The Pie Kitchen
$ • Bakery, Ice Cream
Hours:
3113 Blackiston Mill Rd, New Albany
(812) 590-3580
About The Pie Kitchen
Customers' Favorites
The Pie Kitchen Reviews
Share your opinion about The Pie Kitchen
The last piece of rhubarb pie I had was filled with brownish mush. Their cream pies must have a pound of sugar in them.
Brittany at Fern Creek store was amazing. She was very helpful and professional and got us together for last minute treats for our son’s birthday!
Over the weekend I placed an order for a half sheet cake for my daughter’s baptism at the Highlands Pie Kitchen. When I picked it up I was absolutely SHOCKED at how bad the quality was. The writing was in print, and there were no decorative roses at all. I immediately called the Pie Kitchen in Fern Creek & asked if their baker had better penmanship and could fix the cake and they were working on my cake within 10 minutes. Their amazing baker Lance spent 45 minutes of his time...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
People in New Albany Also Viewed
The Pie Kitchen is a beloved bakery and dessert spot known for its wide selection of treats, including homemade ice cream, pies, cakes, and cookies. Visitors frequently praise the ice cream, describing it as some of the best hard ice cream they've ever had. Many enjoy adding a malt or shake to their ice cream, topped with whipped cream and a cherry, making for extra special desserts. The bakery offers a variety of pies, with popular options like Dutch Caramel Apple Pie, which is highly recommended, and others that can be warmed for a delicious experience. Pies, cake pops, and leftover treats are often on sale, providing great extras for customers. The selection of cakes, such as Chocolate Cream, Strawberry Cream Cheese, and Chocolate Silk, are favorites among families celebrating milestones or just enjoying a treat. Buckeyes are another highlight, with many customers buying them individually or in larger quantities for holidays. The atmosphere is cozy, especially in the dining area during chilly evenings. The staff are generally friendly and helpful, though some reviews mention inconsistency in service. Overall, The Pie Kitchen is considered the best bakery by many, delivering delicious, satisfying treats consistently, and leaving customers eager to return for more.