Restaurants near Fish Lake

“Went on Saturday to give the Prime Rib a try… we were not disappointed. The waitress was GREAT, considering she waited on the entire room by herself! We all worked thru it and had a good time while waiting… I even tried the Blueberry Manhattan!”

“We don't come here a lot but I'm not sure why. This is a great breakfast joint. Their omlets and scrambles are on point. Eggs are perfectly cooked, and they actually put enough cheese in it. Most places skimp on the cheese. Not these guys! The kids absolutely love the Piggy pancakes. They use chocolate chips for the eyes, and the kids go crazy. The only complaint I have and it isn't really a complaint. it's just my preference. They don't butter your toast.The food came fast, and the service was great, and the place itself is very quaint. We will definitely be back!”

“The Diner and Jenn are always a great way to start my day. The comfort food breakfasts never disappoint. I appreciate the consistent service and meals that I have come to expect. If you are in need of a great country style breakfast and small town atmosphere, I highly recommend The Diner. They will not disappoint.”

“This was my first time here. This is a quaint hometown breakfast and lunch restaurant in New Carlisle, Indiana. Our booth had comfortable seats and it was situated right over one of the heat ducts which made itnice and warm the entire time we were there!. Our server was polite and checked on us often enough to keep our drinks filled. I had the BLT club sandwich which was a triple decker! It was grilled with butter on the outside slices of bread and the tomatoes were nice and ripe and it had ample bacon slices. It was actually the best BTL I’ve ever had! My husband had the BBQ pork sandwich and said it was very delicious. I highly recommend Jennie Rae’s for hometown good cooking!”

“Great food and service! Had the daily sandwich special (amazing bun) and cheese curds. Great place for food, and looked like plenty of craft beer options. Highly recommend.”

“I enjoyed breakfast this morning for the first time at This restaurant. The ladies were very kind and my biscuits and gravy was probably one of the best biscuits and gravy I’ve had up north.”

“Love this place. Sweet, friendly ladies baking up delectable concoctions. We picked up a pumpkin roll and were not disappointed! The best we have ever had. Great donuts and muffins, too! Pleasant atmosphere.”

“Great ice cream! Service was fine. Cashier seemed unhappy to be there, but I kinda don’t blame her. Get ice cream early as they run out of flavors as the day goes on.”

“Food is decent, typical diner food. We were the only customers at 1pm on a Saturday. $56 for 2 adults and 1 child to eat basic breakfast no extras. Service was just okay, waitress asked twice if we wanted coffee refills (yes we did) but never actually refilled; was busy chatting with the other employee.”

“We had dinner there with my husband's parents. The food was great. I had the Cordon Blue schnitzel. It was huge and the left overs made for a great lunch. They have a nice assortment of beer. My family enjoyed their beer. Love seeing the wait staff wearing traditional Austrian garb as well. Will definitely go back again”

“This has become a favorite place for us. The staff are always upbeat, friendly, and attentive. Just love Jim, the manager. Good food, reasonably priced; a nice experience!”

“Met the owner and her brother-in-law, first time visiting. They were so nice and when I had to run back in to get a special request after I had already left they gave it to me on the house. Great people. Great donuts. And I cannot wait to try the cannolis!”

“Food was a little pricey for the middle of nowhere but it was great. Best Reuben I've ever had...and I've had some good ones. Not sure if it was worth $18 but it was amazing. Actually liked the raspberry tea and I'm not a fan of flavored tea. Highly recommend!”

“Love exploring small towns USA. Quaint place with a view of Hudson Lake. Gorgeous views of the sunset. Delicious comfort food. The onion rings are killer. The Patty Melt was yummy. Friendly staff! Great service.”

“This subway is always super clean and good. The cashier Payton was super helpful and made my sandwich perfect! The service was outstanding. The food was a perfect temperature.”

“You would have to look far and wide to find better food. A great place to have a drink and actually be able to TALK with the people at your table. I wish you could smell this pizza!”

“Friday night fish. This was our first time but not the last. I had Walleye....huge portion, excellent taste, good potato salad, and fast service. My wife had the pollack and also had leftovers. No need to look for AYCE fish with portion sizes like this!”

“The pizza and breadsticks were absolutely amazing!!! I couldn’t get enough of either. I got a medium mushroom with extra cheese and I don’t normally eat a lot but I almost finished that pizza to myself! The service was great and staff was very friendly! The dine-in area was adorable and I absolutely loved the atmosphere there. Would definitely recommend to anyone that wants some good pizza!! ? ?”

“I usually go thru the drive thru, and they are always very pleasant and courteous.Kid-friendliness: I have been thereseveral times with me grandchildren, and they are always very nice to them.”

“A really good local coffee and pastry place. Their mocha was delicious and so was their cinnamon bun muffin. They had a s'mores flavor of the day and I wish I'd seen it before I ordered.”

“Tried something new, compared to my usual. It wasn't to bad, was definitely different. The price though just for the footlong alone was ridiculous though low. My footlong was the Cali sub (not sure the full name of it off the top of my head) But a footlong sub for that one was $14 on it's own...for $14 I expected more. Maybe it was also because of whoever made my sandwich squeezed the avocado spread out of the bad and barely put any on there. she also made it with lettuce and not spinach and the mozzarella were barely even warmed up on my sandwich. Overall, like I said it wasn't to bad, just could have been better if it was made the way it was supposed to be and maybe just a little warmer. Both my husbands and my sandwich were a MESS though. The lady that did the veggies to the sandwich practically made it like an open face sandwich. Now I know for sure that is not how you make those (I use to work for subway years ago). So that took it down a star automatically just because it was so hard to even try eating. The ladies were nice though and the atmosphere wasn't bad considering it was for their 4th of July parade day.”

“I ♡ the pizza pretzel with ranch dip, or the buggy bites in icing. They just opened a brand new restaurant inside. Looks nice, but when I visited, the trash was overflowing and tables dirty (I cleaned one myself). 2 guys were working. Please take care of this place!”

“I love this place. I placed an order for 4 extra large pizzas for the Career Academy Robotics club. I knew it was a tall order for a small kitchen but I just love their pizza so much Especially the Sharon their buffalo chicken pizza which I highly recommend. There was a little hiccup but the owner was extremely kind and compensating and we got our pizzas to the event on time and the kids gobbled them up. I told everyone there you have to try the perch and the Walleye .It's a down home regular friendly place that I love to visit. Fantastic food great value and friendly service”

“Nicest bartender in the world. Don’t even know his name. Red hair and and red beard. You helped a stranger in need and it will not be forgotten. Thank you, truly. The world needs more people like you. For this reason, I am saying everyone should come here. Friendly, good service, great music.”

“These are by far the best cupcakes ever. We have order several times and they are always fantastic. She also has gluten free cupcakes available and I have never tasted anything gluten free that is nearly as good as hers. Pies are awesome too!!”

“Best Popeyes I've ever been to. The restaurant is visibly kept clean. You must try the blackened chicken. Fries are hit or miss on freshness, but the chicken has always come out hot for us. Pricing is more than most of the other fast food options, but I think it's worth it!”

“China House is welcoming and on point with their service. They get you in and out the door with your food swiftly. I've never had issues with long wait times, and the food is always great!”