15 Best Italian Restaurants near Brewster

“Awesome food, atmosphere, and fabulous service!!!!“

“Laurinos is a go to restaurant when you want something for everyone! Some favorites: Big Mac pizza w/cauli-crust, wedge salad, tasty burger, fish sammy, veggie quesadilla, steak tips & music on Monday!“

“Excellent dinners! Good service. Beautifully decorated inside...so Italy! Highly recommend!“

“The entire experience was amazing. Especially our waitress Ashley. She made our whole experience that much more special. Food was on point, and delicious. We’ll be back for sure“

“I never write reviews, but I felt I had to this time. I never would have stopped here as it looks like a hole in the wall, but a woman we met at a bar told us how good it was. It was one of the best meals we've ever had, at the Cape and at home in CT (and we have great Italian food at home!). \n\nMy husband got the meatball app. The server, Aita, said it was ranked the best on the Cape, and my husband agreed (and he's had them everywhere). I got the haddock milanese over risotto, and he got the short rib ragu over pappardelle, and we shared bites. They were both amazing, and we have leftovers for tomorrow. We'll be back, no doubt!“

“Our table was ready when we arrived. Our server was attentive, friendly and knowledgeable. We shared a couple apps - one on special that wasn't anything great but also the charcuterie board which was very tasty! We ordered the Marsala, Parm and Steak and all were delicious! We brought leftovers home and decided on cocktails for dessert. Will definitely be back!“

“The service, Nora and Billy behind the bar, is outstanding. Warm, caring, fun. Drinks and food are great. So welcoming! ❤️“

“Fantastic special menu! The Veal chop was amazing in presentation and delicious! See the review at @GalPals Gourmet Grub Guide“

“Great food, friendly atmosphere“

“I have been to Montebello twice now. I sat at the bar with 3 other people both times. We all ordered various pasta dishes with chicken, and one other ordered pizza. All of us enjoyed the food! In addition, the complimentary bread and bread dip, were very good. Also, the side salads were small, but fresh and quite good! The bartender Nicholas was polite and very efficient! Drinks were very good as well! We all found the ambience of the bar and the room surrounding the bar quite nice! Based on our combined experiences at Montebello, I (we) would highly recommend it!“

“Great little spot for pizza, meatball sub, darts, and pool. Food was great, staff were excellent! Highly recommend this place.“

“It is out go to place when friends and family are in town because there is something for everyone and the food is consistently delicious. Our waitress this last visit was new to serving and she was really nice. Thank you for serving us Silviane.“

“Going down hill, pizza to me used to be good, I got a pizza the other day wasn’t cooked, hardly no meat on it, might be time to move on to a new place“

“Joey at Paradise created pre - wedding specialty wraps and grinders for my grandaughter's wedding on 9 / 27 - We chose the wraps - from a varied menu - were fresh and delicious served on the many different colored wraps - tomato basil - spinach and many more - The presentation was colorful and lovely for the bridesmaids and bride - we also ordered large grinders for the grooms and again they were fresh and varied with more than generous portions - We recommend Paradise Pizza without reservation of any kind - polite service - all that was promised and more - Sheila Leonard - Worcester Ma and West Dennis Ma“

“Ordered takeout last night. Mushroom,Swiss burgers,medium. Absolutely the best.... Perfectly cooked burger,yummy mushrooms with a surprise of bacon,gooey Swiss cheese,the best. Fries and pickle perfect compliment. Nice job Yardam cooking staff. We'll be back!“