17 Best American Restaurants in Shelbyville

“This place is amazing! Our first time here, my boyfriend got biscuits and gravy and I got French toast and a parfait. The fruit was so fresh and delicious and my boyfriend said it was the best biscuits and gravy he's had in a while and he's pickier than me. The service was great and besides the food, it was comfortable and cozy and it was a great way to start our day. I also really appreciated that there were local art pieces and candles and other things for sale. I wish we came here sooner!“

“the biscuits and gravy were excellent.“

“good food and service. love gift shop“

“Decided to stop for a late evening dinner on our recent roadtrip and found the local Culver's was one of the few options still serving so we thought we'd give it a try.
Oh my were we so pleasantly surprised. The young girl at the counter was an absolute sweetheart sharing menu insights for us newbs to the Culver's experience. When she discovered we were Canadians visiting she was so adorably inquisitive.
The burgers and meals we ordered were some of freshest tasting "fast food" we have ever eaten.
Culver's has made it to our list of "Road trip must haves" for all of our future travels.“

“I've eaten here multiple times, and until tonight, the last couple times have had me ready to swear off ever coming back. But tonight was amazing! The hostess was over cleaning a table but came right over to seat us. What a refreshing change! Usually, they're on their phones or huddled up talking anymore. And it only got better from there. Our server, Raven, was delightful. Just the right amount attention. And she did something I rarely see anymore, she took our dirty dishes or empty glasses. I don't know the name of the hostess, but I continued to see her cleaning tables etc throughout our meal. The food was also amazing, fast and cooked just right. But the service was just, wow! I'm gushing over something that used to be commonplace lol“

“I love the burnt ends at Brew Brothers plus Reianna the bartender always does a great job :)!“

“Excellent service! Fast cooking and really overall just really nice! Made sure everything is correct and good! Definitely will be coming back“

“Great Food Fun and People“

“The food and service here were exceptional. This is a great restaurant with great food and very friendly staff.“

“I grew up on JB's Pizza King that was on 135 in Greenwood next to at that time True Value. Early 80s and until I graduated in 87 and left for the military. I came home in 2012 and it was gone and then someone opened one in Whiteland and I'm glad it closed because they crucified everything I remember pizza king being. Then an Arnie's restaurant opened up on 135 and they said it was from the Original pizza king Bros. And it was good but not what I remembered. Until tonight. Cagneys is what I remember as a kid. The memories I thought forever gone of the pizza king pizza with my mom and dad had been located. Thank you Cagneys. Not was is delicious but I actually had a moment that got to me from those memories. Fantastic pizza. You will not be disappointed. Thank you so much Cagneys!“

“What a wonderful little Cafe! Exhausted from a day of exploring and very hungry, we decided to eat here.

We were not disappointed.
Home cooking, YUM!
Our waitress Donna was very polite and down to earth. Loved Her!

Thank you for Wonderful Lunch!
There are things in here you may critique... but why?

This place made us feel like we could be ourselves, let our hair down, so to speak and fill our bellies full! Thank you ?“

“We both always look forward to going to breakfast almost every Sunday morning before church. Kim is usually our server since we are there early. Food is always hot & good! Kim is the best! Great service and enjoy seeing her. Morning staff is exceptional! Includes Crystal, Angie, Ollie and Maria. I’m sure there are others behind the scenes that we don’t get to interact with. Thanks to them all for all they do.“

“I haven’t set foot inside, but these fried pickles are PHENOMENAL!!“

“Been going to grandmas on sundays for a few years. The wait staff here is always exceptional. The food is okay ish. Cold bacon that sat around, at least freshly cooked eggs, and some of the other offering are a bit hit and miss. This place gets busy after 8am and while the staff work super hard during this time, they can be a bit understaffed until about 9ish.

Shelbyville may have other better offerings for breakfast joints but we keep coming back.“

“I’m from the southern part of the state. I had an early dinner with friends after the eclipse. Great service and above adequate food. Owner (B.A.R.) sat down with us, shared in an adult beverage or two, and listened to our silliness. I found the whole experience to be great and would highly recommend that you check it out.“

“Great food! Good service! No waiting! Love the ice cream!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“This place needs a chef with passion. The ribs were poorly executed, over salty with BBQ sauce ON THE SIDE. I could forgive this if the ribs didn't taste like a salt lick. I don't know who they hired to cook but they gotta go. If this is a company standard thing, someone needs to tell the dummies creating the menu to let the chef be a chef and stop micro managing.“