50 Best Bakeries near Prospect

“The baristas are friendly, the coffee is strong, and the pastries are scrumptious! It’s a great place to work (free wi-fi for customers) or relax and read. Great atmosphere!“

“Great Bakery“

“Ordered a Halloween cake for my grand babies and it was the most beautiful, delicious cake. Excellent communication. Thank you for making their day special. photo in the comments“

“My family gets almost all of our cakes from here! They're amazing and so talented! We've gotten baesic cakes, her pre designed cakes, And even a beautiful custom cake for a baby shower. Highly recommend them! I posted a couple of the cakes we've gotten from them recently!

Updating this on 8/16/2026 to add the custom shark cake she made for my sons 6th birthday. Absolutely amazing! Way better than we imagined!!“

“Amazing taste and customer service“

“Love ❤️ her sweet potato pies! And warm environment…..“

“Stopped in this morning by chance for coffee and pastries. Got the Cubano with a chocolate croissant and an almond croissant.🔥🔥“

“First time ever going to crumbl. Middletown was our pick and we are so glad. The ladies that were there were so very helpful and made us feel at ease not knowing what to order or even how beings it was our first time. Thank you Middletown crumbl your employees were amazing.“

“best donut shop in Louisville“

“Very delicious homemade style cookies. I got them online and shipping was fast. Would buy again. Highly recommended.“

“Great cake slice and chai latte. Nice atmosphere and friendly barista.“

“Usually don’t go out to bakery’s due to having a lack of selection I enjoy, this exceeded my expectations for such a small amount of options… if you’re from Mi they are like crumbl cookie but overall better flavors, taste way fresher, and cheaper then 99% of places I’ve been, if your local to LV KY they would be a great spot to get treats consistently, I am from mid Michigan and have saved this in my phone in case my work ever sends me near again :) 10/10 5star“

“the store itself was a good store, my wife and i got the biscotti tres leches cake but we weren’t really happy with it this go around. it’s our favorite & one we always make sure to get but this time it didn’t have any moisture inside the cake, it was VERY dry. The only thing that had any moisture was the icing…. not the best trip treat wise but the store staff was really kind. I’ll be back just from staff experience.“

“I went here to grab cannolis for my fiance's birthday. I'd heard they made really good ones and I wasn't disappointed! They were exceptional! I also purchased a slice of their flourless chocolate torte and it was perfection, as well. I recommend going earlier in the day, as I went around 230 and they were sold out of a lot of their items. I plan on going again soon to try some breakfast options.“

“Where to even begin?! This is more than an amazing play space and cafe; it’s a place where caregivers can actually get a much needed breather while kids are able to be kids in a safe space. Plus it’s a hub of activity. They are always offering new classes, camps and childcare options. My kiddo took an art class here that was 10/10. They also are very community-minded. They’ve hosted a pantry on-site and offer play days at significantly reduced cost. Amazing people. Amazing atmosphere. Highly recommended GlowWorm!“

“Absolutely delicious! The food and service were amazing. Definitely returning for more. Bonus: Alpha Gal friendly“

“We absolutely love Morgan! Our unique wedding cake and wide variety of flavors of cupcakes were a hit at our wedding!“

“I’ve had delicious pastries and the most amazing Jule Log from here, and the gift shop area is full of Scandi treasures! I’ll be back for another Jule Log!“

“Blu Bakery made our wedding cake for our August 2025 wedding. We wanted something simple and elegant and they understood completely. They recreated our inspiration photo perfectly. We are so happy we went with them!“

“Great breakfast and an excellent bourbon cookie!“

“Ordered a smash cake and a sheet cake for our daughters first birthday. So glad we chose Sweets by Millie! From the beginning, the process was so easy and she understood exactly what I was picturing in my head. The pricing is upfront and matches the quality of cake you will receive. Definitely will be ordering again in the future!“

“Delicious cookies, great service.“

“It was excellent! Highly recommend you check it out!“

“She made a cookie cake for a Derby party and it was pretty & delicious! One of the best cookie cakes I have ever had and I cannot wait to order again!“

“By far one of the best bakeries in the US. Chef Jackie is exceptionally talented and everything she creates is delicious. The staff is wonderful as well.“

“🔥This place has all the bells and whistles for a bakery! The staff is friendly, the space is spotless, and the food is delicious.“

“Recently ordered some Arabic pastries that consisted of chicken. Some of them had cheese, and some had the thyme I highly recommend calling the day before and ordering exactly what you would like. They’re very tasty and very perfect for any gathering.“

“I just want to shout out Olivia at the Saint Matthews location. I have never received better customer service in my entire life and I have worked in food service and customer service For 22 years. Last night at about 6 o’clock I ordered a six pack of the regular size Dubai chocolate cookies from the Saint Matthews location. I live in Fairdale and every other location you know relatively not all of them, but most of them were sold out and I was like well I’ll just go to Saint Matthews so I ordered them. I need the store didn’t close till 10 so I decided not to leave the house until eight thirtyish and I don’t drive. I took an Uber. So we get all the way there after paying you know nearly $60 for an Uber and almost 40 for cookies. We’re coming up to $100 just for these cookies at this point we get to Saint Matthews, my youngest daughter and I, and when we get there, the Baker tells us that they do not have any of the regular size Dubai chocolate cookies they only have four minis and I was like OK well can I get a refund and she said we can’t do it without my manager here and I was like some options are cookies I don’t want or no money back and I’ve already spent $100 like I was pretty bummed I wasn’t rude or anything and but I was just really bummed I felt super letdown so that I called my other children and had them pick out what they wanted and they weren’t too excited but you know she could hear their voice is like I guess I’ll take this now. I guess I’ll take that. Well. I alternate between all three of my kids Crumbl points so that they each can accumulate them and get little rewards and things so yesterday was my middle child’s Crumbl point day and my youngest daughter and I leave Crumbl with the cookies. We weren’t really excited about because we didn’t get the one so we wanted and go to target across the street and before we finish at target my middle child calls to tell me that the manager Olivia called and said that she understood where we were really disappointed by not getting the Dubai chocolate cookies and that she wanted to make it up to us especially because we pre-ordered them and came all the way from across town in an Uber to make it up to us and she was going to drop some off to us personally and I was like well that’s great thank you… And I was thinking she meant 10:30 in the morning because you know nobody wants to go across town after work you know after they’ve worked there their little buns off all day so we get home and 🦋💙👩‍👧My Daughter’s like oh well Miss Olivia’s gonna be here the manager and I was like when is she coming? She said oh she’s on her way. Olivia went above and beyond in every Single possible way. Not only did she come with cookies she got all of them to buy chocolate cookies and she made us a gorgeous little cute little box and she also brought a little goodie bag with two chocolate milks, and two white milks and then another little goodie bag she brought two Crumbl Tumblr cups two Crumbl pop socket sands two Crumbl sunglasses Crumbl tattoos and Crumbl stickers I mean she literally just went above and beyond oh and Crumbl keychains and not only that but she drove them all the way from Saint Matthews To Fairdale at 11 something at night she didn’t get to my house till 1130 so I know she didn’t get home until after midnight after working all day long and I I’ve just never had somebody go above and beyond that way in all of my entire life and she really just deserves a shout out. Not only should she get a shout out like she gave the kind of service that I will gladly pay an Uber to take me all the way across town to Saint Matthews. If it means going to Olivia‘s Crumbl.“

“This place has just about everything! Sandwiches, coffees, teas, boba, Ramen bowls, Pho, burgers, subs, even specialty corn dogs, and amazing bakery items! Super nice people and everything was great tasting and good serving amounts, all for a decent price in my opinion. Also was playing nice music and had nice decor. Can't wait to go back!“

“Stopped in on a whim today and I will definitely be back. Everything I got was absolutely fabulous!“

“You won't regret it! Delish!“

“So much easier on our emotions than visiting a shelter, so you can interact with the fur babies and relax until you reach a decision. Great coffee from Quill's Coffee and yummy snacks! Amazing volunteers who help to make the entire experience very relaxed and chill.“

“A Louisville staple! Everything here is delicious, and the people working behind the counter are always friendly and ready to offer suggestions. The thumbprint cookies and cheese straws are incredible. I hope everyone who visits Louisville stops to pick up a few treats!“

“Brittany at Fern Creek store was amazing. She was very helpful and professional and got us together for last minute treats for our son’s birthday!“

“Great place to get your food truck business up and running or to optimize your current operation! Super folks to deal with too!“

“We had the vegan pepperoni pizza today and had to try the red velvet cake, as well. Both were really good. We will definitely be back the next time we're in Louisville.“

“We had a custom cake made for our daughter’s birthday party, and it literally became the showstopper of the party. Dara matched the icing colors to the invitations we had, and everyone kept complimenting how fancy it looked. Then when we ate it everyone gushed how great it tasted. 11/10 I will definitely be hitting her up for more cakes!“

“The Bourbon Balls are so good and decadent!“

“Christina's cakes are beautiful and so delicious! Her prices are the best around and she has tons of flavor options. She has made my son's birthday cake for years and we have loved it every time. Highly recommend!“

“The custom cookies for a first birthday party both looked great and were delicious! Everyone was impressed with the number of unique designs. We are so happy with how the cookies turned out! Just wish I would have taken more pictures before they were gone.“

“I ordered some muffins from this sweet shop for an event, and they turned out absolutely incredible, outstanding! They were not only delicious but also beautifully made. The team was so kind and lovely to work with. Adorable place, highly recommended!“

“Amazing cakes! So happy to finally have an Indiana location.“

“This is the best ice cream I've had in years. The butter pecan was amazing! Has the nostalgic real ice cream taste from when I was kid.“

“Amber is the absolute sweetest and her treats are always so cute & delicious! You can tell she puts a lot of work into everything she does. Definitely recommend 💕“

“Always looking for a great sandwich bread! Well, I’ve just found the best white bread (great sandwich or peanut butter and jelly, it was fresh, tasty and delicious!
We’re not big bread consumers yet, when you need or want a great fresh loaf, Aunt Millie’s it’s going to be, thank you!!“

“I had the cheesecake brownie and it was the best brownie I’ve ever had!“

“Brittany at Fern Creek store was amazing. She was very helpful and professional and got us together for last minute treats for our son’s birthday!“