Greiner's SubShop
2126 Shelby St, Indianapolis
(317) 783-4136
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Mac and Cheese Fries and Sea Salt Brownie
Mr Turkey Dressed Old School
Owen's Philly Cheese Steak
Doyvke Steak and Cheese
Fire Guy's BBQ Chicken
Italian Beef Sandwich
Ray’S 1969 Hoagie
The Original Genie
Ray's 1969 Hoagie
Chocolate Brownie
Menu
Photos
+54 photos
+53 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Holy cow! This place is amazing. Too say they overload ya is an understatement. I had the 8 inch Italian and could only finish 1/2 of it. Definitely a winner in my opinion. Check em out
I visited Greiner’s SubShop for the first time today. It was an all female team behind the counter, and the atmosphere they created was something I will remember. It was a special balance of strong, independent women working hard, blended with the warmth you feel when someone you care about is preparing a meal for you in their kitchen. I watched the owner, Lisa, work with a particularly tough customer. She handled his difficult nature with grace and kindness, elegantly defusing...
10/10 Hoagie. I’ve been looking for a quality Pennsylvania style sandwich. I’m from eastern PA and it’s hard to find something to scratch that itch. And this was it. I love that they have sides other than chips. The meatball? Give me 14 of them. I’ll tear it up live.
You May Also Like
Baba’s fish, chicken Food Mart - 2133 Shelby St
![]()
Chicken Wings, Mexican
Sam's Fish and Chicken - 2133 Shelby St
![]()
Chicken Wings, Fish & Chips, Mexican
White Castle - 2165 Shelby St
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers