8 Best Bakeries in New Albany

Leaven Bakery Bakery • $
Recommended
1515 E Market St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Capriole Farms Goat Cheese Salad
Breakfast Sandwich and Potatoes
Healthy-Ish Breakfast Sandwich
Maple Bacon French Toast
TBS Turkey Bacon Swiss
Chicken Pesto Sandwich
Rosemary Bread Loaf
Breakfast Burrito
English Muffins
Mushroom Toast

“This beautiful bakery was a fantastic find during our weekend getaway in New Albany. Suggested by our Airbnb hosts, we grabbed breakfast and coffee from here Friday morning and it was incredible! My husband got the Buttered Pecan French Toast and I got the Americana both of which were delicious! Their homemade sourdough bread was to die for! We also split a cream cheese Danish that was out of this world. We sat at the "bar" and the owners chatted with us while we ate and shared some of their backstory. Very sincere and kind people! Their staff was super friendly. The experiences as a whole was just fantastic. Highly, highly recommend!!“

4.9 Superb73 Reviews
Sweet Stuff Bakery Bakery • $
323 E Spring St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry & White Cup Cakes
White Cake with White Icing
Strawberry Birthday Cake
Wife's Birthday Cake
3 Tier Wedding Cake
1st Birthday Cake
White Cupcakes
Red Velvet Cake
Sugar Cookie
The Italian

“🌊🎂✨ THE BEST CAKE I’VE EVER SEEN!!

If I could give this bakery 100 stars, I would!! My boyfriend just picked up my ponyo themed birthday cake and I am absolutely obsessed.

They nailed every single detail, the pictures and the cake design came out very well and It seriously looked like a scene straight out of the movie. 😭💖

You can tell they poured a lot of love, creativity, and care into every inch of it.“

4.9 Superb66 Reviews
Cake Ladies Dream Shoppe Bakery • $
421 W Main St, New Albany

“Seems a bit hidden but definitely a gem in its own right for bakers. If you need it to bake a cake, pastry, or confection, they have it and in multiple flavors and colors. Not only that but they can even help you learn while you are there. My go to birthday cake supply store!“

5 Superb17 Reviews
Toni T's Cupcakes • $
4510 Charlestown Rd, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Bread Pudding

“First time trying out Toni T’s today, and it was DELICIOUS!! My kids and I LOVED the classic sprinkle in glazed and chocolate, and my husband loved the raspberry filled. SO yummy! I’m not sure if the man who helped me was Toni the owner, but he was incredibly kind!!“

4.6 Superb61 Reviews
Rookies Cookies Bakery • $
310 Pearl St, New Albany

“I had some cookies special ordered for baby shower. Beautiful details and decorated as I requested!“

5 Superb8 Reviews
Royal Couture Treats Boutique Bakery •
216 Pearl St, New Albany

“Just want to say u done an amazing job on the beautiful cake u made 4 THE BREAKAWAY recovery home graduation on Valentines Day!!! The flavor and decoration both were so great! Thank you for stepping up, Taking the time out of your schedule on short notice to assure that our graduate had the most amazing cake for her huge accomplishment!Thank you over and over!!“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Legacy Pizza & Bakery Pizza • $
1001 Vincennes St Suite 100, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Calzones Are Loaded with Cheese and Up to 3 Meats Veggies
Ruby Rose Cannoli Is Only Available February to May
Brioche Bread Fresh Out of the Oven
Legacy Classic Pizza
Spaghetti Squash
Pepperoni Pizza
Chocolate Chip
Bread Pudding
Cheese Bread
Meatball Sub

“Once again Legacy was amazing. I ordered something new tonight and it didn't disappoint. If you like pineapple on your pizza the Hurricane is for you. The pineapple was sweet and the red onions and pepperdews balanced it out beautifully. And as always the pistachio cannoli was outstanding!!!“

4.8 Superb125 Reviews
Coffee Crossing Coffee Shops • $
140 E Main St, New Albany

Customers` Favorites

Egg and Bacon Sandwich
Latte and Croissant
White Mocha Latte
Coffee Cake
Scones

“Went there today for my first time very great atmosphere didn’t know what I was wanting to get or what I should get so I decide to ask an employee there what they think is a good recommendation. After a few recommendations I decided to go with something and when I did, I was not disappointed. I’m sure there is multiple other things there that are very good but all in all great experience very well ran and very respectful employees will definitely be going back and recommending it to others. They sure did brighten my evening!“

4.7 Superb50 Reviews

Enjoy Similar Cuisines In New Albany