Pizza Uncommon

The pizza is delicious all the way down to the crust! I love the flavor of the dough. Their variety of toppings makes it a unique pizza experience. I also love their vegan chocolate chip cookies.

Fantastic pizza. You can tell they make it with care.

Short wait times. My pizza was ready within 30 minutes from the time I ordered it online.

I hope they don't get jaded from entitled, excessively negative reviewers, and continue producing quality pizza.

We visited the campus location and enjoyed 4 different kinds of pizza.

Great pizza with a good selection of unusual pops.

Outstanding pizza, possibly the best in Lafayette. This is not dorm room pizza. The menu is creative, featuring combinations you don't often see but which work quite well. Fig and prosciutto? Surprisingly good. Blackberries? Intriguing. They also have an extensive vegetarian and vegan selection. I generally prefer pizzas with plenty of meat, but even I find their vegetarian pizzas tempting. The food is also much less greasy than most others, which is nice, and keeps well for lunch the next day.

Some reviewers complain about a lack of toppings or sauce. While there are certainly other restaurants that use more sauce and toppings, I felt that the excellent bread and quality toppings made up for the lack of quantity. A little hot honey goes a long way! Besides, there are plenty of pictures on the menu, so you know what you are getting. It's also not the cheapest, but again this isn't dorm room pizza made with the cheapest factory produced ingredients. You're getting in-house sourdough bread, fresh mozzarella, goat cheese, prosciutto, and other premium ingredients. Don't act surprised that a Mercedes costs more than a Honda

My one real complaint is that they do use a third party delivery service, even when you order through their web site. I have rarely had a positive experience with either Uber Eats or Door Dash, so it is very disappointing. Go with dine-in or carry-out instead.

In summary, those looking for something cheap and vanilla will be disappointed but if you are looking for an uncommon treat, give them a look.

I’m quite the stickler when it comes to pizza. There will be no leftovers.

We got 3 different pies and they were all amazing! We will definitely be making this our go to pizza joint here in Westfield. So excited to welcome Pizza Uncommon to the area!

I discovered Pizza Uncommon in Madison earlier this year and was excited to see they have a location in Lafayette. It's an unfortunate distance off the interstate, but it's worth it for the best breadsticks. I ordered ahead online and my order was ready when I got there.

Excellent pizza!

Dietary restrictions: Lots of vegan options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Everything

Excellent pizza and outstanding gelato! There’s a wide variety of vegetarian and vegan options, including a great vegan cheese. We tried the Caprese pizza and vegan cheese sticks—both were fantastic. The campus location offers a really cool atmosphere to dine in.

Vegetarian options: Vegan and vegetarian

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great gluten free pizza and sticks. They only use rice flour inside their shop for everything so it's relatively safe for celiac.

Dietary restrictions: Gf gluten free

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Everything, Breadsticks

Crab Rangoon and thai chicken pizzas were amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab Rangoon Pizza

Delicious, great service 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

One of the best pizzerias in West Lafayette.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Everything

Delicious! I wish they had tap water available rather than bottled, as well as fountain drinks instead of bottles. Salad would be nice too. But the pizza and cheese bread are fantastic!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4