Greiner's SubShop
2126 Shelby St, Indianapolis
(317) 783-4136
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Mac and Cheese Fries and Sea Salt Brownie
Mr Turkey Dressed Old School
Owen's Philly Cheese Steak
Doyvke Steak and Cheese
Fire Guy's BBQ Chicken
Italian Beef Sandwich
Ray’S 1969 Hoagie
The Original Genie
Ray's 1969 Hoagie
Chocolate Brownie
Menu
Photos
+69 photos
+68 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Idk microwaving some of the sandwiches parts aka meatballs don't know if there frozen but seemed like it was weird and the onion rings tasted like mashed baby food tasted like cheap frozen ones maybe I just got the wrong sandwich going again to try a normal sub to see if it's better but the 2 things I got were not it.
We recently moved to Indy and have been on the hunt for the best sub place. Just found it! Definitely get the Mac and cheese and a dessert as well. The gentleman behind the counter went above and beyond for us. (thank you if you see this)
Absolutely fantastic! Got the Italian beef and the original sub, absolute 10/10 a must try! The man running the place at the time threw in a few homemade cookies for us to try and had us try this Carmel Oreo cake he made. It absolutely blew my mind. The desserts there are incredible and worth totally going out of your way for!!
You May Also Like
Baba’s fish, chicken Food Mart - 2133 Shelby St
![]()
Chicken Wings, Mexican
Sam's Fish and Chicken - 2133 Shelby St
![]()
Chicken Wings, Fish & Chips, Mexican
White Castle - 2165 Shelby St
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers