46 Best Pizza Restaurants in Evansville

“Dontae's has the best pizza in town in my opinion! Everything is so fresh and his pizzas are culinary masterpieces! I literally cannot wait to try the new deep dish. He is the type of business owner that puts his heart and soul into the food and it shows! If you're wondering if you should give Dontae's a try this is your sign! You won't be disappointed.“

“Great! Fresh ingredients, crispy thin crust, and it's always hot when they deliver! AAA+“

“Heard it was the best in town and by god they weren’t kidding! Simple menu great food and some of the friendliest people you’ll ever encounter! Highly recommended the cheesy bread too! The price beats everywhere else also with the generous toppings!“

“I had a great Grapefruit IPA recommended by our waitress. Great environment, AMAZING food. We are up this way several times a year. We will be back!!! If you are on the north side of Evansville almost to 64, stop in...you will love Pips!!!“

“It's fire. Best tasting food I've ever had. The service is magnificent and the atmosphere is amazing. I really loved it!“

“Their Stromboli is great. I have been a Pizza King Stromboli guy for years. Lately, the new building on the west side Stroms have tasted like heartbreak and disappointment. That is NOT the case here. This former Pizza King guy now has a new place to get Strombolis. You should try them too.“

“This is some good pizza....“

“Food good/ workers great people-

Pizza? The crust gives me heartburn due to not being made in house………

Has mr. beefs on Thursdays, but runs out before anyone can even try it, sounds like it needs to be available more days out of the week.“

“Azzip pizza was a hit last night for dinner. The kids loved it! MARCH CRABNESS- Crab Rangoon Mix, Mozzarella, Sweet Soy Sauce, Thai Chili Sauce & Crispy Wontons E'VIL PIG / WESTSIDER PIZZA- Sweet 'n Sassy BBQ Sauce, Mozzarella, Slow Smoked Pork, Red Onion, Grippos, Ski Reduction Definitely would recommend. 10/10“

“Great pizza, we usually opt for combo or pepperoni and awesome smiling faces when you walk through the door. They always do a great job.“

“This is some good pizza....“

“I was there early today. placed an order at the carry out section. I am the one that screwed up my own order, they made it right for me anyway. The young lady that waited on me and her manager were absolutely awesome. I hope they both know how much I appreciated their attitudes concerning my mistake.“

“FANTASTIC New York style Pizza!! I love thin crust that isn't like a cracker and has flavor. Top tier toppings. Reheats beautifully. The slice of the day options are fire!!“

“Love The Slice! I eat there 2-3 times a week and switch between my favorites: ranch, potatoe, cheese, and pepperoni 🩷“

“Didn’t like the egg salad. Was a bit too sweaty.“

“Y little girl always has such a wonderful time visiting Chuck E Cheese! Chuck E comes out every hour and dances with the kids and stays for pictures. The employees are great at customer service and keeping the kids happy.“

“My husband took our kids and his mom to Rounders Too for lunch Friday and had the best experience. Our son uses a speech device primarily to communicate and was super interested in the iPad the waitress was using to order. She asked him what he wanted and then offered him to order everyone's food and drink using the iPad himself. He was extremely happy to be able to do that, as most people don't direct questions to him due to him being mostly non-verbal. We appreciate her kindness in giving him that opportunity and making his day. When they left, our daughter had left behind a stuffed animal and the waitress came out to the car to make sure they didn't leave without it. Eating out can be a very stressful situation for us in general, but I think we have found a new lunch spot!“

“The Pizza Oven is the perfect hole-in-the-wall joint that makes excellent pies with the tastiest toppings and a perfect crust. Their strombolis are top-notch. This is by far the best pizza in Evansville. You just can't go wrong at The Pizza Oven!“

“We absolutely love Spankey’s pizza and salads. Service is always amazing 🍕🥗 😋“

“We absolutely love Spankey’s pizza and salads. Service is always amazing 🍕🥗 😋“

“Miranda was absolutely amazing. Absolutely recommend and ask for her.“

“Great service! This place had the best Stromboli that we’ve ever eaten, and the pizza was absolutely fantastic! We highly recommend!“

“Best stroms and hot ham and cheese around.“

“great service pizza is awesome got to try finger bread the cheese on the pizza is so thick pick up slice the cheese comes right with it the way it should“

“First time to order and it's the best pizza in town. I've been here 4 years and not sure how I missed this place. Delivery was faster than the time they said, the pizza was huge and hot, the drinks were ice cold. Friendly delivery driver. This is my new go-to place for pizza.“

“When I order pizza, this is my go to place. Local and close to home. I had a bit of an abnormally long hold time, but it's understandable on a Friday night before snowmegedon. The hold time didn't bother me, however the hold music did (longggg hold).
It was erie, and soothing at the same time. Up until the bell like Melody cracks and screeches. I jokingly told the server I had a complaint about the hold music. She went and got the manager, we joked about it and the manager let me pick the new hold music!! What a time to be alive! I took home delicious pizza, the best strom in town, and got to pick the hold music? It's a good night.
As a licensed journeyman plumber Its my professional opinion those two ladies get promoted above peers, a weeks paid vacation, and a raise.“

“Visited Turoni’s today while visiting from Texas and I have to say we received the best service from Haley and the food was awesome!! The Stromboli was delicious and such a hefty portion for the lunch special! We also order the buffalo chicken pizza which was delicious! The entire experience was on point and so glad we picked this place to eat today!! thank yall!!“

“Kiki, Andrew and the staff at kipplees outdid themselves today in service and friendship. Had my husband's retirement party today and they did an outstanding job. I highly recommend them for parties and gatherings. Thanks again Kipplees“

“DiMaggio’s Pizza is absolutely fantastic! My go-to order is the pepperoni with hot honey, and it is unreal. The crust is perfectly crispy yet chewy, the pepperoni is flavorful, and the hot honey adds the perfect sweet-heat kick! Yum!“

“Build your own delicious pizza in a clean restaurant! The “no name cake” takes me back to the foil wrapped chocolate cakes of my childhood-delicious! The name brand ones that aren’t wrapped in foil any longer just aren’t as good as they used to be.“

“amazing food and experience!“

“VERY good food. Flavors and portions on point, reasonable prices. Only negative thing is it’s so quiet and music was way too low. Kinda depressing. Will come back though when we’re in really, really good moods! 🤪“

“Great“

“My wife and I ate here for the first time today. I ate the fried shrimp and it was amazing. She ate the Monte Cristo and loved it! Our server was Destiny and she was the best! She even made my wife a special drink she asked for. Definitely will return!“

“Michelle was very friendly and professional. She resolved anything that we were questionable concerning. We were uncertain about some things regarding what we were receiving though she made for sure we received exactly what we wanted and was prompt within her service. The bread sticks were delicious and fresh. The rest of the food we ordered was as well. . Michelle went above and beyond to make sure that we had a truly pleasant experience and was very bubbly and personable. It is hard to come across a person that practices such customer service skills. If we are in the area again we will be sure to stop back through.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“We had some family in town and met at Roca Bar for our final farewell dinner. Everything was served promptly and with a smile. We shared the large Italian salad, ordered two large pizzas with the $10 ($1 per wing) wings deal and a medium pepperoni for the kiddos. Everything was fantastic and everyone really seemed to enjoy the Roca Bar experience. Kudos to our server Misty! We will gladly plan more family events.“

“We had a great experience tonight! Our server Kelsey was exceptional. Not only did she make great recommendations on food but beer choices as well. She was able to keep up with my joking husband . Lol The food came out hot, fresh and flavorful. We were there about 30 mins from closing so that makes the fact that the food was still fresh even better. Definitely a favorite!“

“Jasmine always has a pleasant smile on her face and a very sweet young lady.
We always try to give her time and The personal side of her he is appealing in our world that doesn’t seem to care about what kind of service they want to give. She is a human being too! We can change everyone one person at a time. But I’ll just say that“

“The big Don sub is the best in the United States!“

“Family is been putting out great food for years. My grandfather was a hudge customer of them! (Great story of how much 1 customer can be a Value to a place) I know they are good home town folks doing a grand down home job for it's people. Producing very good food. If they slip, they quick fast to make it right. I do recommend this every day. Just sad they are not open for lunch. But thank you for your hard great work.“

“I am surprised to hear other locations in Evansville have closed. Lack of sales? I’m fairly new to the area from the west coast. Papa Murphy’s is very popular there. Tuesdays are ANY large pizza for $10!! Ten dollars for delicious food. Take & bake here is fresh and delicious. All you have to do it preheat your oven, remove the plastic wrap and bake it for the time noted. These are the best take and bake pizzas. I’m glad they are convenient to my house. Keep it goin Papa Murphy’s!“