14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Crawfordsville

“Have been a huge fan of this pizza for a couple years. Was a bit disappointed in my first pizza from the restaurant. The crust had absolutely no crisp like it used to. The flavor, while delicious, was too salty. Still better than most others in town. Wonderful owners/staff.“

“I went to Brothers for the first time yesterday. I had a BBQ, pepperoni, sausage pizza. It was delicious! It was less expensive than all other pizza I've had in W Lafayette/Lafayette area. I will definitely go back.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“We eat at Arnis more often than any other pizza place. It is the go to when my parents are in town from Tennessee! We ate there this evening after my nieces birthday party. There was a boy name Jaiden running food. He is absolutely amazing! He was very kind, attentive and made sure we were doing okay several times. It is very refreshing to see a young kid with a good work ethic! These are the type of employees that need to be recognized and the reason for my review tonight. Good job Jaiden and Good job Arnis!“

“Great service and even better food! It was are first time eating there, we definitely recommend!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“I order from them a lot.And they have the best pizza.Always hot and fresh when I get delivery.Love their pizza.🍕“

“always delicious. And I'm pretty picky about my pizza. Made fast and everyone is always friendly. I totally recommend ordering from here“

“We have been looking into purchasing a home in the area and have been trying local places to find a favorite. Pizza is normally a safe choice for us with three little boys. Honestly, we stopped by after spending hours at Turkey Run and everyone was worn out and hungry. ~4:30pm Sunday. As soon as drinks were delivered to the table, our youngest knocked his glass over and the waitress was so calm and brought more napkins for us. The food was the best Pizza Hut we’ve ever had. The pizza was hot and perfectly cooked. The breadsticks were soft inside but perfectly toasty on the outside. Refills were prompt and correct. Dishes and table were all clean. Very very happy with the food and service.“

“Went to buy lottery ticket before I headed to Indianapolis. Went in store I was very impressed how I was welcomed before door shut . I looked around very impressed by how clean store was . I decided to order a whole pizza . Went to woman's bathroom while waiting on pizza & I would have to say it was pretty nasty . Toilet paper on floor but then I want into handicap stall there was the toilet that had stuff on seat so I didn't go in that one . First off went to that stall so I could hang purse . So went in first one not as dirty but nowhere to hang purse . So I had to place my purse on outside on dryer and leave my stall door half open in case the possibility of my purse being taken because after I ordered my pizza it got pretty busy not packed but busy . Got pizza thanked the young lady that made it . Got in car so I tried the pizza would say it only cost $17. & Some change . It was really great pizza for a gas station . Because I was expecting pizza to be as awful Speedway pizza. The price was so reasonable & it was truly good pizza & I had 5 toppings . So other than the bathrooms the it was a very pleasant experience. Staff was so great . Still give it all 5 stars .
Thank You for to Casey's Awesome staff
Sincerely
R. Scott“

“I like it because they always have the $5 pizzas and at lunch time they have a $5 meal which is a 20 oz bottle and four pieces of deep dish pizza which is really good most of the time.... No matter what you think...it will fill you up and everything is extremely fast even if you don't want the five dollar ? pizza.. it doesn't take long for them to make what u want... It's not McDonald's but I love it..“