13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Middlebury

“We had the pizza, I believe this is their thing. The pizza was good. It was what you expect from pizza. What separated them, in my opinion, was the amount of toppings for the price. There was so much cheese and topping that it was hard for the crust to hold it all.“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Yes, in this tiny little town, I had the best pizza I had for years. They do pizza right by heaps of cheese and toppings, not bread! While everyone else props their crust, the bread, Piccadilly Circus Pizza puts the focus where it should be, cheese, cheese, and more cheese. Delicious!“

“Awesome friendly staff, I between Middlebury, Ligonier, and Lagrange pizza hut's Middlebury is the most consistent in quality to me. Haven't gotten one uneven pizza where there are gaps of missing cheese or toppings missing. In my experience.“

“The best pizza we have ever had and the service was phenomenal!! Willa was our waitress and she was amazing. Old fashion was top 10 ever had as well. We will be back soon!!“

“The pizza is great, my favorite is the buffalo chicken bacon ranch or New York White. All of the appetizers are good, but I think the cheesy garlic bread is best. A solid selection of beer that updates occasionally, plus great bartenders like Molly and Spencer who mix excellent drinks. The staff is always friendly and welcoming.“

“We were staying at a hotel nearby and noticed Shipshe Pizza. Convenient location, ample parking, delicious pizza , wings and salads. We watched a family enjoying the miniature golf. We will return for more good food.“

“We visited shipshewana for a long weekend and ate here twice. Food was good, warm, just enough sauce on the pizza. Friendly staff. Very clean facilities that I can see. The salad bar was very good. I would highly recommend this place.“

“Service was fast! Pleasant! Food was delicious!!!!“

“Went in this last Friday to get my pickup order I had called in. Soon as I walked In I seen a guy with tattoos all over his arms wipe BBQ off a ready to bake pizza with no gloves on… then licked his two fingers, the one finger went all the way in his mouth, and licked another part of his hand, the dug his hand into the meat and continued making coustomers pizzas. Disgusting! Absolutely disgusting… not a single person at this place had a pair of gloves on… sad…sad…sad… this was the Goshen location by the way right down town ..310 north Main Street.“

“some good stuff and convenient at most stores I love it“

“Great service and friendly staff. Even being shorthanded, they were prompt. The food was great as usual!!“

“They told me my total bill was $19.30, and I paid by card. The cashier rings it up and hands me a slip to sign, the total is now over $20. It was the credit card 4% they neglected to tell me about although they do have a couple of sentences explaining the card fee on the counter. I'm guessing most people pay by card, so just raise all your prices by $1.00 to cover the card cost.Nobody likes surprises, but don't lie to me about the total. If the total is $19.30 (and that total is spoken by the Gerace's employee), then the total is $19.30, nothing more, nothing less.“