12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Greendale

“I had my wife pickup a pizza for me here a couple weeks ago. I wanted to try a new pizza place. I just got pepperoni that day. I was blown away. I typically like deluxe pizza so this weekend I ordered one. On the way to get it my wife told me how nice the people were when she picked up pizza last time. When I walked in to pick up my pizza, my wife’s statements were instantly backed up. The woman at the register immediately started speaking to me. She was incredibly delightful to speak with. Very personable. A man walked up front from the back and immediately started conversation. Same experience with him. Just a wonderful interaction. As a business owner myself and someone who loves talking to my own customers on this same level, I was very happy I came in here. Also the pizza was definitely the best I’ve had in a long time. I’m a new reoccurring customer.“

“this is been my go to spot 5 minutes from home watch the reds on TV they're at least three times a week great food great service and love the baseball game on right there at the bar can't beat it in greendale not a whole lot going on haha“

“Used to have my "go to" pizza place in the small town I grew up in. Good memories going there with dad and thought nothing will ever come close. Now I am a dad myself and take my family to comb's. Not the same place I used to go to but its awesome. Small, family run, awesome atmosphere, awesome people and good quality food for fair prices. Now all they needed is an old fashioned bubblegum machine and my kid begging for change and we are set to head down nostalgia road.“

“I really love to come and see the pizza being made right in front of me, Hannah wand Heather are the best, but when I was here last time, there was a blonde manager that stood next to my table complaining about customers to the employees, it was super awkward for me. Looked like it was awkward for the employees, too!“

“The young blonde lady that works during the day is so amazing, she is usually in there alone but she seems to handle the pressure very well! She is easy to make conversation with and she makes my pizzas sooo good! I will be a forever customer!“

“This particular time I got a large sausage with extra cheese...there having a sale and it was less than 11 dollars its always delicious the crust is soft and tasty enough that I actually eat it and they use plenty of cheese and there cheese blend it great its chewy and satisfying...my favorite pizza“

“You can't go wrong with Primetime! We have family and friends from out of town who don't want to go out to eat when they get here...just order Primetime! I have never had a bad experience with our food, servers, or drivers. I crave this pizza like no other! So good!“

“The food was great, the service was excellent and my wife and I had a great time! My only criticism is that the restaurant needs more atmosphere and maybe some Italian style pictures decorating the wall to give that 'Italian feeling'.“

“LOVE the food, and I've always had great service... Until tonight. I've been coming here since their original location in the old roller rink - so what, about twenty yrs? I've never been met with such rude service. Upon calling tonight to put in our order, my husband started giving our order to a young woman and she yelled "BRIDGET I NEED TO GO TO THE BATHROOM AFTER THIS ORDER".... This is in the middle of us giving her our order; not even a full 60 seconds into our phone call. Then about minute later, while in the middle of ordering another item (not even kidding, we were mid-sentence) she says HALLIE DID YOU GET IT? I mean she paid attention to everyone BUT us. She didn't even ask if we were done ordering and said "Okay your total is..." and we had to say, uh, we aren't done ordering?I immediately called back and spoke with Bridget who stated she was effectively supervisor on duty for the night. She was apologetic and ensured our order was correct, but boy oh boy will I rethink my next visit here if they don't care about my business enough to give me 3 minutes of their time to take my order with their full attention.*Edit 3/2: upon picking up our order, they had given our food to someone else. So my husband had to wait an additional 30 minutes for it all to be remade. Bridget handled it well, I appreciate her empathy and ownership of the situation, but it does little to make our overall experience tonight a positive one. Disappointing.*Edit 3/4: John the owner quickly remedied the situation, which makes ALL the difference when dealing with a business. Updating my review to 4 stars. Thank you John for your quick ownership and efficient handling of the situation!!“

“Their food is absolutely delicious! My daughter ESPECIALLY loves the Junior Beast and their "cookie pie". Just don't plan to eat in. They only have one booth, but for us, that's not a problem. We always take it to go. Whether it's to home, or for a picnic. I would DEFINITELY suggest giving them a try. Absolutely worth it! ???“

“Food was prepared asordered and was good. Had to wait a few minutes at the counter to order, ordered a pizza to go. Went to the restroom while I was waiting; very nasty. With the signs I saw up in several places they are apparently very short on help.“

“My first time at Snappy's ?. Employee very friendly, informative and patient. Quickly fixed me the exact Pizza I wanted. Prices on par with all the other ? joints. I got the ultimate and there were plenty of toppings and the crust was nice and soft. I can't wait to try more items from the menu ?!“