26 Best Italian Restaurants near Barnstable

“Love the food excellent service great atmosphere!!!“

“We head to the Cape fairly regularly during the summer and this is the only place that is a true MUST every time. Never had a bad meal or experience. Management and ownership really do a great job! Customer for life here“

“The pizza was good. For a mall pizza place this pie was hitting good. I will say it reminds me of papa Gino’s Pizza tangy sauce, the cheese, the smell, even the dough reminded me of Papa Gino’s pizza. But it’s Regina Puzza and it was good. Looking for more reviews check out review time with Tim on YouTube.

Parking: Big mall parking lot

Kid-friendliness: Yes the kids will like this pizza

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes it’s in a mall“

“Sarah was a great waitress. She was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything came out quickly and exactly how we wanted it. She checked in at the right times without being overbearing and had such a positive attitude the whole time. Definitely made the experience better!!!“

“Wife & I bought a half tray of Chix-Parm for a dinner party...MEOW!!!! 'nuff food for 10...2 DIE 4..X-ra sauce 'n bread...again MEOW“

“Great Food Great Service will definitely be back“

“Stopped in for lunch while waiting on my appointment at the RMV and the perfectly crisp slices cured me of the despair induced by the morass of the RMV.

The best two slices of pizza I’ve had in recent memory - just a cheese and margherita but it made my day. Will definitely come back next time I’m on the Cape. Worth the drive from Barnstable for sure.“

“A wonderful ambience, welcoming, professional staff, excellent food/drinks and reasonable competitive prices. The atmosphere and professionalism exceeded that of other comparable area restaurants. A dining experience- not just a meal“

“My daughter and I discovered this gem last year on our annual visit to the Cape. Our waitress then was the lovely Ayta, and we were fortunate to have her again this year both times we ate there. She is so genuine and personable, with a vast knowledge of the menu. I couldn't resist having the chicken picatta with risotto cakes twice simply because it is just excellent. We certainly plan on a return visit next year, and hope Ayta will still be there.“

“What a Fantastic place ‼💯🤩 The Osso Buco , Eggplant Rollatini,Chicken Francaise were perfect . Dario provided exceptional service and even the music created an unforgettable dining experience. Will be back many more times in the years ahead for this extraordinary restaurant.“

“Crisp never lets me down. Excellent flatbreads and quick friendly service. Scallop and bacon and short ribs are the favorites but you can never go wrong at Crisp!!! Give it a try, it will become your new favorite place for takeout.“

“My family and I went here for Thanksgiving. It was such a wonderful experience and made a special day even better. Everything from the food to the service was impeccable. Thank you so much for a wonderful experience!“

“Everything was excellent from the service to the food. We all got the four course dinner and I cannot say enough. It was amazing!“

“The Shrimp Diavolo is amazing! The entire dish was prepared just right and the bread was also great. I highly recommend this restaurant when on the Cape.“

“Great little spot for pizza, meatball sub, darts, and pool. Food was great, staff were excellent! Highly recommend this place.“

“We took our family of 8 for dinner. Host was very accommodating as I did not call ahead for a reservation of a large party. Once seated the service was impeccable. Host was very good with our 2 year old grandson. Food was absolutely amazing. Can’t say enough about Four Seasons. Thank you for a wonderful dining experience.“

“I have been to Montebello twice now. I sat at the bar with 3 other people both times. We all ordered various pasta dishes with chicken, and one other ordered pizza. All of us enjoyed the food! In addition, the complimentary bread and bread dip, were very good. Also, the side salads were small, but fresh and quite good! The bartender Nicholas was polite and very efficient! Drinks were very good as well! We all found the ambience of the bar and the room surrounding the bar quite nice! Based on our combined experiences at Montebello, I (we) would highly recommend it!“

“We always sit at the bar to eat, need to definitely get there early for the bar seat because they do fill up fast. Food, atmosphere, service and drinks are top knotch. The Antipasto Salad to share with 2 people is more than enough. Any of the seafood specials do not disappoint or the desserts...there is always room for a taste of dessert to share with friends to end the night.
Enjoy“

“It is out go to place when friends and family are in town because there is something for everyone and the food is consistently delicious. Our waitress this last visit was new to serving and she was really nice. Thank you for serving us Silviane.“

“Fantastic special menu! The Veal chop was amazing in presentation and delicious! See the review at @GalPals Gourmet Grub Guide“

“We have been coming to Cape Cod every year since 2017 and staying at our timeshare at The Cove, and I cannot express how happy we are to have The Sunset Restaurant right across the street!

Over the years, this has become one of those places we truly look forward to visiting every time we come back. The staff is always incredibly friendly, welcoming, and makes you feel right at home. The food is consistently delicious, with great portions and that wonderful homemade feel. My wife especially loves the home fries! 😋

This year, I also want to give a special thank you to Kay. We wish you nothing but the very best on your journey ahead, and we sincerely hope to see you again when we return next year.

Thank you to everyone at The Sunset Restaurant for always being part of our Cape Cod vacation memories. After coming here year after year since 2017, it truly feels like one of our traditions. Highly recommended! ❤️☀️🍳“

“Great team, great service, great food. Excellent dining experience. Keep up the awesome!!“

“one of the greatest places we have been to in a long time. would definitely recommend eating here, everything was great, no complaints. definitely 5 stars.“

“Best pizza I have ever had!!! I couldn’t believe how quickly we got our pizza! My twins are very picky about pizza and couldn’t believe we have never heard of the is place! The owner said he has owned it almost 50 years! Definitely recommend it. I will only be going to this pizza place from now on!“

“Decided to try another local spot for dinner. Checked out their menu a head of time and their daily special of chicken pie and other specials seemed like a winner. We ordered 2 chicken pie dinners which came with a garden salad and mashed potato and butternut squash. The pie was very flavorful with a light flaky shell. The butternut squash was flavorful without being overly sweet or spiced. The mashed potato’s were homemade and lacked a little spice. Also ordered the fried scallops which she said were very flavorful And tender. We’ll definitely be coming back here again. These prices were very reasonable. $55 for our 3 meals.“

“Wonderful service. So accommodating...I had my children and grandchildren with me for Mother's Day and needed a little space from the band. Kevin went out of the way to provide a little private spot for us so we could enjoy the Grab Brothers and still attend to the younger ones. Food was amazing...everyone enjoyed every morsel. Cannot say enough“