Pots & Pans Pie Co.

Name: Pots & Pans Pie Co.
Address: 4915 N College Ave, Indianapolis, Indiana, 46205, US
Telephone: (317) 600-3475
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.5

$$ • Bakery, Gluten-Free, Vegan

Hours:
4915 N College Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 600-3475

Menu Order Online

About Pots & Pans Pie Co.

Pots & Pans Pie Co. offers delicious sweet and savory pies, including their standout Thai Chicken Curry pie, known for its bold flavors and spicy kick. The establishment is praised for its exceptional crust, reminiscent of a cherished family recipe. Customers often praise the flaky, buttery crust, which is baked to perfection and considered exactly how pie crust should be. Their variety of pies includes the Sugar Creme Brulee Pie and Peaches & Almond Cream Pie, both noted for their well-balanced fillings. The shop also features other savory options like mac and cheese and pork chili, served in pie tins, although some find the mac and cheese may be heavy on pepper.

Recently, customers have enjoyed hand pies such as the singara and spicy sausage & tomato, with the singara being described as a giant samosa with a cozy spice mix, while the spicy sausage & tomato hand pie has a cream sauce that elevates the flavor. The restaurant’s mini pies, used at events like wedding receptions, have received high praise, with many guests commenting on their outstanding quality. Customers appreciate the unique and seasonal flavors of their dessert pies, which keep the menu fresh and attractive to both new and returning visitors. The chocolate chip shortbread cookies are admired for their perfect size and freshness. Many consider the pies to be the best they've ever had, with some suggesting that Pots & Pans Pie Co. deserves a Michelin star. While the overall quality is highly praised, some feel that the price per slice could be better justified based on their experiences. The friendly service adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a favorite stop for those looking for the tastiest pies around.