4.2
Good
248 Reviews
914 Oak Street, Kenova · 1.7 miles
Customers’ favorites
- Pepperoni Pizza with Mushrooms and Banana Peppers
- Double Jãlapenos Pepperoni and Bacon Pizza
- Pizza with Pepperoni Sausage and Mushrooms
- Pepperoni Italian Sausage Bacon Mushrooms
“Evaroni's in Kenova, West Virginia earns a 4-star rating. This remains a regional-worthy stop with a strong local identity and a long track record of delivering quality food, even though the restaurant has noticeably declined from its previous peak. The biggest strength is still the food. Evaroni's has built its reputation around straightforward, satisfying Italian-American fare, with its pizza being particularly distinctive. A defining feature is the restaurant's signature sweet pizza sauce, which gives the pizza a noticeably different flavor profile from a traditional savory or acidic tomato sauce. It is an important part of what makes Evaroni's recognizable and gives the restaurant something genuinely distinctive within the local pizza scene. Much of the restaurant's longstanding appeal remains intact. The portions are generous, the flavors are familiar, and the overall experience still feels rooted in the kind of old-school regional restaurant that people return to for years. That said, the quality is not quite where it once was. Compared with previous visits, there has been a noticeable drop in consistency and overall execution. The food is still very good, but it no longer feels as reliably excellent as it did at its best. That decline is enough to keep it from pushing into a higher tier, but not severe enough to erase what Evaroni's continues to do well. The atmosphere remains part of the appeal. Evaroni's still has the character of a long-standing local institution, and that history gives the restaurant a sense of place that newer competitors cannot easily replicate. Overall, Evaroni's remains one of the stronger dining options in the Kenova area. Its distinctive sweet pizza sauce, local identity, and continued food quality keep it firmly within the regional-worthy category, even if the restaurant is no longer operating at the level it once did. Worth the miles.”
Chinese · $
