Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge

Name: Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge
Address: 1101 English Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46203, US
Telephone: (317) 600-3336
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$$ • Steakhouses, Cocktail Bar, Seafood

Hours:
1101 English Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 600-3336

Menu Order Online

About Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge

Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge offers an incredible dining experience with wonderful food and fantastic service. The rustic and beautifully decorated restaurant provides a quiet and intimate atmosphere, making it an ideal spot to celebrate special occasions. The restaurant's hospitality and attention to detail have been praised by customers, who describe their dining experiences as extraordinary and memorable.

The menu features a variety of delectable dishes, including oysters, French onion soup, Chateaubriand, and decadent chocolate cake. Customers have also raved about the impeccable service, interesting cocktails, and delicious sides like fries and glazed carrots. The restaurant's filet mignon has been acclaimed as one of the best in the city, and the bread pudding has been described as amazing. Many guests have enjoyed their first experience, with staff providing excellent care during dinner in the dining room. They appreciated the wine, Caesar salad, asparagus, au gratin potatoes, bread pudding for dessert, and the tasty coffee service. Others have mentioned that the cocktails were on point, meat cooked to perfection, and service attentive, kind, and fun—highlighting desserts like crème brûlée as a must-try. The beef wellington is highly recommended, with some describing it as nirvana and a moment of bliss they would sell their first-born to experience again.

Recent reviews highlight the delightful atmosphere and quality of the food. Guests enjoyed spontaneous dinners post Colts game, splitting a wedge salad and filet, with large portions and wonderful bread service. Mushrooms were praised as some of the best in Indy, and the bartender was charming and fun to talk to. Another visitor celebrated their anniversary and husband's birthday with a memorable meal, choosing Geraldine's for its reputation for great steaks and celebrations. They received a signed card, house-made raspberry sorbet, and birthday truffles, adding a special touch. The steaks, including Wyoming filet and dry-aged Delmonico ribeye, were cooked to perfection and considered some of the best beef they ever had. The au gratin potatoes and creamed spinach complemented the meal well. A live piano performance with love ballads and standards added warmth and beauty to the evening. Customers often describe Geraldine's as a hidden gem and their favorite steakhouse in Indianapolis, praising the laid-back vibe and attentive service of staff like Misty, the general manager. Overall, Geraldine's Supper Club & Lounge continues to impress with fantastic food, drinks, and a welcoming atmosphere, making it a top choice for romantic evenings and special celebrations.