23 Best Pizza Restaurants near Millersburg

1 Pizza Depot “Millersburg”

4.6 Superb 148 Reviews

104 North Jefferson Street, Millersburg

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The food is 100% amazing. The cleanliness is above and beyond. The staff there are the sweetest people you'll ever meet. The customer service is fast. The prices are reasonable. There always checking on you while dining in. There so amazing. I highly recommend trying There food if you haven't yet. We are regular customers. And as long as there in business. They will continue to get our service. Thank you Pizza Depot of Millersburg. You guys Rock. Thank you for always going above and beyond.”

2 Venturi

4.6 Superb 156 Reviews

123 East Lincoln Avenue, Goshen · 8.26 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“today was our first time going and it was sooooo good! the service was amazing she explained about some of the items, which I appreciated, and uugh it was just so good! Will definitely go back!”

3 Danny's Diner

4.5 Superb 274 Reviews

422 South Main Street, Middlebury · 9.83 miles

• Delivery

“Very tasty no-frills offerings at great prices. We ordered pizza, a calzone, and a grinder at the counter, then filled our drinks and settled ourselves in a booth. The food came pretty quickly and we were impressed by the generous portions and fresh ingredients.”

4 The Fold Goshen

4.5 Superb 131 Reviews

219 S Main St, Goshen · 8.25 miles

“The pizza is great, my favorite is the buffalo chicken bacon ranch or New York White. All of the appetizers are good, but I think the cheesy garlic bread is best. A solid selection of beer that updates occasionally, plus great bartenders like Molly and Spencer who mix excellent drinks. The staff is always friendly and welcoming.”

5 Down Under

4.4 Superb 108 Reviews

801 North Huntington Street STE 12, Syracuse · 7.54 miles

• Take-Out

“First time being here in a bout 15 years. Had the French dip and French onion soup, it was very tasty! My girlfriend had the prime rib special and which was also very tasty! Super tender. Such a cool, slick environment. A good cocktail as well. Definitely recommend! We will be back.”

6 Grounded Coffee House

4.7 Superb 130 Reviews

306 South Cavin Street, Ligonier · 7.09 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We just opened the pet grooming salon next door, and we’ve came here everyday. Kayla and her crew are so nice and welcoming and the food is delicious!”

7 Vinee's Pizza

4.8 Superb 25 Reviews

116 North Jefferson Street, Cromwell · 9.67 miles

• Take-Out

“very clean, nice atmosphere, and the best pizza I have ever had!!! awesome thin crust. Will be going back!”

8 Old Time Pizza

4.3 Superb 111 Reviews

19152 Co Rd 46, New Paris · 7.32 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food, great people. Definitely stop in & get some great food.”

9 Momo's Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 91 Reviews

503 South Huntington Street, Syracuse · 8.11 miles

“I do love this pizza . I’ve had it 4 times. Tonight was the only time it was Meh. I only write this because I had family in from out of town. We ordered 2 extra large ones and the pizzas didn’t fill the boxes. They were considerably smaller pizzas and less substantial than the other times we gotten it. The owner wasn’t the one who made it. Maybe better training for those when the owner isn’t there? But I’ve had 3 really great experiences. I know I will again.”

10 Hunt Brothers Pizza

5.0 Superb 6 Reviews

104 US-20, Middlebury · 8.82 miles

• Delivery

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

11 Pizza Hut

4.1 Good 83 Reviews

1112 South Huntington Street, Syracuse · 8.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“So we went into Pizza Hut tonight food was good like always but the older guy that was in his thirties wouldn't sell us beer because he didn't have a liquor license I'm pretty sure it's the establishment that has the liquor license and as long as you're over the age of 21 you can sell it. I think someone needs to talk to this employee ( Josh )this isn't the first time we've had this experience. UPDATE!!! JOSH thank you for your great service tonight we gave it another shot and you went above and beyond we will be back!!”

12 Noble Roman's

5.0 Superb 1 Review

68310 IN-15, New Paris · 7.43 miles

• Delivery

“Not only is this a great place to grab pizza for lunch but you can also order pizza packs for supper. They also offer a great variety of wings and breadsticks for full meal deals. I really enjoy the chicken bacon ranch, a nice twist on a traditional pizza”

13 Hunt Brothers Pizza

4.5 Superb 2 Reviews

8095 US-20, Shipshewana · 10.54 miles

“some good stuff and convenient at most stores I love it”

14 Piccadilly Circus Pizza

3.8 Good 4 Reviews

901 South Main Street, Middlebury · 8.73 miles

• Delivery

“Yes, in this tiny little town, I had the best pizza I had for years. They do pizza right by heaps of cheese and toppings, not bread! While everyone else props their crust, the bread, Piccadilly Circus Pizza puts the focus where it should be, cheese, cheese, and more cheese. Delicious!”

15 Pizza King

4.0 Good 87 Reviews

719 South Huntington Street, IN-13, Syracuse · 8.28 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We had fast & great service !! Pizza was excellent !!!”

16 Gerace's Pizzeria

3.8 Good 88 Reviews

Waterford Mills Plaza, 65529 Indiana 15, 65529 IN-15, Goshen · 7.04 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have not been here for over a year. I tried it last night and came back again tonight. There have been major improvements done to the pizza. The sauce is better, the crust is better, the toppings are on top of the cheese which just looks delicious and they now have stuffed crust!!! 10 out of 10!!!”

17 Pizza Hut

3.7 Good 51 Reviews

258 US-6, Ligonier · 7.5 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Christmas Eve they were crazy busy I went inside to pick up my order and you could just see them all working together and smiling even if they had to be exhausted we had ordered seven pizzas and they were all great 🙂”

18 Chubbies Pub And Grub

4.0 Good 171 Reviews

1201 South Huntington Street Suite 1934, Syracuse · 8.72 miles

• Take-Out

“Went on Tuesday for the breaded tenderloin special ($4.99). We needed 2 to go and ate 2 in the restaurant. We were surprised to hear they charge full price ($10.99) for the 2 we took home since we did eat in the restaurant as well. I understand the up-charge for strictly carry out, but we ate there as well. The BPT (breaded pork tenderloin) was really good, we would recommend and will go back.”

19 Pizza Hut

3.2 Average 44 Reviews

500 Spg Vly Road, Middlebury · 9.83 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Awesome friendly staff, I between Middlebury, Ligonier, and Lagrange pizza hut's Middlebury is the most consistent in quality to me. Haven't gotten one uneven pizza where there are gaps of missing cheese or toppings missing. In my experience.”

20 Rulli's Italian Restaurant

3.6 Good 284 Reviews

851 US-20, Middlebury · 9.84 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Excellent Italian Food and great Service! Really enjoyed the pizza and the wife enjoyed her lasagna!! Very generous portions! Would highly recommend!! 5 stars out of 5!”

21 Massimo's Pizzeria

3.2 Average 67 Reviews

1003 North Main Street, Goshen · 8.72 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Massimo's is a little hole in the wall pizza joint that makes the best pizzas I've ever had, hands down. I only visit Goshen once a year for an annual event, but I make it a point to get pizza here every visit. Outstanding quality.”

22 Little Caesars Pizza

3.2 Average 205 Reviews

720 Lincolnway East, Goshen · 7.17 miles

• Delivery

“I have been coming to this location for a little over a year now. The manager here is great and she makes sure she takes care of the customers. My orders are always correct and my food is fresh. I recommend giving this place a try. Great staff and great food. Will continue to frequent the location!”

23 Papa Johns Pizza

3.1 Average 184 Reviews

301 North Main Street, Goshen · 8.42 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Went in this last Friday to get my pickup order I had called in. Soon as I walked In I seen a guy with tattoos all over his arms wipe BBQ off a ready to bake pizza with no gloves on… then licked his two fingers, the one finger went all the way in his mouth, and licked another part of his hand, the dug his hand into the meat and continued making coustomers pizzas. Disgusting! Absolutely disgusting… not a single person at this place had a pair of gloves on… sad…sad…sad… this was the Goshen location by the way right down town ..310 north Main Street.”