23 Best Pizza Restaurants in Paducah

“Sweetest girl behind the counter, I would give her five stars came in to get my order that I placed online. The sirens were going off. She had a 30 pizza order before all of ours and she just kept apologizing and she was so nice and I think you should recognize her for her kindness and excellent customer service. 5/16/25 And my pizza was delicious 👍🏻“

“I love this place! So fun, super affordable and definitely made for you and your family!!!“

“First time here, won't be the last. True Italian fare for sure. I had a pizza and it was definitely authentic classic Italian. I've never had a New York style pizza but it was delicious. Light airy crust with a perfect crisp. Sauce was phenomenal. Toppings were fresh.“

“Absolutely by far the best pizza in Paducah!! Maybe best in Kentucky! Jeff is an artist!! Love their thin crust! I keep it simple. Bacon and tomato on a ranch base! The only problem is once you’ve had their pizza everywhere else is disappointing! I strongly suggest you give it a try.“

“Best subs in Paducah ❤️ and the pizza is great too! I love Italian Village!“

“We stopped by at 5:30 pm on 4th of July before the fireworks celebration & no problem getting a table. The service was good & we enjoyed our time there! We had the Chicken gorgonzola pasta & the Bone in Pork Chops - which were both very good & perfect serving sizes! They out did themselves on the desserts (creme brulee & bread pudding). We will definitely return again♥️“

“we ate 6 29 24 at 330 pm . the place was filthy and hot . the hostass didn't speak left to clean a table and never came back . finally another hostess setted us . the food ordered came out 25 minutes different for the 2 orders. the manager didn't care. Larry simply went and set at bar and laughed with friends. its a shame to see the cluster that restaurant is in . the food was good once we got it. so bad none extinct management. we have eaten at Gatlinburg and bowling Green. both were 5 star... Paducah needs new management and a good cleaning. we like the food but the atmosphere was zero hot un organized. nasty ... SAD“

“This is NOT a restaurant this is a hucks gas station however godfathers pizza IS FREAKIN FANTASTIC!!!!! Like for some gas station pizza it's top notch! I'd rather eat from this gas station than go to some of the pizza places we have around here.“

“I ordered 2 LG Meat Lovers to be delivered about 2 miles down the road, a hour and 25 minutes later we got our pizza at Beautiful Nails. Our guy was awesome and was very deserving of our generous tip!!! He was so kind and so apologetic and the pizza was awesome as usual ? We will order again and hope we get the same delivery guy ❤️“

“What an awesome place!! Read and reviews and had to check it out and YEAH, place is GREAT! Had the wings and meatball sandwich which both were awesome! Service, and I'm sorry I forgot the thing lady, she was excellent! Love the history and the decorations are a touch back in time 👍👍😊“

“I work here. But also eat out with my family here. Some of us enjoy the pizza while the rest might want chicken or cheeseburger. We have a huge variety to choose from amd getting bigger by the day. I love the chicken bacon ranch pizza and the ranch cheesesticks. I'm not much of a pizza person. I typically get tenders and mash potatoes.

Kid-friendliness: Most time there are stickers or little games at the front desk for the kiddos. We have child menus and lots of candies and toys for purchase.

Wheelchair accessibility: Handicapped restroom, slanted sidewalk for wheelchair use and extra large handicapped accessible restrooms.“

“The Southside Paducah Papa Johns is the best. I called in an order, the Employee on the phone was great, repeated my order back to me, suggested other items, and just seemed to care about doing her job correctly. My Pizza was delivered on time, Hot, Accurate and actually looked as good as the picture.“

“This location never disappoints. Papa johns is pricier but you really do pay for what you get and they always have coupons available. Food is always top notch, delivery drivers are always friendly, food always arrives sooner than promised, and the few times I’ve gone for carryout or to pick up a doordash order, everyone has been so friendly and welcoming.
Yall also have the best local stuffed crust, brownies, AND garlic sauce. Thank you so much for always coming in clutch. ?“

“Our server was great , he was very attentive & gave great recommendations. Food was very good & great portion size. Will definitely be back“

“great atmosphere, music, food & staff. grateful for the role they play in our community“

“I don't have to worry if my pizza is going to be Hot and Fresh.
It's been that way everytime. A big issue when I have gone to other restaurants and paid $$ for a meal that's been under a heat lamp for a min..So I make sure to Thank the Management and Driver's whether I pick it up or have it delivered..

Vegetarian options: They have vegetarian pizzas..“

“They were busy the day I went and ordered the food took a little longer than I wished but it wasn't from their lack of effort. I loved their pizza amazing flavor great crust not doughy but not thin. Highly recommend just call in your order first unlike me.“

“Driving through from out of town. They were super busy and the wait was a little long but their kindness and respect to customers was heartwarming. Despite being busy they helped people to their car with their food and opened doors for people.“

“Such polite and energetic staff!!“

“They get busy at certain times. But, when the line is short it's only take a couple minutes to get some pizza and cheese sticks to feed the family. Where else you gonna feed a family of 4 for $20?“

“OMG I ordered the stuffed crust for the first time and it was, kid you not, the best. I was skeptical because last time I ordered from them I asked for well done and square cut and got neither request. This time the crust was perfectly crispy on the outside and airy on the inside. The square cuts were perfect for little sandwiches. Also, I have to admit their staff are the best no matter when you go. Always polite and friendly. Good job everyone!“

“Great service, very hospitable, would stop in again on my travels through“

“This dominos is AWESOME! We always have a HUGE order. Our food has always been exactly what was ordered, hot, and the delivery drivers are very kind and professional. This is becoming very rare at establishments nowadays. My family appreciates the employees and all their hard work. Thank you!!“