9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shipshewana

“some good stuff and convenient at most stores I love it“

“We were a group of eight who went in on the Saturday before Christmas at 5:00. We were visiting from Indy and wanted some good pizza. This place did not disappoint! The buffet was constantly stocked and the salad bar had a good variety. Our little kids enjoyed the breadsticks and dessert pizza. Most importantly, we realized on Sunday (after returning to Indy) that we had left our diaper bag at the restaurant. Obviously, we were not going to make the trip back. The owner kindly offered to ship it to us and despite me asking to pay for it, she declined. We were truly so appreciative of this kind gesture. Anytime we are back in shipshewana, we will return for the great food and good service. Thank you for your kindness during the holidays.“

“We were in Middlebury to have warranty work on our RV. Decided to try their pizza on Tuesday. It was delicious and a good price! Since it was so good, we decided to try the wings the next night. They were different than what we have in NC. We like ours cooked where the skin is crispy. Not sure how these were cooked but had to pull the skin off. They should probably cook them in an air fryer to get crispy then add sauce. Would not recommend the wings but the pizza was delicious!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Yes, in this tiny little town, I had the best pizza I had for years. They do pizza right by heaps of cheese and toppings, not bread! While everyone else props their crust, the bread, Piccadilly Circus Pizza puts the focus where it should be, cheese, cheese, and more cheese. Delicious!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Great food , great service, highly recommended“

“This place is absolutely INCREDIBLE! So grateful!“

“Great service and friendly staff. Even being shorthanded, they were prompt. The food was great as usual!!“