13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Lafayette

“Excellent Restaurant! The food here was good. I order a BLT and Soup. The sandwich was quality made and tasted very good and flavorful. The soup was just as good. The pricing was surprisingly affordable given that the food was really good a quality. The service was great too and accommodating. I definitely recommend coming here weather its to drink or eat.“

“One of the best kept secrets in town. I’ve been hundreds of times over the years and cannot say a single time where my food wasn’t amazing. Despite there only being a couple of employees, my food always comes out fast and fresh. It’s also super fun to watch the owner do his thing in the kitchen!! Every meal I’ve tried has been amazing.“

“For local, non-chain pizza, Magoo's is possibly the best. I typically do not like pizza, yet Magoo's is one I actually crave from time to time. Lots of toppings to choose from. The sauce is tasty, and they use the perfect amount. They also use a bunch of cheese. The star, however, is the crust; it's flavorful, crispy, and yet still tender. I assume it's the same dough as is used for the breadsticks because they are very good as well and the cheese dip is also very good.“

“My first experience here and I'm a fan! Friendly employees, very fast ordering process, lots of great choices, and my pizza was delicious. It was hot and fresh, and they definitely did not skimp on the toppings. I often work in Lafayette, and Azzip is going to be a regular lunch spot for me.“

“I have really come to love Parkway. I met my oldest son and daughter in law here quite some time ago, and my only regret is not trying it sooner!The atmosphere is quaint, the service is phenomenal, and thus far, everything that I've tried is delicious!I can't say enough about Parkway. I HIGHLY recommend! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“What a great place. I have been going to Arni's since I was a young child. Now I have grown up and am in my 50's. I have moved away and every time I come home to see my mother I stop here for a bite to eat. Pizza by far is the best ever. Salads are amazing and sandwiches are unique and delicious.“

“Oh, hello. Didn't notice you were even there. My bad. You want to know how my recent meal was at the Monicals Pizza in Lafayette, IN? I can answer that, let's break it down a little bit more, sound good?!* Specific date is in question but if I had to guess this was a dinner I had with my wife and daughter on Dec.27th-ish* Ordered a tiny 7" cheese pizza and a 16" large half supreme and half pepperoni, cheese bread, and an order of chix wings, the real kind not the fake boneless* Very happy with the wings, they came out perfectly crispy, meaty and delicious. That's a perfect ten* Cheesy bread is always very good, it's on French bread I believe and has a unique mozzarella flavor and served with their red sauce. We gave it a perfect ten.* Pizza came out with a smile, give Props to your waitress, they have a million reasons NOT to get a job bringing food to people, so thank them with your wallet, what's a couple bucks anyways, im not into giving handouts either, they earn it, for sure.* Giving the pizza a rating of a 8 out of ten. It is very delicious pizza, thin crust, but in order to get a ten, I'd need to have an out of body, other worldly experience. And so, well that just didn't happen, so here we go, all in all, drumroll, please.*“

“Small dine in area, near the Tesla Supercharger. Super Friendly staff! The young man and woman running the shop were polite and fast.The TASTY pizza could be best described as high end “frozen”. Not actually frozen, but thinner and drier crust (not a bad thing)It’s like the pizza of my childhood. It is perfectly reasonable, tasty, inexpensive pizza, and perfect stop on your supercharger journey. My son loved it.They should lean into the Fox mascot and make this a more kid focused spot! Cool logo.“

“I think mad mushroom is the best pizza in Lafayette. We. Eat there prolly 4 or 5 times a month. I highly recommend their pizza, Sammie's, cheese stix, and their calzonesVegetarian options: Veggie pizza for those that are vegetarianDietary restrictions: They have crustless for those that have to be carb conscious.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp for wheelchair accessibility.“

“Had my daughters 8th birthday, had about a dozen or 15 people, $150 fed everyone and they picked what they wanted, was worth it.The bday cake we brought in after rollerskating was allowed, and we used a candle app for her to blow out the safe candle ?“

“I wish this place had a good place to sit. Only two small tables . The lady making the food was very nice . My husband heard from Co- workers how good the pizza is ! They are right ! We live an hour away and having a nice place to eat would be great !“

“In town, this is the best pizza one can get. I’d venture also for the state of Indiana due to the unique hand-made slices, original recipes, and the brick fired oven.I remember when Snuggs first started out of The Spot, and I loved it from the beginning.I have the pleasure of owning a Snuggs longsleeve shirt, and a signed Snuggs box for my pizza wall because this pizza is so good.Support local ??Vegetarian options: Usually they include an all vegetarian slice when they conduct store pop-ups so everyone can enjoy some pizza :)“

“Well, I never went here, but it was delivered, it's always delivered. I don't drive anymore. But, I have been eating Pizza Hut since I was a young boy. I'm 60 now, and it's great pizza, don't get me wrong, but 50-55 years ago, the taste was different. A lot different making it better than today's. See, I said; don't get me wrong. Haha, the atmosphere, um, right on time, my hut! It was all good! ?“