Custom Cakes near New Albany, IN

“The best cake I have ever had. 10000/10.“

“They have a wide assortment of cakes, pastries, cookies, as well as coffee and lattes. We got some cookies and lattes, all of which were delicious and high quality. The people were extremely friendly and helpful. The interior was extravagantly and uniquely decorated. Great vibes all around. Can't wait to come back and try more!“

“Ordered a smash cake and a sheet cake for our daughters first birthday. So glad we chose Sweets by Millie! From the beginning, the process was so easy and she understood exactly what I was picturing in my head. The pricing is upfront and matches the quality of cake you will receive. Definitely will be ordering again in the future!“

“Ordered a cake for my daughter’s birthday and it was delicious! Everyone loved it! Cake was moist and not overly sweet. The butter cream was the perfect sweetness too! I will definitely be ordering more cakes in the near future .“

“We had a custom cake made for our daughter’s birthday party, and it literally became the showstopper of the party. Dara matched the icing colors to the invitations we had, and everyone kept complimenting how fancy it looked. Then when we ate it everyone gushed how great it tasted. 11/10 I will definitely be hitting her up for more cakes!“

“First time visiting. Drove from Shelbyville for our weekend donut date. Will definitely be returning soon. Very good donuts ❤️“

“Update: Thank you so much Jessica for reaching out and making it right. Since then I have ordered 3 separate times and the cookies are back to normal. You have a great staff and Darrian was so kind when I stopped in on Mothers day.

I used to order weekly but the last two times my cookies have been over cooked and a lot flatter than usual. I’m not sure if there’s a new baker but the reason I order these cookies is because they come warm and they melt in my mouth. The last two times they have been hard and taste like basic cookies. Something needs to change!“