Restaurants near South Whitley

“Jen is a master in the Kitchen and Jay and the boys are true brewmasters! the atmosphere and conversation there is also a great time! Such a delicious and fun experience!”

“One of my daughter's and I stopped in for the first time today. Such a cute place! Loved the Lemon Cheesecake Ice Cream and the Sugar Cream Pie. We bought some cookies, too, but haven't tried them yet. They look delicious!”

“their food is amazing, and they are all so kind! ❤”

“Great customer service. They remember us and our orders. Helpful in teaching us about other products and flavors. Iced medium sweet coffee is the best. See you next year from Missouri.”

“Kind staff & soooo many delicious options!”

“Had an early dinner and food was great. Big portion. Couldn’t eat it all.”

“As I come into the door they were mopping they were very polite asked me how I was doing and gave her my order asked me if I wanted it toasted or not what kind of cheese how I wanted it done whole nine yards even asked if I wanted it initialed so I can tell them apart which was awesome it was clean there but there veggies were all about out but it's probably because they haven't refilled them just at yet price was more then I wanted to spend but the food is good and they do offer online orders too and they were at a black olives lettuce was awesome but the tomatoes didn't seem that fresh and the doctor paper was low on syrup but besides that it was good”

“We had fun at carols today! Highly recommend, what a cute place and cheap!! Just remember your cash !!”

“We love this place so much we had our baby shower here! The price to rent the cafe and have catering was way more than fair. They were so kind and truly made us feel special 💖”

“Julie (owner) welcomed me and my two littles to her shop on a rather disastrous day, on our part. She was so patient and kind and accepted us just as we were -- extremely frazzled mom, barefoot + overtired toddler, and soon to be publicly breastfed two month old. Never once did I feel unwelcomed, disdained, or the least bit out of place despite the chaos I brought to her little slice of heaven. Julie is peppy, hard working, and outgoing. She not only served us swiftly and kindly (hello mandatory samples and extra time with decisions, offering suggestions as well as finding busy work while I thought), but also invested in our journey, asking thoughtfully worded questions and sharing her passions as we conversed. We easily spent an hour in her shop, dripping ice cream and breastmilk and exhaustion; tracking sticky fingers over her game pieces, and adjusting the atmosphere from pleasant to slightly stinky newborn blowout... and yet Julie met us where we were at with kindness and welcoming presence. Is that all? Goodness, no. I am gf/df and one of my littles is df and I was shocked to discover Moo Over not only existed in one but BOTH of my allergen capacities... and others, such as egg. I've been traveling to CC regularly for years and completely oblivious to this gem I could have been visiting every time with zero dietary concerns! Letting my hair down around food is a luxury that can become a common experience now that I know! I discovered her because she put a very GENEROUS coupon out in the Parkview Whitley new parents welcome packages. Originally I was sad it was a coupon I couldn't use, because dairy and ice cream... but I was so excited to discover I was wrong! And Julie, It worked -- I am a forever customer! Is THAT all? Goodness, no! This frazzled momma finally drove off, but left her debit card laying on the counter. Julie held onto it and when I called the next day, offered to mail it to me. She went through the hassle and expense of her time and resources to ensure I didn't have to cancel my bank card or worry about making an extra trip out (an hour away is so much longer when there are littles to load up everywhere you go!). I am beyond impressed with every aspect of what Julie does with Moo Over. She truly exudes excellence and the mindset of community she needs to excel. Such a genuinely amazing business woman. Thank you Julie for doing what you do and doing it so well!”

“The tenderloin was fantastic! Its a must have if you are a true Hoosier.”

“We absolutely had the best sushi & the Hibachi dinner did not disappoint. Good food great service and would recommend over anything else in the area.”

“Love! Very friendly and I love that every week the pastries are always different. Everything is so delicious! Thank you!!!”

“Great fun, food, and vibes!”

“This is a small town gem. They have a huge menu as well as daily specials. The wait staff is incredible. Definitely give Bigs a try, you will love your food.”

“My first time here on 2-24-25. Loved it. The place is so chill and relaxing. The two baristas working were very friendly and helpful. I was asking for an unknown coffee to them - a Café con leche, which is a Spanish expresso with steamed milk. They made it perfectly and the price was right. I’m sitting here now typing this and am so comfortable and relaxed that I don’t want to leave……😊. Come check them out. You won’t be disappointed. I’m from Fort Wayne but will be stopping in whenever I’m back n Columbia City, which is frequently. I can’t believe I haven’t stopped in previously.”

“Proud of my family, put blood, sweat, and tears into this family affair business. Food, entertainment good people ! Big shout out to Mel and other staff . Who doesn't want to go where everyone knows your name. Lol. Bar is cleanest bar ever ! Awesome job kids... ?”

“Yum! And the owners family was icing on the cake!”

“Good food at low prices. Good service and friendly atmosphere!”

“The ribs are awesome and love the fish”

“The best selection & the Greatest peach ice cream I have ever discovered.”

“Placed a delivery order with Papa John directly on 10/2. Shortly after the order was placed, was notified it was on the way via Door Dash. There was no way the order was ready that quickly. Dasher shows up and said that she verified this was my order and "they" confirmed it was mine, they must have put the wings orders in one box. She handed it to me and left. I looked at the label on the boxes and it was NOT my order at all. Wrong address, name, phone number! I managed to get a message to the Door Dash girl (again, I did not place my order through DD) to let her know and then called the store. The manager said I have your order in my hand and I only have one driver, as soon as he gets back, I'll send it to you. Could be 10 minutes, could be 30 minutes. Additionally, I reminded her to make sure the extras I ordered and paid for were delivered as well. Hopefully the other guy got his piping hot order! Mine was cold and wasted. An HOUR later, cold cheesebread, lukewarm wings, no extra sauce we're delivered. The driver says, "I heard you got the wrong order, here." To which I replied it is all cold and useless now. Called the store AGAIN and the manager answered. Told her it was cold and I am done with them.”

“I've been to THE INN since I was 18. The inside has changed little but the workers and the customers come and go. Except Charlie, she said she had been there for 40 years. The best cook is Charles. All are welcome, my favorite sandwich is the breaded tenderloin. The water is free and the beer is good. Ask for the ribs. Cooks all day and falls off the bone.”

“Their Campechano tacos are the best I’ve ever had. And the “hot” salsa was amazing. Nachos were generously covered!”

“We really enjoyed our pizza! We will be back.”

“My mom and I always try new places. Today we had the BEST experience we have had in a long time! The salad bar was super delicious! The service was OUTSTANDING!!! The teamwork between the bartender and server was perfection! Even the pre bussing was on point! Food was wonderful too! Wish I had their names so I could give them an even better shout out but they never said their names and no name tags! But GREAT JOB!”

“Food was delicious, but what really impressed me was our waitress (Bailey I think). She didn’t like the way our Mac & Cheese looked, so she had some new warmed up for us. She anticipated our needs, and was efficient, friendly, and just a pleasure to have serve us. It has been a while since we had been there, but we will be back!”

“This place is an absolute GEM, and everyone working there is so kind and helpful. Great coffee, great soup, awesome antiques and handmade items, a must-stop on your road trip!”

“The staff working tonight did a fantastic job when everyone from the SpongeBob musical showed up! Every employee kept their composure despite how busy they were. As always the food/ice cream was fantastic! Keep up the great work!!”

“Husband had this pizza years ago at a rural location. He completely forgot about it until seeing sign at a different location in another very rural area. I personally have never had it and I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza. It's one of my favorite foods. Well he suggested I try it because he remembers loving it over a decade ago. So I agreed and got a simple pepperoni pizza and then drove 15 mins home. Only cost $11.99 plus tax for a 12" Pizza which is cheapest pizza I've ever purchased. I had to rewarm it which made me hesitant on the quality. I was totally wrong. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN. First purchase for me was yesterday and today I went out and bought 2 more. Great dough, sauce, cheese the works. I will forever be a Hunt Brothers Pizza only..”