking: Former St. Louis Bread/Panera location. You would not know if not told.“

“I must say…Some of THE BEST Pizza!!! Thanks for making my Birthday memorable😉“

“Great St. Louis style and authentic Italian ingredients cooked right in front of you. At least at the Waterloo location, that one is my favorite. There few places to sit but good luck if there customers waiting for the best carry out pizza.“

“The Italian beef was amazing, wish I would have gotten two!!!“

“My husband and I stopped in during the Pride event just looking for the first place we found with food, and not only was the music and atmosphere super cool, we got the chicken bacon ranch pizza, and I swear, it was THE BEST pizza 👏🏻 I’ve 👏🏻 ever 👏🏻 had. The service was great, the food was affordable. Can’t wait to go back!“

“I always order online. I've been getting the Pretty Pizza for the entire 5/6 years I've lived here. maybe in the past year, I've intermittently ordered a 1/2 PP and 1/2 BBQ. Somehow my order didn't come out right today. Is the app glitchy? Staff said the second half wasn't even selected, so THEY chose cheese pizza for me. not really happy. My number was available. Couldn't someone have CALLED me before making this? I'm taking a break from your establishment.“

“We have been here several times and everything is fantastic! The salads are enormous and the pizzas are excellent but I do recommend extra sweet pizza sauce!! Sooo good! Atmosphere is excellent and can see this place getting very big very quickly!!“

“Got the sweet heat pizza. First time ever having Imo's It was pretty good. Crust was a little harder than I was anticipating but overall it was yummy. Probably just used to regular hand tossed crusts that are fluffier and lighter but I will go back for sure.“

“Always amazing and have loved coming here since I was a kid“

“Hosted a party and it was so fun. The food was amazing. Especially the chicken wings. Jeff and Christy are very accommodating. Tara is a great bartender. Highly recommend this venue“

“It’s my Saturday night go to for feeding my employees at work.“

“We order from here way more than we should and food is consistently delicious! Cheesy bread is a regular in our house, as well as the buffalo wings. Delivery times insane which is understandable if not enough help, so we tend to DoorDash when we are feaning for Marcos pizza. It literally never disappoints. I did pick up once and the wait was long, but the ladies behind the counter were awesome! The guys working prep and boxing were literally amazing because it was obvious they were slammed but they put extreme care into each order prepared so the wait didn’t bother me. Keep it Marcos at Central Plaza!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“When I first moved to town 10 years ago, this place was a disaster. However, the past several years it’s become outstanding, one of the better locations I deal with anywhere. The manager, Mariah has really turned this place around and they don’t have a bunch of crap employees like they used to or the other bs.

It’s gone from “oh F no” to “absolutely” when considering ordering food from here. Glad it’s out here.“

“Great place , very friendly

Vegetarian options: Lots of veggies, and if ur easy on the sauce makes it healthier for carbs intakes

Parking: Parking lot has few places to park , they share parking with the slots neighbors“

“I just ordered through uber eats & good lord whoever was cooking that food around 9pm PLEASE keep them back there!! this is the best imos ive ever had in my life from the wings, pizza & salad! Its so rare to get good food on the go, please keep it upppp🫶🏽“

“Hanging out for March Madness, and it got crazy! Lexi was our amazing bartender and she handled the unexpected crowd with humor and ease. Bobby took over when she had to leave and not a misstep in service. I ordered the Fried Cod Basket and it was outstanding; crispy and hot! Highly recommend today…“

“Carlyle Avenue, Awesome no contact delivery (Richard). Great service and great tasting Papa Dillas.“

“Every time I’ve ordered from here, they’ve been super quick, and very kind and friendly. I was in a pinch where I needed diapers and had no way to get to the store, and I called them before placing my order to see if they could grab some diapers on their way to my house to make the delivery, and they were understanding and kind and brought the diapers for me in addition to my food. I’ve never had such great customer service before, and am incredibly thankful for the help when I needed it.“

“Wow!!! Best catfish and shrimp I’ve had probably anywhere! The gyro is also delicious, and the fries are golden and crispy. Great owners, friendly service, highly recommend to anyone. You may wait a little while, but the food is prepared fresh to perfection!“