18 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Paris

“Not only is this a great place to grab pizza for lunch but you can also order pizza packs for supper. They also offer a great variety of wings and breadsticks for full meal deals. I really enjoy the chicken bacon ranch, a nice twist on a traditional pizza“

“Great food, great people. Definitely stop in & get some great food.“

“The best pizza we have ever had and the service was phenomenal!! Willa was our waitress and she was amazing. Old fashion was top 10 ever had as well. We will be back soon!!“

“The pizza is great, my favorite is the buffalo chicken bacon ranch or New York White. All of the appetizers are good, but I think the cheesy garlic bread is best. A solid selection of beer that updates occasionally, plus great bartenders like Molly and Spencer who mix excellent drinks. The staff is always friendly and welcoming.“

“The food is 100% amazing. The cleanliness is above and beyond. The staff there are the sweetest people you'll ever meet. The customer service is fast. The prices are reasonable. There always checking on you while dining in. There so amazing. I highly recommend trying There food if you haven't yet. We are regular customers. And as long as there in business. They will continue to get our service. Thank you Pizza Depot of Millersburg. You guys Rock. Thank you for always going above and beyond.“

“I ordered the pizza sandwich (kinda like a personal pizza) because I was short on time and didn’t realize they don’t have pizza by the slice and it was a great idea because it was very delicious, the right size for 1 or 2 people to feel full and took less than 10 mins. Only suggestion I’d make is to put a couple of chairs or a bench for those who are waiting for their food to be ready“

“I love the Pizza. I love local owned business they always have the best food. The owner is a great guy. The staff is always cordial. Our weekly choice.“

“King cut med. rare prime rib was magnificent. The au-jus was so good that I'd order it as a beverage. The wife had the lightly breaded walleye. She said it was very good. The house salad was better than expected. We ordered the spinach dip with chips. Very nice. We were there on Thursday at 5 pm. Our dip and chips came quickly, then our salad soon after. But our entrees came too soon. The kitchen should have held off 15 minutes or so. All in all, it was a teriff9c experience. Cannot wait to go back. Bill was $90.00, which included a dessert to go. Tip commensurate with the bill.“

“Never disappointed! Always great food!“

“So we went into Pizza Hut tonight food was good like always but the older guy that was in his thirties wouldn't sell us beer because he didn't have a liquor license I'm pretty sure it's the establishment that has the liquor license and as long as you're over the age of 21 you can sell it. I think someone needs to talk to this employee ( Josh )this isn't the first time we've had this experience. UPDATE!!! JOSH thank you for your great service tonight we gave it another shot and you went above and beyond we will be back!!“

“Clean, friendly, and fast. We enjoy this gas station. Great slushies and the "restaurant" portion is a wick pizza style bite to eat. Breakfast all day as well when the elmos part is open. There is also a drive thru.

Parking: Around entire sides and front of building.“

“Pizza Hut is so nostalgic to me. Pizza Hut is where we’d go every Friday after my parents worked for the week, and this was our, family night, so 80’s. So I drive from Goshen to this particular Pizza Hut. Look at the quality, the toppings, and the hefty toppings. The staff are so friendly, pizza ready on time, I love everything about the staff. My pizza is piping hot, they give you your money’s worth. Clean inside. The outside can be better, like the water dripping by the door overhead and it turns to ice, and is a hazard for a slip and fall. So hopefully they see this. No complaints“

“We had fast & great service !! Pizza was excellent !!!“

“Went in this last Friday to get my pickup order I had called in. Soon as I walked In I seen a guy with tattoos all over his arms wipe BBQ off a ready to bake pizza with no gloves on… then licked his two fingers, the one finger went all the way in his mouth, and licked another part of his hand, the dug his hand into the meat and continued making coustomers pizzas. Disgusting! Absolutely disgusting… not a single person at this place had a pair of gloves on… sad…sad…sad… this was the Goshen location by the way right down town ..310 north Main Street.“

“Husband got a pizza Thursday night for us. It was still hot when he got it home and it was very delicious. Crust was not burnt. Was cut all the way through. My thoughts were they had chanced crust and sauce…no was not that. He been getting it at a different shop then we use to get from. He said this was the place he will always get at. Pizza sure was good and was nice not to try eating a crust that was terrible like from the other store in Goshen. Yep this is his go to pizza shop now.“

“Great place to bring your family. A bowling alley is attached to it as well. Great food and service so you really can't go wrong!

Parking: Easy right in front of the building.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly as well.“

“They told me my total bill was $19.30, and I paid by card. The cashier rings it up and hands me a slip to sign, the total is now over $20. It was the credit card 4% they neglected to tell me about although they do have a couple of sentences explaining the card fee on the counter. I'm guessing most people pay by card, so just raise all your prices by $1.00 to cover the card cost.Nobody likes surprises, but don't lie to me about the total. If the total is $19.30 (and that total is spoken by the Gerace's employee), then the total is $19.30, nothing more, nothing less.“

“Massimo's is a little hole in the wall pizza joint that makes the best pizzas I've ever had, hands down. I only visit Goshen once a year for an annual event, but I make it a point to get pizza here every visit. Outstanding quality.“