9 Best Bakeries in New Albany

“Best of everything! Food, vibe…and the people are top notch!“

“Sweet Stuff made the cake for our June wedding and it was so delicious! My husband and I chose orange and strawberry for our different tiers. They were so easy with planning and our cake came out so beautiful. They captured my vision perfectly. Cake tasting was one of the best parts of wedding planning. They also remake a smaller cake for your one year anniversary, which will be perfect for celebrating! I have always loved Sweet Stuff in the past, but now they are even more special to us after being part of our special day.“

“I have been here a number of times, everything I have ever gotten has been awesome, fresh large servings and great price My favorite is the Oreo Cheesecake and chocolate chip cookies, Buddy loves the Oreo filled long John, Chelsey the banana pudding, And Corey the Chess Bars you can’t beat the price or quality.“

“Just want to say u done an amazing job on the beautiful cake u made 4 THE BREAKAWAY recovery home graduation on Valentines Day!!! The flavor and decoration both were so great! Thank you for stepping up, Taking the time out of your schedule on short notice to assure that our graduate had the most amazing cake for her huge accomplishment!Thank you over and over!!“

“I ordered a cake for my sister’s 40th birthday and it turned out amazing! She was so thrilled with it she didn’t want to cut it but we finally talked her into it. It tasted wonderful and was a great price for what we received. Highly recommend!“

“We have been to Legacy Pizza twice in the past two weeks. Each time, delicious food and fantastic service. My wife and older son each had sandwiches that they loved. My younger son and I had pizzas, which were fantastic. It is great to support a local restaurant and help local servers make extra money. Kyra and Aubrey were impressive servers. Highly recommend Legacy Pizza!“

“Looooved this place! The coffee was perfect. Atmosphere was nice and relaxed, and the service was excellent.“

“I got 2 pies (lemon meringue & Reese's) yesterday at the Fern Creek location, and they were both yummmmyyyy!“

“First time I’ve ever stopped at one. Not a coffee drinker. But my girlfriend was given a gift certificate from a coworker. We both had a delicious cup of hot chocolate. She had peppermint put in hers and really liked it. Probably have to stop in and do this again. Service was friendly and fast!“