Mr Gatti's Pizza
$ • PizzaAbout Mr Gatti's Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Mr Gatti's Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Mr Gatti's Pizza
Pizza tasted funny like freezer burned do
I’ve love coming here ever since I was a kid and prefer it to the Louisville locations because it stayed the same as when I was a kid. Good food with great staff. There was a sign out front warning about no ice which was really disappointing, but Richard ran out to let us know they did have ice, it was just low.
When we first walked in and paid, we were immediately asked if we wanted to request anything which was great. We sat down and Richard came over to give us...read full review
Salad bar was not fresh and very limited. Extremely expensive for pizza and iceberg lettuce. For the same price you can eat at a buffet with steak down the street or Asian buffets with over 100 choices. Filthy restrooms.
Hours
| Monday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 8PM |
Mr Gatti's Pizza is a casual and affordable eatery that's perfect for families. The restaurant has made improvements, including a renovated entryway, clean dining room, and welcoming staff. The all-day buffet is a highlight, with a variety of pizza options, including a salad bar with several items. The place is a little run down, but that's to be expected of an almost 50 year old building. It is very kid friendly with some arcade games. One worker, known for making the BEST pizza, offers favorites like the bacon Mac n cheese pizza and the BBQ chicken pizza.
Customers have mixed reviews about the restaurant. Some note issues with the food quality, such as overcooked pizzas, mushy pasta, and wilted salad bar items, especially on Sundays. However, others praise the variety of comfort foods and the attentive service of a staff member named Richard, who provides a cheerful and personalized experience.