38 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cedar Lake

“Best pizza around! You've gotta try the thin crust pizza! Bacon bits and cheese, I know it sounds plain, but it's anything but that with their sweet sauce!❤️“

“I have ordered Rosati's pizza delivery many times. Delivery was excellent however our pizza tonight was definitely not up to the regular standards. The crust was soggy, it was light on sauce, and could have cooked a few minutes more. I will continue to order Rosati pizza as I feel it is the best in the area. Maybe just a difficult night for the cook.“

“We did not eat in but had our pizza delivered. It arrived hot and just as we asked for it. They are not chintzy with their toppings and the crust was heavenly. This is the first time we've ordered from there as we were at our daughter's house. I would definitely make the trip to have another one.“

“Called in the person was patient with me and very nice took order correctly did drive up pizzas were ready. Only gave 4 stars because we ordered a gluten free pizza and the crust tasted like dust it was really weird but our regular family size was delicious although could have been hotter but all in all we would order again just not gluten free“

“Best wings and pizza around! Best crust in town“

“Doug was patient, cordial, very attentive. My mom, 96, has not been out for a meal in 5 yrs. Doug made this a pleasant experience for the 4 of us. Comfortable sitting, great comfortable noise level, not crowded sitting( we had a wheelchair), food excellent. Pork shoulder outstanding. No stickiness on anything. Best day/meal ever! Thank u Doug“

“We love this place! The food is always hit and delicious and the servers are always friendly!“

“Just had Rosati's, it was fantastic. The crust was great – perfectly cooked and delicious. The sauce was Absolutely amazing. Seriously, one of the best pizza sauces I've had in a long time.
You've got to try the garlic knots; they were killer! Big shout-out to Emily for the great customer service too. She was super friendly and made the experience even better.
Highly recommend Rosati's for a top-notch pizza experience!“

“Amazing pizza. We had the the Margherita pizza with pesto and Pepperoni! Top notch.“

“ordered route 2 pizza last night for dinner. Got a medium cheese pizza(kids), a medium sausage and spinach pizza, and two steak tacos, on corn, with cilantro, onions and cheese. I have got to compliment their AMAZING tacos. They were huge and the steak was so tender. I usually don't get steak out because i always get steak too tough or not enough flavor. This place is a pizza place but man their tacos are my favorite now. And the pizza, just as amazing with the right amount of toppings and didn't skimp on the cheese. I wanted to leave a review as I'm reheating my pizza in my air fryer right now, which comes out just as amazing as yesterday. Thanks route 2! My family really enjoyed dinner last night!“

“Hired Battista’s for my wedding last weekend. The two man team was fast and was able to feed a large amount of guests within a short amount of time! All of our guests LOVED the pizza!! Thank you!!“

“Always great pizza and delivery time today was faster then expected“

“My son and I love this place. Our server Katrina is wonderful - She even ran our leftover pizza out to my car after I left it on the table in a to go box- She's a real cutie too ;)“

“Pizza Cellar is amazing!!!! What a hidden treasure in Crown Point. Their pizza has high quality ingredients and was not greasy. I ordered the thin crust and a deep dish. They both had generous toppings and the crust was great. 10/10 recommend!“

“We had the most delicious cauliflower crust pizza tonight! It is our weekly treat for eating healthy and boy did Faustino's come through! A big thanks to Lori and her team for making such a fantastic dinner for us tonight! We highly recommend Faustino's...hands down...AWESOME!“

“This Rosati's Restraunt was absolutely DELICIOUS!!
Wonderful dining experience!
Our waitress was phenomenal,friendly & attentive!
We had my daughters birthday party with family here pretty big party! They were so accommodating & food was SO fast! Our hungry crowd had more than enough food & quickly! We got a double order of shareable bread bites they are so light decadent & FULL OF FLAVOR!, with the most craveable (best ive ever eaten) Fav SAUCE!!!(& I know sauce hehe I'm Italian) (was such a crowd favorite!!!!) ( we ordered another to go) haha we got a Large pizza, a deep dish, & a small thin crust & we had TONS to take home. Best pizza in NWI!
The restraunt is adorned with cute decor, had a fireplace, fancy seating for date nights,comfy big cushioned seats,love the atmosphere as well!

They made our dining experience a wonderful celebration, including let us put our cake in the fridge till we were ready to eat it & offering us cool paper plates for cake & provided us extra cutlery!
Thank you so much Rosati's from my family, for the delicious FIRST time experience we won't forget & can't wait for many more yummy Italian meals here! We are for sure going to be regular customers now!“

“GREAT pizza...period! Simple decor, nice people and service. One of Chicagoland areas best pizza carry out.“

“My daughter and I picked a random place today, and we ended up here. Definitely didn’t know what to expect, and the menu had so many choice it was hard to decide ( a good thing )!!! The waitress was super helpful and super nice!!! My food was so good! And the portions were enough for leftovers. I will definitely try this place again. 👍“

“My husband and I have been ordering from Doreen’s pizza for 14+ years. We’ve ALWAYS gotten the perfect pizza! Super delicious!“

“We finally went to S & T and bought the 12 inch thin crust sausage pizza set up. 3 pizzas for $26! We made one last night and added green pepper and pepperoni it was delicious!! I assembled the other two and they are ready to go in the freezer for next time. What a great concept and savings on take out. Highly recommend!“

“Pizza here is definitely tasty. A little doughy so it’s not the typical thin crust tavern style you find at a lot of small shops.

It’s inside a gas station. Order in person or over the phone. Pay at the gas station cashier. Bring back your receipt to the pizza counter to grab your pizza.

It was fast and friendly service. Clean and smells amazing inside.

I got the beef and onion along with a specialty pizza, the taco pizza.

I enjoyed the taco pizza. Very tasty except it’s a hard one to warm up the next day due to the lettuce and tomato.

The beef and onion was decent. It doesn’t have a strong flavor. Just enough to make you wanting more. Again, lots of dough so it fills you up quickly.“

“Good service fun atmosphere for the children 😊“

“First, the service was very good. The bartender was quick to pick up on whether we wanted a drink or we wanted a menu. The food was great, as always. I have to eat something when I come in here. I just can't pass it up.

Parking: There is a lot of parking, but you may have to walk.“

“We love coming here, and the last couple times we’ve been here, we had Lauren as our server. She is amazing, sit in her section if you can. She’s great at her job. She brought us extra dipping sauces, was very timely, remembered us, was extremely kind, checked on us several times, brought us free samples of her beer recommendations (based off of our personal taste!); I can’t say enough about her! The curds are amazing, the beer is great, and we love everything we’ve tried so far. Get the pizza extra crispy when you go!“

“I like to think that im a pizza connoisseur, I can look at pizza pictures and tell if it will be good or not to try. So that what I did for this place and they did not disappoint it was the best pizza I had in long time. I eat Nancy's and Italian village in Illinois, and Mama D's is way better. The pizza was thin with the right amount of sauce and cheese. Very well seasoned pizza! Im telling everyone.“

“you hungry for real great food, that's cool, me too, you should go here!!! you're welcome. staff is really nice as well.“

“The beef sandwich is amazing! I highly recommend.“

“Took a night vacation fom Illinois and ordered delivery to Hilton Garden Inn Merrillville and the pizza came HOT AND FRESH😍 like it was fresh from the oven! Delivery was fast and delivery driver was so sweet! Great pizza!! So glad to have an Aurelio's in Crown Point!!“

“Dear Aurelio's Staff,

I am writing to express my sincere gratitude for the exceptional service we received during my husband's surprise 60th birthday party at your Winfield location. From the initial planning stages to the final touches on the decorations, your team was incredibly accommodating and helpful, going above and beyond to ensure everything ran smoothly. The level of personalized attention was truly remarkable.

The party was a resounding success, largely thanks to your dedication. The food was absolutely delicious – a delightful array of options that catered to all tastes. The breadsticks were perfectly crisp, the salad refreshing, and the Mostaccioli was a particular hit. The pizza, roast beef, and the carefully curated selection of beer, wine, and soft drinks completed a truly superb spread. I was especially impressed that you were able to accommodate my request for my husband's favorite beer, even though it's not typically on your menu – that extra effort truly made a difference.

Having 50 guests and managing to stay under $20 per person was a pleasant surprise and a testament to your efficient and cost-effective catering services. More importantly, the party was a memorable and joyous occasion, exceeding all expectations. My husband had the best birthday celebration he’s ever experienced, and for that, I am eternally grateful.

Thank you again for your outstanding service and for helping to create such a wonderful and unforgettable event.

Sincerely, Victoria“

“😃please consider bringing back the appetizer combo platter, most people enjoy the variety! I know I would, thanks“

“Giordano's Pizza tastes great.... all the time! Taste is consistent regardless if it's dine-in or take out! I've enjoyed Giordano's for at least 10 years now and looking forward for more! First time doing business with Schererville and it is very pleasant. Thank you Schereville team!“

“This place is going downhill fast. I emailed Aurelios in Schererville about an experience 3 wks ago they NEVER got back to me.... we take my mom here every time we visit her. We've had issues yesterday 5.12.24 and the time before as well. I complained about getting the cookie my mom loves because it was brought to the table and was entirely melted ice cream and whip cream so melted you could pour it like water. Yesterday the pizza was entirely burnt and so hard . If they do something wrong and you complain about it believe you will pay for it if you return. This was our pizza yesterday that we asked them to cut in squares. Happy Mother's day to us.“

“Excelente service! Great flavorful pizza. I recommend this restaurant. It broke the scale of my expectations! I will return again.“

“Driving on route 30 in Indiana we saw State line Pizza. We decided to go in and to my surprise a nice low key pizza spot. Suzanne our waitress paid attention my order i don't eat meat. I had ordered A Ceasars salad, no idea that Ceasar salad had anchovie paste in the dressing. Suzanne informed me of my options. We also ordered the veggie thin crust pizza, well done the crust was nice and crispy just the way we like it , and the half basket appetizer which was good too and more than enough for two. This State line Pizza gets a double thumbs up.“

“Had a fantastic carryout this evening. The Italian beef with cheese, the ribeye steak sandwich, and pasta shell sides. Absolutely awesome. They take very good care of me every time I go there. Thank you, Pepino’s.❤️❤️❤️“

“Very good experience at sbarro this morning. We arrived at about 11:10, right after opening, and all of the food was out and fresh. Everything looked amazing-we wanted it all. We ended up trying the pizza, spaghetti with meatballs, and breadsticks and it was all so good. The workers were also very friendly and quick. Would definitely go back“

“Very nice little family restaurant.“