23 Best Italian Restaurants near Portage

1 Cappo's

4.3 Superb 374 Reviews

6656 West U.S. Hwy 6, Portage

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This place is a 10/10 my first experience was with my fiancée and everything was wonderful. Today I took my kids and Ms. Donna is truly amazing. Her customer service, conversation and humor was everything. She’s so sweet and very friendly and professional. It’s a great vibe and food has always been so delicious and fulfilling. Ms Donna were appreciate you and loved our interaction with you. You are truly wonderful person thank you for being you. Cappos we’ll be back again soon!!”

2 Aurelio's Pizza

3.9 Good 262 Reviews

6500 West U.S. Hwy 6, Portage

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Perfect pizza as usual. Thank you. Drove 140 miles home and it was still perfect. Just warmed it back up in my air fryer. Thank you Jill”

3 Gelsosomo's Pizzeria

3.9 Good 318 Reviews

5023 US-6, Portage

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“What a perfect delicious pizza [Original] What a perfect delicious pizza”

4 Albano's Pasta Shop

4.8 Superb 471 Reviews

22 Washington Street, Valparaiso · 9.45 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food and atmosphere; a must try for anyone in the Valpo area!”

5 Fazoli's

4.7 Superb 417 Reviews

2809 Calumet Avenue, Valparaiso · 8.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“fast service and cheap good food”

6 Pesto's Italian Restaurant

4.5 Superb 407 Reviews

3123 Calumet Avenue, Valparaiso · 8.73 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Not only was the restaurant atmosphere lovely but the food was simply delicious, the portions more than generous and our waitress was pleasant and helpful!!!”

7 Lia's Bella Cucina

4.6 Superb 83 Reviews

401 Broadway Avenue, Chesterton · 6.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We went tonight for the igloo experience. It was wonderful and the staff were very attentive! The igloo lights, music, and atmosphere were perfect for our date night. The food was also great. Highly recommend.”

8 Tomato Bar Pizza Bakery

4.7 Superb 353 Reviews

2310 Laporte Avenue, Valparaiso · 10.56 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Always a great experience dining in or carrying out. Love how fresh and delicious the ingredients are. From starters, to salad, wraps, calzones, or pizza. We’re always happy with whatever we get and it’s such a fun place to bring our kids too. Love the beer options as well. Thanks for making us happy customers.”

9 Lucrezia Café

4.3 Superb 354 Reviews

428 South Calumet Road, Chesterton · 6.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“5stars!!! Superb crab cakes, lamb and crème brûlée. Will be back soon. Congratulations to Jesus, the new chef.”

10 Pizza Terra

4.7 Superb 243 Reviews

302 Melton Road, Burns Harbor · 3.14 miles

“Seems like we were the only ones amongst our foodie friends who had not been to Pizza Terra. Well we dined there Thursday and savored everything we had. The Brussels Sprouts and Waigu meatballs are must haves. Pasta dishes were tasty and plentiful. Can’t wait to back!!”

11 Cafe Farina Valparaiso

4.2 Good 109 Reviews

55 Franklin Street, Valparaiso · 9.62 miles

• Delivery

“What an amazing Italian Cafe’ in downtown Valparaiso!! Chris, the GM, the waitstaff, the kitchen…AMAZING! Delicious food, great cocktails and wine and over the top customer service! They fed an out town Oakland University Volleyball team and staff in less than an hour on a Friday night! Downtown Valpo is adorable and Cafe’Farina Valparaiso was “icing on the cake”!”

12 Semento's

4.5 Superb 244 Reviews

1200 West Street, Valparaiso · 9.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I went in for carry out and was greeted immediately. Granted its a slower night but Tony was super professional and even jumped in to get my food going. I happened to notice the manager and flagged to tell him how great his staff was, clean the place is, and how we were looking forward to our meal. Turned out his name was Tony and he was going around making sure the lights were perfect, the orders were right and guests were greeted. Truly refreshing to see people taking such pride and enjoyment out of their job and serving great quality. A new favorite place for us to go and the price is exceptional for the great quality and tasty food. Check it out!”

13 T's Pizza & Family Restaurant

4.5 Superb 234 Reviews

840 East 3rd Street, Hobart · 4.74 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“the pizza always comes super hot and super delicious! and stuffed pizza?! I thought it meant stuffed crust, so I was like yeah we can try it. ohh man was it so good! cant stop ordering it that way!”

14 Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.1 Good 506 Reviews

1900 Southlake Mall, Merrillville · 10.1 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“had an amazing time and great food. the portions were great for the price. plus the waiter me and my partner had was amazing at his job and treated us great. the only reason i didnt give atmosphere 5/5 is because they were packed and did not have enough waiters on staff so they were a little slow but otherwise i would definitely come again.”

15 Santini's Pizza And Wings

4.5 Superb 167 Reviews

390 West U.S. Hwy 6 Ste G, Valparaiso · 2.59 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We have used them for several parties. I usually call my order in early and ask to have it delivered at a certain time and it is always delivered on time. We love the pizza and wings and always get compliments on how good the food is at the party! Highly recommend!”

16 Val's Famous Pizza & Grinders

4.4 Superb 298 Reviews

112 South 11th Street, Chesterton · 6.16 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Aliyah was an amazing waitress. It was incredibly busy for a Tuesday night but she kept her head held high! She kept our drinks full and served our food hot. We would love to have her as our server every time!!”

17 South Shore Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 169 Reviews

213 Broadway Avenue, Chesterton · 6.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“excellent food excellent service the portions are huge be prepared to take home leftovers! I ordered the cheese sticks they were so good I took an order home for later I had the Italian beef sandwich it was awesome and my wife had the chicken alfredo she loved it all this for under $50 is unbelievable we will be back!”

18 Uncle Menny's Original Greek's Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 160 Reviews

59 Indiana Avenue, Valparaiso · 9.6 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The pizza had a perfect crust—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The toppings were fresh and generous, making each bite delicious. The atmosphere was relaxed, and the staff were friendly and welcoming. If you're looking for a great pizza place in Valparaiso, Uncle Menny's is definitely worth checking out!”

19 Gelsosomo's Pizzeria Chesterton

4.2 Good 304 Reviews

371 Indian Boundary Road # B, Chesterton · 7.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“stopped by as our son wanted a Chicago style pizza, and I wasn't driving into Chicago. it was amazing. the young lady that was serving us was great at her job, overall great experience”

20 Palermos of 63rd Merrillville IN

3.9 Good 113 Reviews

2893 East 81st Avenue, Merrillville · 9.75 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My daughter and I picked a random place today, and we ended up here. Definitely didn’t know what to expect, and the menu had so many choice it was hard to decide ( a good thing )!!! The waitress was super helpful and super nice!!! My food was so good! And the portions were enough for leftovers. I will definitely try this place again. 👍”

21 Aurelio's Pizza of Valparaiso

3.5 Good 124 Reviews

265 West Morthland Drive, Valparaiso · 9.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great service from employees, pizza and wings are also delicious! Will come back.”

22 Sbarro

3.0 Average 63 Reviews

2288 Southlake Mall, Merrillville · 10.14 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have been waiting to try your pizza! It was worth the wait! 5 stars!!!!”

23 Rosati's Pizza

3.6 Good 178 Reviews

1411 South Lake Park Avenue, Hobart · 6.05 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“My mother was in the hospital across the street from the restaurant, we were tired, stressed and hungry. The food and service were a great comfort. We were given so much food we had plenty for 3 days. My mother said it was some of the best spaghetti she has ever eaten in all of her 86 year. We didn't take the time to take photos”