13 Best Italian Restaurants in Lafayette

“We went in Saturday without a reservation and lucked out with the last table available. I love the atmosphere. I appreciate the good wine choices and had a great glass of Malbec. Our entrees were excellent. We had pizza and the special of the night. Service was excellent and we will certainly be back!
Reminder all bread is made in-house and to die for!

Vegetarian options: I am not a Vegetarian but try to have two - three plus days of only veggies per week. There are plenty of pasta and vegi options or pizza or calzones and ingredients are of high quality!“

“Went today for a late lunch. This was our first visit and definitely not our last. Our server Jessica went above and beyond to make our first experience the best we ever had. Food was amazing! The GM Lupe even came visit with us at our table. Best dining experience we have ever had!“

“Our team had a wonderful lunch at Marcello’s a few weeks ago, and Riley Comeaux made the experience exceptional. She was attentive, knowledgeable, and personable. Riley took the time to explain all the specials in detail and made sure we were well taken care of throughout the meal, always checking in to ensure everything was perfect. Her professionalism and friendly attitude really stood out. Highly recommend her if you're dining at Marcello's!“

“THE FOOD AND SERVICE IS ALWAYS TOP TIER ME AND MY CHILDREN LOVE IT HERE!!!

Vegetarian options: Menu is labeled for vegetarian options

Dietary restrictions: The server can help with any dietary restrictions

Parking: Parking around the whole building

Kid-friendliness: GREAT KIDS MENU OPTIONS

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it is“

“Great staff and friendly !! Lillian was the best waitress!!!“

“The food and service is outstanding!“

“From the moment I stepped inside I was enveloped in an atmosphere of pure elegance. The soft ambient lighting, tasteful décor, and hushed conversations created an intimate yet refined setting, perfect for a memorable evening. The service was impeccable—attentive yet unobtrusive, with every detail meticulously attended to. The staff’s knowledge of the menu and wine pairings was impressive, guiding us through a culinary journey that felt both personalized and indulgent. ❣️“

“Great foods excellent Very quiet“

“The best pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life“

“Authentic Italian food. Loved the chicken parmesan. Our 8 yr old son got the cheese pizza and spaghetti with meatball. His two favorite foods. He is very picky about taste and loved them both. We found out new place for Italian food!!

Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free“

“Every now and then when we visit Lafayette, we sometimes come here. And the food is always good when we go! I don’t need you to see pics of that. What you need pics of are the air vents. When I see stuff like this it makes me wonder what the kitchen looks like, if things are being sanitized properly. Right when you walk in, you see these vents. You also see the bar and maybe you’re hoping that is big and bright enough to distract from the grossness of all surrounding areas, including the floors. Please don’t neglect your vents any longer!“

“I've been here a handful of times and the service here never disappoints. Tonight was a surprise with live music and a relaxing atmosphere. This is a great place for date nights. Especially if you want a nice place for drinks and pizza. The appetizers and food is really good too. If you want pizza I highly recommend here. Especially if you want cauliflower crust pizza. Sooooo good!?“

“The pizza was so great that it brought me to italy, but let the food cool down because the pizza is served molted hot that the cheese slides down!

Kid-friendliness: There was disney channle so 100000+ points for kid friendliness, but adult swift was also on a TV but dragon ball was playing so still kid friendly“