9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Shelbyville

“I grew up on JB's Pizza King that was on 135 in Greenwood next to at that time True Value. Early 80s and until I graduated in 87 and left for the military. I came home in 2012 and it was gone and then someone opened one in Whiteland and I'm glad it closed because they crucified everything I remember pizza king being. Then an Arnie's restaurant opened up on 135 and they said it was from the Original pizza king Bros. And it was good but not what I remembered. Until tonight. Cagneys is what I remember as a kid. The memories I thought forever gone of the pizza king pizza with my mom and dad had been located. Thank you Cagneys. Not was is delicious but I actually had a moment that got to me from those memories. Fantastic pizza. You will not be disappointed. Thank you so much Cagneys!“

“Great pizza, great service and great employees.“

“Thank you ? to the wonderful ladies at dominos ? pizza in Shelbyville. I ordered a pan spinach chicken Alfredo pizza ? the ladies (Kim & Linda) were super friendly! The pizza ? is delicious! One of my favorites to order now. I was very fortunate to get the free pizza ? for a year!!!“

“Small hole in the wall place. My wife has to be gluten free and they took utmost care to make sure there was no cross contamination. My wife was well pleased and we will add Bellacinos to our rotation. Couldn't have been more pleased!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free“

“This place is awesome! The staff is always so nice and more than easy to get along with. We have had several birthdays parties as well as homeschool co-op days at Blue River Bowl. Everyone always has a wonderful time! Today we had about 30 people in total at our event and everyone ordered lots of food. The guys busted butt and got it all served so fast. Not too mention, I have some picky family members lol and they are always impressed by the pizza as well as the staff! Keep up the great work everyone!“

“It was take out. Dependably good pizza as they've been doing it for decades. Once the "king" of the pizza industry, their product still ranks at/near the top. I hope the public will make PH trendy again. Their ad slogan is pretty accurate.... "No one out-pizzas the Hut"!“

“The absolute worst professionalism and customer service yet of any restaurant I have ever been to in my life. I placed a rather large order an hour and a half before we needed it, order went through fine got the information to track it said expect delivery between 6:30 p.m. 6:35 p.m. which would have been perfect to feed a bunch of hungry preteens and teenagers and get them out the door by 7:00 7:15. at 6:40 still no word from Little Caesars so I called. The person answering the phone said we don't have anyone to deliver We had to call a third party like DoorDash to deliver and I said you need to call them and find out where they are and give me a timeline please to which they replied no you call and I said I don't know which service you used You mentioned too and it's technically your job since you have been paid to make sure your customer gets the delivery can you please call them and get a timeline for me and then I heard click they hung up so I called right back. they answered again I told them who I was and that I had just been hung up on and I was trying to figure out where my order was and they started in again about the third party delivery and I said I understand but I need you to call your third party person and figure out where they are if they picked up I said has it even gone out and she said no we're waiting and then hung up so I got in my car and drove there Thank God I had other adults to watch the kids while I went to do that got there and they're set all of our pizzas in their warming oven when their app said they were just being baked at 6:02 p.m. and here it was by the time I got there 10 minutes until 7:00... And she proceeded to tell me they only had one receipt either one for me or one for the delivery person I said I am the delivery person I'm picking up my own food because you're not understanding what I'm asking you. so they got everything stacked up on the counter printed off my receipt and out the door I went. I will never ever use them again especially for a large order that was close to $100. I will pay more money and go to Papa John's or Pizza Hut before I would ever use Little Caesars again. Shelbyville branch needs to have new owners or managers if they can't do any better than what they exhibited today.“

“This place is awesome! The staff is always so nice and more than easy to get along with. We have had several birthdays parties as well as homeschool co-op days at Blue River Bowl. Everyone always has a wonderful time! Today we had about 30 people in total at our event and everyone ordered lots of food. The guys busted butt and got it all served so fast. Not too mention, I have some picky family members lol and they are always impressed by the pizza as well as the staff! Keep up the great work everyone!“

“I love the burnt ends at Brew Brothers plus Reianna the bartender always does a great job :)!“