J's Lobster & Fish Market

906 Carrollton Ave #370, Indianapolis
(855) 562-7655

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Lobster Mac and Cheese
Lobster Grilled Cheese
Side of Mac and Cheese
Lobster Grill Cheese
Blue Crab Roll
The Works Roll
Lobster Bisque
Hush Puppies
Clam Chowder
Lobster Roll

Menu

New England Favorites Menu
The Works Roll
Our famous toasted bun with a generous strip of black truffle mayo, shredded lettuce, and filled with equal portions of lobster, blue crab, and shrimp drizzled with warm butter and a dash of Old Bay Seasoning.
Lobster Roll
Our famous toasted bun with a strip of mayo, shredded lettuce, chunks of coleslaw & knuckle lobster meat drizzled with warm butter and a dash of old bay seasoning.
Blue Crab Roll
Toasted bun with a strip of mayo, shredded lettuce filled with blue crab meat, drizzled with warm butter and a dash of Old Bay Seasoning.
Shrimp Roll
Toasted bun with a strip of mayo and shredded lettuce filled with shrimp, drizzled with warm butter and a dash of Old Bay Seasoning.

Soups
Lobster Bisque
Made in Boston, MA.
New England Clam Chowder
Made in Boston, MA.

Sides
Hush Puppies
Seasoned Grilled Broccoli
Basket of Fries
Potato Chips
Mac & Cheese
Coleslaw
Made in-house.

Dessert Rolls
Cinnamon Sugar Dessert Roll

J's Specialties
NOT Fish & Chips
Crab cakes served on a bed of fries and our "soon to be famous tartar sauce"
Clam Chowder Queso Nachos
Cheesy Fries
Seasoned fries with cheese sauce, sour cream, bacon bits, and green onion with your choice of seafood.
Fish Tacos
Fried cod with spicy aoli, lettuce and homemade pico topped with cilantro on a warm flour tortilla.
Mac & Cheese

Sammiches
Lobster B.L.T.
The name says it all! Comes with Potato Chips & Coleslaw
The L.G.C. (Lobster Grilled Cheese)
Buttered and toasted hearty country white bread with melted aged Vermont cheddar cheese, chunks of claw & knuckle lobster meat and house sauce. Comes with Potato Chips & Coleslaw
Fish Sammich
Cod fish on a brioche bun, shredded lettuce, pickle and our "soon to be famous tartar sauce". Served with Potato chips & Coleslaw
A Simply Classic Tuna Melt
We use American Cheese. Your inner Child will thank us.

Lighter Fare (Gluten Free)
Chopped Salad
Iceberg lettuce with tomato, red onion, carrot, hard boiled egg, and shredded cheese.
Honey Chipotle Grilled Shrimp
Sauteed shrimp with a chipotle rub and topped with a honey butter sauce. Served with a side of rice and house salad.
Shrimp Cocktail
A classic....need we say more.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+10 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+9 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I don’t know how this place could get less than 5 stars. I’ve had a bunch of lobster in my life and this was some of the best I’ve ever had. So good we came back again the next day bc I wanted it again. Highly recommend the lobster roll.
June 2025
I was really intrigued by all the lobster items over here and husband really wanted to try the Lobster Mac & Cheese so that's what we got.

The mac and cheese itself was quite creamy and cheesy, but I wasn't a fan of how the lobster went with it.
But I think that's just me the topic of seafood related pastas.
Husband definitely enjoyed this though!
March 2025
I got the Works Roll with fries. For $45 it was ok. My cold sandwich was put on top of hot fries in a plastic container. It took me about 20 min to get home. Bread was soggy by the time I got to it. I couldn't tell if it was really toasted but it was buttery.
Shrimp & lobster on sandwich were good but crab was bland. There was no Old Bay seasoning (or any other seasoning). Sandwich also had too much mayo. Bread was the only thing with flavor.

Price...
September 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Lil Dumplings Noodle Bar - 926 Carrollton Ave
Ramen, Noodles, Asian Fusion, Vegetarian
Mama Fofo’s Greek Kitchen - 926 Carrollton Ave
Greek
Abbiocco Pizzeria - 906 Carrollton Ave suite 385
Pizza, Peruvian

J's Lobster & Fish Market

906 Carrollton Ave #370, Indianapolis, IN 46202
(855) 562-7655