What are you looking for?

Italian Restaurants in Michigan City

4.7 - 118 votes

Hours: 12 - 8PM

822 N Karwick Rd, Michigan City
(219) 878-0458

Papa Johns Pizza

Good lord. The best Italian I've had in a very long time. Great value for what you are getting. Everything tastes fresh and made with love. Very hig... More reviews

4.1 - 598 votes

Hours: 4 - 10PM

3311 Pottawattomie Trail, Michigan City
(219) 874-7729

Papa Johns Pizza

Service very slow and not attentive, linguine extremely salty, not edible, calamari was the best out of the whole meal. Parmesan cheese not offered, no s... More reviews

3.9 - 139 votes

Hours: 4PM - 12AM

2400 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 872-9123

Papa Johns Pizza

This is definitely the best pizza in Michigan City. Most things are made from scratch and absolutely delicious! More reviews

3.9 - 202 votes

Hours: 11AM - 11PM

4441 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 879-6830

Papa Johns Pizza

Came in to test out the endless pasta for myself and had a pretty good experience. The staff member who attended my fiancee and I was very sweet and did ... More reviews

3.3 - 49 votes

515 Franklin St, Michigan City
(219) 243-7181

Papa Johns Pizza

Visiting town from Chicago. The staff at Shady Creek Winery recommended we try here for dinner and it was a win! Cute decor on the inside. They were unde... More reviews

View on map