5 Best Bakeries in Muncie

“If I could give more than 5 stars, I would! Get Baked is an absolute gem — from their delicious variety of *special* treats to the warm, welcoming atmosphere. What really made my experience stand out, though, was the incredible customer service. Mrs. Tara and Mrs.Nae were beyond amazing — so helpful, knowledgeable, and so very kind . They took the time to answer my questions, offer thoughtful recommendations, and made me feel like more than just a customer. Their kindness and energy really brought the whole experience together. If you’re looking for a spot with incredible options and even better people, Get Baked is it!! I’ll definitely be back — Best place EVER!!!!!“

“Jason and Nicole went above and beyond to ensure my Mom's 70th birthday was extra special with a surprise cake delivery! Living on the other side of the country, I was struggling to find a local baker in Muncie that could hand-make a traditional Pineapple Upside Down Cake and deliver it directly on her birthday. Jason and Nicole were thrilled to help and allowed me to place custom order over the phone. They normally don't deliver small orders like this, but they offered it to me for a small special fee given I live out of state. I was blown away by their graciousness! The top notch quality of customer service they provided is not something you find very often! THANK YOU for the exceptional service and rapid communication to make this happen. Highly recommend this shop for custom cake orders of any size!“

“Great customer service! Good menu choices. Love the new look of the store.“

“Came in today during a very busy time and was helped by Melanie T. She was absolutely wonderful—friendly, kind, and very helpful. She taped my box, stapled my bag without being asked, and made sure everything was taken care of.

Even with the bakery being crowded, she stayed calm and welcoming. Those small gestures made a big difference, and I truly appreciated the great service. Melanie T is a real asset to this bakery!“

“Great place! Awesome service, the donuts and coffee were good quality. Very good atmosphere and dog friendly!! Highly highly recommend this place!!!“