9 Best Pizza Restaurants in West Lafayette

The Tap Brewpubs • $$
100 S Chauncey Ave, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Pretzel Sticks and Beer Cheese
Pretzel Sticks Beer Cheese
Beer Cheese Burger
Fried Green Beans
Tex Mex Steak Wrap
Haystack Burger
Tater Tots
Tap Fries
Cali Club
Hamburger

“Matthew H. was a great server! He’s funny, charismatic, and very kind. He made great drinks and was very attentive. Our service was fast, accurate, and we were often visited to make sure we had everything we needed. 10/10 experience with Matthew H :)“

4.4 Superb171 Reviews
Pizza Uncommon Pizza • $$
1522 Win Hentschel Blvd, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Hot Honey Pepperoni
Chicken Lemon Pesto
Margherita Pizza
Vegan Everything
Everything Pizza
Vegan Pizza
Breadsticks
Sauces

“I have celiac disease and Pizza Uncommon has been one of my best dining experiences since my diagnosis. It’s not a burden to them to make things gluten free!! The thorough explanation of procedures I felt very comfort & even confident eating here. The fluffiest & BEST gluten free crust I’ve ever gotten!! AND offering gluten free breadsticks, can’t tell you the last time that’s been possible! Made this celiac gal’s day!!Dietary restrictions: I have celiac disease and this is the most thorough gluten safe procedures I’ve seen at most dining places!“

4.5 Superb104 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
506 Sagamore Pkwy W, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Pizza
Traditional Wings
Big Dinner Box
Sausage Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Cheese Pizza
Breadsticks
Garlic Bread

“I don't generally care for chain store pizza. But as a life-long Chicago tavern-style fan living in central Indiana, I'm not exactly spoiled for choice around here. You get what you get. Central Indiana pizzerias never met a sausage that they couldn't grind into itty bitty chunks the size of gravel. WHY? WHY DO YOU DO THIS?Anyway.Pizza Hut. The pan pizza with sausage, bacon, pepperoni is pretty darned good but not because it's anything like Chicago style, cuz it isn't. It's its own thing. In particular, it's the crispiness in the crust. That's what makes it. Sure, the ingredients are fine. Nothing special to be honest. It's that crispiness that you just cannot get anywhere else. Not anywhere I know of anyway and that's good enough for me.Plus the crew is always friendly and chill. I appreciate that. Most chain store employees are generally (and rightfully) grumbly, so it's nice when you run into a crew that doesn't seem to be miserable.Also, pro tip, add special instructions to have them add butter to the crust. Makes it not only buttery but even crispier!That said, I will never forgive Pizza Hut for doing away with the tomato sauce they used to use on the thin crust. The thin crust cheese was fantastic. The new marina just does not work on thin crust. Bring back that sauce!!!!!“

4.1 Good56 Reviews
Monical's Pizza of West Lafayette Pizza • $$
3457 Bethel Dr C, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Large Sandwich
Veggie Pizza
Extra Chips
Cookies
Lasagna

“It was 15 minutes before Closing and i called in and asked about Breadsticks. As i was picking up Pizza from another Pizza joint close by that didn't have Bread sticks. All i can say!... is the Bread Sticks were AMAZING! And the Cheese was Excellent too!... WILL Return for More Bread Sticks and Maybe try the Pizza this Time!!!!“

4.2 Good30 Reviews
Greek's Pizzeria Pizza • $$
2520 N Salisbury St #1428, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Small Pizza with Cheeses & Any One Topping
Medium Sized Pepperoni and Sausage
Homemade Garlic Bread Sticks
Grilled Chicken Salad
Greek's Special Pizza
Chicken Fajita Pizza
The White Pizza
Stromboli Shell
White Zinfandel
Pepperoni Pizza

“Very nice place.The owner was supper nice.The bread sticks had a lot of grease, but napkin to soak it resolved that. Most people could handle the grease with no issue.Pizza was good, not super greasy.They are not stingy with the cheese sauce for breadsticks, also have parmesan.Place was very cute and homly. Though there was an odd smell,but you get used to it.Place was clean.Hope to go again and try their dessert menu as well next time. Breadsticks are okay left over.Kid-friendliness: Has a highchair.“

4 Good42 Reviews
HotBox Pizza Pizza • $
302 Vine St, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Bread Sticks and Cheese Sauce
Hippie

“I’m a terrible person and forgot to leave these folk a tip when I picked up my order tonight! I hope this review will make up for it. Kelsey took our order over the phone and checked us out upon pick up. We were welcomed at the door (as soon as we walked in) with greetings and smiles. Our order was ready and still hot. She made sure we knew we could take paper-ware and cheese/pepper packets. Such friendly service and the pizza itself was delicious! Well balanced toppings, not too much sauce or cheese, and their classic crust is just the right thickness with excellent chewy crust - lightly seasoned as well. Thank you!Parking: There are two free 15 minute short term parking spots around the corner“

3.8 Good124 Reviews
Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
616 W Stadium Ave, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings
Tater Tots
Lava Cake

“Domino's Pizza is my go-to pizza destination. They have the best dough I've ever had, along with fresh vegetables and a perfectly balanced ingredients. The cheese is right, melting wonderfully and adding the perfect touch.The Girls and Boys Working here are fantastic &always Welcoming wearing a big smile , which is appreciated . There's plenty of seating inside, perfect place to enjoy pizza with friends .No matter where I travel I can always count on their pizza being reliable and tasty.Vegetarian options: They have good vegetarian pizza ?Parking: There is a car parking right next to this store“

3.7 Good75 Reviews
Mad Mushroom Pizza • $
307 Sagamore Pkwy W #300, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Breadstix

“This is a new store serving predictably good Mad Mushroom pizza. The store is very small and focused on pick up and delivery. There are three tables inside if you want to eat in. Not much waiting area either if you are waiting on an order. The food is consistent with other Mad Mushroom stores. We ordered The Steve pizza. The crust is soft and floury to touch/taste. The pizza was kinda there. Not a lot of zip to grab your taste. A moderate amount of toppings and sauce. The toppings did taste fresh. The garden salads were a nice size. The salad and ingredients were fresh. There were a nice amount of side vegetables. The dressings will be a packet of Ken's which is good stuff. The team here hustled on this occasion. They were very friendly and did a good job at keeping the facility clean. Here is my tip...and I should share this since it will come back to get me. This facility is tucked in a strip mall as you are getting ready to get back on the bypass. After a Purdue game...this is an easy place to get into...grab a bite to eat...and let the traffic clear out. The facility seems to new for people to figure this out yet.“

3.8 Good17 Reviews
Papa Johns Pizza Pizza • $
1400 W State St, West Lafayette

Customers` Favorites

Large Up to
BBQ Sauce

“Pretty decent food for it being a Papa John's. No complaints about speed or the service, but the quality of the food isn't as great as you could get at a nicer pizza place. Again though, for the price and it being a Papa John's, it's really not bad“

3.7 Good22 Reviews
Loading...
map Map