16 Best Pizza Restaurants near Guthrie

“Stopped at Tiny Town Produce for the first time today and immediately added it to the list my favorite spots! Their flower selection was amazing and their flowers and plants were gorgeous and very well taken care of! The staff was very knowledgeable and able to give advice and genuinely seemed to love their job! Already looking forward to going back!“

“Stop by for the first time today and will be coming back! We ordered the cheese sticks, house salad, and wings. Everything was fresh and oh so delicious 🤤“

“It was one week ago today that we had a bunch of hangy tired teenagers and we were passing through Mobile, AL at lunchtime. We pulled into Godfather's Pizza in Tillman' Corned, AL outside of Mobile 5 min before buffet ended. I gave the manager a pass and told him we would happily go somewhere else if we were too late for the buffet. Steve would hear none of this! He told me to unload everyone and come eat. We weren't all even finished ordering before it ended and they were totally amazing about. They cooked every off the wall pizza we asked for and did it all with patience and smiles. They were actually happy we were there. I love it when I can eat great pizza AND give money to kind and awesome people. Can't wait to go back. #godfatherspizza #stayclassy #bestpizza #legendaryservice #customers4life“

“Yesterday we ordered pizzas from this restaurant. And it is by far the best tasting pizza we have had in a long time. We will definitely be back.“

“Awesome Food and people great atmosphere“

“I love going to the Gyro House. Their gyros are obviously delicious. Their pizzas are incredibly good. I just tried the loaded lamb fries and they are heaven (ask to add banana peppers!). The staff are so friendly. We have been several times and have never had a bad experience. Heck we’ve never had a mediocre experience! It’s always been great. Fast friendly and delicious. We are grateful to have the Gyro House to look forward to on nights I don't want to cook!“

“We always love dates at Old Chicago! Verda was our server, was upbeat, perky and did a great job. Food was excellent too!“

“Great experience for the children!! Good food!“

“I am not pleased with my order today 7/7/2025. I called for the 8 dollar 2 topping pizzas [ I verbally asked for the 8 dollar pizzas and he stated that it was the 2 topping larger pizzas]only to drive there and pay an 3 dollars per pizza and when I tried to explain to the manager[black lady] on duty she cuts me off and continued to ring up my order while stating the obvious that their prices have gone up. I will not be back“

“Our PTO used Fazolis for Back To School Night to feed our amazing teachers and it DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!! So much food for such an amazing price! The staff and management were so easy to work with, so friendly, and very helpful with loading it all up too. Lots of great feedback from the teachers for the variety and the amount of food. No one was left hungry! Highly recommend their catering option for large events! You all are amazing!! THANK YOU!!!!“

“Carried out an awesome small pizza to share with my wife for lunch. We drove across town for home and the aroma was so tempting. We devoured that sucker! So very,very good! The restaurant was quiet when I came in to order. The service was great and everything was nice and clean (I did use the facilities also). Highly recommended!“

“Placed my order at 11:23, Pizza was at my door at 11:43, exactly 20 minutes. The store is about a 10 minute drive from my house. Not sure how they made it and got it to me that fast but it's super fresh and tastes great. Always a good experience ordering here.“

“Best crust around!! Amazing“

“Didn't want to cook so we opted for pizza. Then didn't get pizza, LOL. I got the Philly cheesesteak sandwich, he got the bacon cheddar ranch sandwich, and we split the sandwiches so we both got a half of each. Also got some tots and the cookie brownie. I did enjoy those sandwiches.“

“Huge shout out to Papa John's on Wilma and our delivery driver tonight! He was earlier than expected do we werent even paying attention. He waited for 10 MINUTES for us to to come to the door! We greatly appreciate his patience! And the food was still hot and amazing!“

“5 stars for the exceptional service received! Ordered food to the hotel and not only did they have all my drinks and sauces but what stood out was the additional paper plates, stack of napkins, and even the packets of seasoning they added to my order that I didnt ask for. That's how you go above and beyond!“