Whitetail Sweet Shop
$ • Ice Cream
Hours:
2020 S Memorial Dr Ste I, New Castle
(765) 524-4891
About Whitetail Sweet Shop
Customers' Favorites
Whitetail Sweet Shop Reviews
Share your opinion about Whitetail Sweet Shop
We rented the building connected to the ice cream that they rent. with package 3for a birthday party for my twins and it was so amazing! Very easy to work with very clean! They came and checked on us made sure we had everything we needed. Was a wonderful experience highly recommend if your looking for a meeting room or a place to throw a birthday party. 🥳
Family atmosphere and loves the customers. Great options. We love that they have a dairy free and vegan options because our little guy is no dairy. Wonderful location and very sweet employees! Our family loves to go there! We cannot recommend them enough!! ❤️
First time there and it is amazing…..however, I ordered a banana split thru the drive thru and didn’t realize til about 10 bites in they forgot my banana 🤣🤣 I’ll definitely be back when I can go inside and try some different things.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 2 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 2 - 8PM |
| Friday | 2 - 8PM |
| Saturday | 2 - 8PM |
| Sunday | 2 - 8PM |
People in New Castle Also Viewed
Whitetail Sweet Shop is a charming and modern shop offering a wide variety of sweet treats. The staff is super friendly and kind, making customers feel welcome. The shop has an incredible smell when you walk in, and the ice cream flavors are numerous and delicious. A highlight is the ice cream tacos, which can be customized to suit every taste. The shop also offers great prices, friendly service, and a big variety of treats, including drinks and maple fudge.
The shop has a family-friendly atmosphere and cares about its customers, providing options for everyone, including dairy-free and vegan choices, which are perfect for those with special dietary needs. Visitors often enjoy their "usual" and praise the fresh waffle cones and blackberry lemon bar. The location is wonderful, and the staff is very sweet. In addition, the connected building can be rented for events like birthday parties, making it an ideal place for celebrations. The staff is attentive, checking on guests and ensuring everything runs smoothly, creating a clean and enjoyable experience for all.