13 Best Italian Restaurants in Elkhart

“If you're looking for an authentic neighborhood Italian restaurant with great food and great service in a quaint setting, head to Michael's. It is a hidden gem. The pizza is phenomenal, I can't wait to go back and try some of their entrees especially the eggplant parmigiana.“

“We had Sue as our server, she was very detailed explaining the menu. She was Awesome! Will return and ask for her!“

“AMAZING! Alyssa is the best. Our family and friends who are family make the trip from Ohio to Notre Dame every year for a football game. We stay in Elkhart and always have a wonderful experience here. We decided on Olive Garden after a full day of traveling and visiting the campus. Let me tell you - this was the best dining out experience I have had in a really long time! We were treated with patience and value by the hostesses and were seated much sooner than expected. One of our party had a birthday, so our server Alyssa helped us plot a surprise "happy birthday" song (which sounded so professional, by the way, as well as a complimentary birthday dessert. Thanks Alyssa!

My 6 year old daughter was recently diagnosed with Type 1 Diabetes and then Celiac - so we are in the process of changing her to a completely gluten-free diet and letting her try new GF foods. When we ordered the GF pasta, Alyssa asked if this was an allergy so she could alert the kitchen, which I found extremely thoughtful. When our food was brought to our table, before adding any cheese, it was confirmed it was okay and safe for her to have! Navigating chronic autoimmune diseases in your child is overwhelming, so feeling understood and valued meant the absolute world to me!

If I could hug Alyssa and let her know how much her thoughtfulness, kindness, and amazing service meant to me, I would.

I also appreciated the manager coming to our table and making sure we enjoyed our meal.

10/10 would definitely eat here again! Thank you again and give Alyssa a raise! ??“

“My family makes an annual trip to Rulli's as part of my birthday celebrations as they give out a free meal if you are part of their email club. It's really one of the best deals. As for the food, my wife and I both really like the pizza and my kids like the spaghetti with the huge meatballs. The restaurant is clean and the parking is more than ample.“

“10/10 recommend Bruno’s on 17! Their 24” pizza is a stellar pie!“

“5 stars.the best pizza ever .. love Detroit style.“

“I called and ordered a large pizza. The person taking my order was very professional and easy to place my order with. They estimated about a 40 minute delivery time and it was delivered well before which was a pleasant surprise. The pizza was hot and the delivery driver was kind and patient. Would recommend them!“

“as an out-of-towner best I found around locally in niles“

“Food was so good and service was awesome!“

“Breadsticks were the best I've tasted! They were light, with a good baked bread taste, and they were extremely fresh. Sicilian style pizza was also very good, the kind Noble Roman's used to sell when they had sit down restaurants. Be aware, the sicilian pan pizza has the sauce on top, not under the toppings, so if you don't want a blast if pizza sauce, go with another style of pizza. Iced tea was excellent, and it was good to be able to get the refills myself. Definitely will visit again!“

“Hands-down the best pizza I’ve had in Elkhart. It has its own unique flavor with a delicious chewiness, slight char flavor and excellent thin crunchy outside. I can’t recommend this pizza enough. Bruno’s, Vesuvios, and Marcos are all good but this is BEST baby.“

“10/10 recommend Bruno’s on 17! Their 24” pizza is a stellar pie!“