23 Best Italian Restaurants near Portage

“This place is a 10/10 my first experience was with my fiancée and everything was wonderful. Today I took my kids and Ms. Donna is truly amazing. Her customer service, conversation and humor was everything. She’s so sweet and very friendly and professional. It’s a great vibe and food has always been so delicious and fulfilling. Ms Donna were appreciate you and loved our interaction with you. You are truly wonderful person thank you for being you. Cappos we’ll be back again soon!!“

“Perfect pizza as usual. Thank you. Drove 140 miles home and it was still perfect. Just warmed it back up in my air fryer. Thank you Jill“

“What a perfect delicious pizza [Original] What a perfect delicious pizza“

“Nick, the owner of Albano’s, showed our family a level of generosity we will never forget. I reached out to him to cater my mom’s 75th birthday. She comes from an Italian family her grandfather emigrated from Alessandria del Carretto and she is very particular about her Italian food. Albano’s is by far her favorite restaurant and truly blows every other place out of the water. This birthday meant so much because my mom hasn’t been well. I wanted it to be special and intimate. When my husband picked up the food, Nick insisted we not pay. We were completely overwhelmed by his kindness. The food was absolutely incredible and everyone raved about it. We can never thank Nick enough. If you want authentic Italian food made with heart, Albano’s is the place.“

“fast service and cheap good food“

“Went on Valentines Day, was told about an hour wait, gave them my phone number and was going to get a call when my table was ready. They had a cancellation and my table was ready in 15 minutes, not bad for 4PM on a Saturday during V-Day. Food was absolutely delicious, good portions, service was great. It was very busy but they were 100% on top of things, can't wait to go back.“

“We went tonight for the igloo experience. It was wonderful and the staff were very attentive! The igloo lights, music, and atmosphere were perfect for our date night. The food was also great. Highly recommend.“

“5stars!!! Superb crab cakes, lamb and crème brûlée. Will be back soon. Congratulations to Jesus, the new chef.“

“Had a great experience!
I’ve heard mixed reviews about dining here but I wanted to make my own judgement. I’m very glad I did, the food was delicious.
To start we had the big mozz, which is HUGE but delicious. For our sides we got the truffle fries and ceasar salad. The sides were also a big portion and very tasty! For our mains we got the brisket tortellini and bolognese. We both enjoyed our meals but the tortellini with the vodka sauce was amazing. My husband kept stealing bites for himself. The portions were large and we have plenty of leftovers.

Looking forward to my next visit 😊“

“01/2026: The main food was delicious, as always. I had the spaghetti and meatballs 🍝 this time. The servers were nice, however, it was impossible for them to bring breadsticks that were not cold and hard. I gave up after 2 requests and just used one as crackers for my soup.“

“Seems like we were the only ones amongst our foodie friends who had not been to Pizza Terra. Well we dined there Thursday and savored everything we had. The Brussels Sprouts and Waigu meatballs are must haves. Pasta dishes were tasty and plentiful. Can’t wait to back!!“

“Always a great experience dining in or carrying out. Love how fresh and delicious the ingredients are. From starters, to salad, wraps, calzones, or pizza. We’re always happy with whatever we get and it’s such a fun place to bring our kids too. Love the beer options as well. Thanks for making us happy customers.“

“Aliyah was an amazing waitress. It was incredibly busy for a Tuesday night but she kept her head held high! She kept our drinks full and served our food hot. We would love to have her as our server every time!!“

“My husband and I tried Semento's for the first time last night. We were amazed by the entire experience. We were greeted by friendly staff, seated promptly, waitress (Stephanie L) provided excellent service, and the food was hot and delicious!! We ordered an app, my husband had the prime rib, I ordered the patty melt, and we both had a cocktail. Everything was delicious! The music was a little loud but appropriate for the atmosphere. We could still chat and enjoy our meals. The portions were hearty and I took home the leftovers with actual intention of eating later because it was so good! Cost was reasonable for the amount of food we received. Everything was clean, even the restroom. We will definitely return!“

“The pizza had a perfect crust—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The toppings were fresh and generous, making each bite delicious. The atmosphere was relaxed, and the staff were friendly and welcoming. If you're looking for a great pizza place in Valparaiso, Uncle Menny's is definitely worth checking out!“

“the pizza always comes super hot and super delicious! and stuffed pizza?! I thought it meant stuffed crust, so I was like yeah we can try it. ohh man was it so good! cant stop ordering it that way!“

“excellent food excellent service the portions are huge be prepared to take home leftovers! I ordered the cheese sticks they were so good I took an order home for later I had the Italian beef sandwich it was awesome and my wife had the chicken alfredo she loved it all this for under $50 is unbelievable we will be back!“

“I had an antipasta salad and brownie.
The antipasta was delicious with the raspberry vinegrette, it is also enough for me to eat again tomorrow. I also got one of their house brownies, which was unlike any brownie I've ever had before. Awesome presentation on the brownie too, it stayed in place on its way here.
Ice cold pop wrapped in foil. Refreshing and low priced.“

“stopped by as our son wanted a Chicago style pizza, and I wasn't driving into Chicago. it was amazing. the young lady that was serving us was great at her job, overall great experience“

“Very good experience at sbarro this morning. We arrived at about 11:10, right after opening, and all of the food was out and fresh. Everything looked amazing-we wanted it all. We ended up trying the pizza, spaghetti with meatballs, and breadsticks and it was all so good. The workers were also very friendly and quick. Would definitely go back“

“My daughter and I picked a random place today, and we ended up here. Definitely didn’t know what to expect, and the menu had so many choice it was hard to decide ( a good thing )!!! The waitress was super helpful and super nice!!! My food was so good! And the portions were enough for leftovers. I will definitely try this place again. 👍“

“Unfortunately I hadn’t been ordering from this Rosati’s, although it’s been in my backyard. I’d had it in the past but due to unhappiness with service, and seeing negative reviews I hadn’t ordered in years.

This past weekend I had a specific craving for Chicago style thin crust pizza. My spouse suggested we give it a try. Wow! It blew us both away by how good the pizza was. It was everything we wanted and more. The “fabulous four” (Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, and onion) was mouthwateringly delicious! The Italian sausage savory and the veggies were so fresh. It was even better the next day, reheated in our toaster oven. The other pizza was fantastic too. Along with the few appetizers we ordered. Their marinara sauce tastes so fresh and is the perfect balance of savory and just a hint of sweet.

I cannot believe we haven’t been ordering from here for so long but now that we’ve had it again and tasted the quality we will be loyal customers. It’s a littler more price wise than our local chains around here like Domino’s but I promise you, if you like Chicago style thin crust and quality ingredients it is so worth it. The best part is getting an authentic Chicago pizza without traveling to the city.“

“Great service from employees, pizza and wings are also delicious! Will come back.“