Customers` Favorites
Customers` Favorites
“down to earth and awesome atmosphere. the owner rocks she is amazing“
Customers` Favorites
“I really like the burgers. They are way better and don't cost an arm and a leg like that other burger place in Highland. Everyone that works there seems friendly. My waitress, Karen, was super fast and seemed really nice.“
Customers` Favorites
“Excellent pizza!! Friendly service our family favorite!!“
Customers` Favorites
“Love the atmosphere and the owner and staff is wonderful. The food is delicious 😋“
Customers` Favorites
“Ordered our own buffet bowl! Food was awesome. Some many choices. PACK your bowl FULL. Pick your base. Pick your sauce. They do the rest. Comes with soup and salad. Will be back! Had enough carryout for another meal.“
Customers` Favorites
“Always check hours online - and watch your step when you walk in the front door. There are a ton of food items on this menu - including a refrigerated section for soup, frozen pierogies, and there are other salads and desserts.
You do get a discount if you pay in CASH.
I tried some pierogis - potato and sweet cheese. They appear to be fried as they are a bit crunchy, but I like them like that. They are pretty full pierogis. You can order them frozen to go home and cook on your own - or have them cooked to order.
I also got the order of polish sausage w/kraut and some fries. The polish sausage is snappy and the kraut is great. The bun I could do without, but I just removed it and ate on it's own. The fries were salty with a mix of crispy and soggy ones.
I will definitely be back to try more options and more pierogis!
Inside is small, but they added some extra eating in the room next door. You can dine in if you wish, it never seemed too crowded.“
Customers` Favorites
“Had such an amazing time with my mother to celebrate her birthday!! Will come again!! <3“
Customers` Favorites
“Best nachos. Tacos are great. Burritos we're phenomenal. First timer, I will be back. Customer service was great.“
Customers` Favorites
“Prices are great! They were busy but the servers and manager still came around to all of the tables. They shared all responsibilities to make sure the tables were taken care of.“
Customers` Favorites
“Great food“
Customers` Favorites
“Good Mexican food served fast. My go-to for Tortas and Tacos.“
Customers` Favorites
“Pizza here has always been good, we've never had a problem. My family and I have ordered here many times.
Parking: The parking lot is shared with other businesses in a strip mall type lot.
Kid-friendliness: I've never met a kid that didn't like pizza, chicken strips or fries which is all something they have.“
Customers` Favorites
“I took it home to eat, very hot, delicious & plentiful. Leftovers tomorrow!“
Customers` Favorites
“I'm a pro vs con review
Pro
From scratch food
Old school relish tray
Scratch soup
Delicious old school recipes
Great staff
Great service
Amazing martinis at a great price
Owner pitch in when needed
Con
Old and tired atmosphere
Owner is grumpy
Owner needs you to make a reservation
Owner needs help, I understand his issues but needs to be pushed. If not, he will not make another 75 years. Xoxo
Ps
I want this beautiful restaurant to succeed“
Customers` Favorites
“This place and there staff are wonderful and sweet and kind!! The boss lady was very sweet too! I have only ordered today would be my second time and the pizza was great, im not a pizza person but my daughter snagged a slice while we were on our way home an i ate some to and it was the tastiest most delicious pizza ive ever had by the time i got home i ate 5 slices lol, also they fixed my order with a smile and no hesitation thank you, you all are amazing and have great customer service! FIVE STARS⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“
Customers` Favorites
“Steve does everything right! Servers are very good and the food is awesome. Ya gotta try their fries. ?“
Customers` Favorites
“Our server Ramiro Angel was the kindest soul we ever met, this restaurant is so blessed to have such a great worker! My friends and I came on a Monday and the food was amazing, but the service just made it the best experience! Thank you for a great service, you are an awesome cool dude Ramiro !! ❤️🙌🏽“
Customers` Favorites
“It's clean, the wait staff is well-trained and well-mannered, and the food is tasty and well-prepared. It's a family business, and one of the owners is usually present. I have never had an unpleasant experience in any of their three locations in NW Indiana (Highland, Schererville, Merrillville). Prices are decent; what one would expect to pay for a better-than-average breakfast and lunch venue, but not too costly. Try it. You'll like it!“
Customers` Favorites
“{{restaurant.reviews}}“
Loading...
“We have Been at Theo’s at least 20 times in the last 3 years. The first time was the best and last night was the last. Food was a lot better 3 years ago. The staff seemed like they cared about you buying the right or the best value, Last night we were ripped off. David was our server. Telling how great the specials were with out telling us the price. My wife wanted seafood not steak. So we ordered her the seafood crab legs, lobster tail and shrimp. Crab legs tasted like they were frozen for a long time, the lobster was Tuff. Shrimp was good in garlic butter. I had a steak. With mushrooms. Do your self a favor ask what the price for any specials . DON’T BUY ANYTHING WITHOUT KNOWING THE PRICE. SeaFood Special $175.66 Who the hell charges this for a pound of crab legs and a lobster tail? Never again! Buyer beware!“